NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request
Grail Bio UK Ltd · Commercial
In term In term in the September 2026 edition: the latest version runs to 29 March 2030.
- Reference
- DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L
- Current version
- v7.2
- Term of current version
- 24 October 2025 to 29 March 2030
- Start date
- 9 February 2022
- Data controller
- Joint Data Controller
- Commercial purposes
- Yes
- Sublicensing
- No
- Files released to date
- 140
Data controllers
Why the data was released
Objective for processing
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and Queen Mary University London (QMUL), as joint Controllers, are requesting access to NHS England pseudonymised record-level Data in order to carry out follow-up analysis based on a cohort of patients who were recruited to a clinical trial called ‘NHS-Galleri’ following being invited to participate if they were found to meet the required eligibility criteria.
Note that members of the team running the trial are based at the Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) at QMUL. For the sake of consistency, and as QMUL is listed as a Controller, when referring to QMUL throughout the application, this encompasses the team at CPTU from QMUL.
A new Multi-Cancer Early Detection (MCED) test has been developed that can detect many types of cancer from a single blood sample. This test is called Galleri (Registered Trademark). This trial aims to find out whether it is better at detecting cancer early, compared to other tests that the NHS currently uses. The purpose of NHS-Galleri is to demonstrate the clinical utility of the MCED blood test for individuals in a general screening population in a real world NHS setting. The rationale behind this trial is that MCED is a novel screening paradigm, and assessment of the use and impact of test results is necessary to enable integration into clinical practice. This will be the first randomised, double blind, controlled trial statistically powered to assess clinical utility of a MCED test.
Recruitment to the trial has been aided by NHS England's DigiTrials team via a sister Data Sharing Agreement (DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H) and took place over 10 – 12 months from August 2021 with a recruitment target of 140,000 people. Recruitment successfully completed and the target was met. Different geographic areas were targeted for recruitment, beginning with North-West England. Recruitment in a particular area lasted for 4 – 6 weeks, before moving on to another area. Recruitment was managed through mobile units on scheduled routes around a particular area. Batches of invitations were constructed to target whatever area the mobile units were in at the time of writing out to potential participants. Potential participants were only contacted once and there were no follow-ups sent after the original invitation letter.
Requesting Not to Take Part in Trial:
In addition to the National Data Opt-out, members of the public were able to specifically request not to be contacted for the NHS-Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd promoted this information via the dedicated trial website (nhs-galleri.org) and NHS England did the same via a dedicated page on its website (https://digital.nhs.uk/services/nhs-digitrials/nhs-galleri-trial). There was also an option for people to register their request not to take part in NHS-Galleri by telephone. NHS England records these requests not to take part and ensure that anyone who has registered for this will be excluded from the cohort selection and as a result their details will not be on the list for invitations to be sent.
• Primary Objective of the NHS-Galleri Trial:
- For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual test and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a. For a prespecified group of cancer types, including lung, head and neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver / bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary and bladder.
b. For all cancer types, excluding prostate cancer.
c. For all cancer types.
• Secondary Objectives of the NHS-Galleri Trial:
1) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of advanced cancers (defined as a cancer diagnosed at stage III or IV or one that results in a cancer-specific death) in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a) First, evaluate for a statistically significant difference in a prespecified group of primary cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
b) If a statistically significant reduction in absolute numbers is found, continue by evaluating for a difference in all cancer types excluding prostate cancer.
c) If the above evaluations are both significant, evaluate for a difference in all cancer types.
2) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a difference in the proportion of stage I and II cancers between the two arms of the study in the third testing round (i.e. for cancers diagnosed with an average 16-18 months of follow-up after the third test).
3) Evaluate the performance (overall sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three intervals of testing.
4) Evaluate the safety, including harms, of the testing pathway in the intervention arm among individuals with positive MCED test results.
a) Assess participant-reported anxiety among those receiving a positive MCED test result following the initial blood draw at various time points.
b) Examine the radiation exposure by participants associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures following a positive MCED test result
c) Describe the number and type of invasive procedures performed, and number of complications and deaths associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures.
5) Determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following the initial screening round and 12 months of follow-up (excluding cancers identified by the test performed at the 12-month visit)
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer;
c) For all cancer types.
6) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer
c) For all cancer types.
7) Determine whether there is a statistically significant difference in cancer detection rates in the two arms of the study with 12 months follow-up after the first test.
8) Model the expected differences in cancer-specific mortality at 7 years post-randomisation based on cancers diagnosed within an average of 40-42 months of randomisation.
9) Summarize stage distribution per cancer type for the two arms, and compare the absolute numbers of stage IV alone as well as stage III and IV cancers, following the third screening and an average 16-18* months of follow-up.
10) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers, excluding breast, cervical, and colorectal (i.e., those without a standard of care screening modality) as compared to the control arm following the third annual screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up.
11) Assess the impact on cancer-specific mortality:
a) (Endpoint powered) Assess the potential for avoidance/postponement of cancer death by comparing the rates of death from cancer with-specific mortality rates among individuals receiving a positive MCED test at any of the 3 screening rounds in the intervention arm with that among individuals retrospectively testing positive at any of the 3 screening rounds in the control arm, at 3 years after the last study visit (retrospectively testing all samples from cancer deaths in the control arm).
b) (Endpoint not powered) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms for all cancer types at a) 3 years and b) 6 years after the last study visit.
12) Compare the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers following the second blood draw and 12 months of follow-up, with prevalent cases excluded.
13) Compare the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers following the third blood draw and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, with cases from the first and second screenings excluded.
14) Assess the impact of use of the MCED test across three annual timepoints on healthcare resource utilization for cancer diagnosis and treatment.
15) Assess the potential impact of overdiagnosis by comparing the cumulative incidence (Kaplan-Meier curves) of cancers diagnosed after a positive baseline MCED test up to 36-48 months after randomization between the intervention and control arms (retrospectively testing baseline samples from all participants diagnosed with cancer in the control arm).
NHS ENGLAND DATA SETS REQUESTED:
> NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations
> NDRS Cancer Registry
> NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT)
> NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS)
> NDRS Linked Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC)
> NDRS Linked HES Outpatients (OP)
> NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) (Treatments and Referrals)
> NDRS Linked Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) (provided Summer 2022 onward)
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) (provided Summer 2022 onward)
FREQUENCY - every 6 months beginning March 2022 (Rapid Registrations every 2 months from March 2022).
FROM AUGUST 2022 (Version 2 of this Data Sharing Agreement)) - Frequency of drops
> NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) - no change
> NDRS Linked HES APC - no change
> NDRS Linked HES Outpatients (OP) - no change
> NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) (Treatments and Referrals) - no change
> NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS) – No change
> NDRS Linked Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> NDRS Linked Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations - Rapid Registrations will be provided every month rather than every two months from August 2022 to enable frequent monitoring of cancer diagnoses in the study.
> NDRS Cancer Registry - will be provided every month rather than every other month from August 2022 to enable frequent reporting of cancer diagnoses in the study and use the data as a filter for participant invitations for annual follow up timepoints. Expand historic gold standard registration field selection for 1995-2021 and addition of field to allow the trial team to distinguish provisional from finalised gold standard tumours. These changes are required for primary and secondary analysis. Data will be used to characterize the cohort for risk factors (prior cancers), and also assess test performance in a subpopulation of cancer survivors. The Status of Registration is required to enable accurate reporting and filtering of provisional data vs finalized data to internal and external stakeholders, and the interim analysis in the study. Death fields added to dataset specification for analysis of key secondary endpoints in the study. Death Data will also be used for reporting subject disposition in the analysis. Death Data, while requested with the Cancer Registry Data, should include information on all participants in the cohort (including participants that have not been diagnosed with cancer).
JUSTIFICATION FOR DATA SETS REQUESTED AND DATA MINIMISATION
> Cancer Registry and Rapid Registrations - These central NHS England datasets will be the sole source for the data required for primary and secondary objectives analyses in the study. They will be used to identify Primary endpoints, which are incidence and stage at diagnosis for cancer types that are stage-able (e.g., with available staging systems). Cancer is defined as any of the following cancers:
- Invasive solid cancer, excluding non-melanoma skin cancer
- Haematologic malignancies, including lymphoma, lymphoid leukemia, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, myeloid neoplasms (including myelodysplastic and myeloproliferative neoplasms with behaviour code 3 based on ICD-O-3.2*).
[*The International Classification of Diseases for Oncology, Third Edition (ICD-O-3) is the standard classification system for the registration of cancers in the United States (and most areas of the world) and contains widely-accepted histologic categories of brain tumors.]
The Cancer Registry will also be used to identify cohort characteristics/baseline risk - Personal history of cancer assessed using limited set of data fields. Historical cancer data dating back to 1995 will be available.
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Outpatients (OP), Admitted Patient Care (APC) and Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS), Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT) and Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Will be used to identify Secondary endpoints (including safety objectives). Among all test positive cases, number of follow-up procedures and number of invasive procedures (including all biopsies, surgical interventions, bronchoscopy, thoracoscopy and endoscopy) to achieve diagnostic resolution (i.e. cancer diagnosis, non-cancer diagnosis, or no diagnosis and discharge from the diagnostic follow-up). Will also identify:
- Number and type of invasive procedures performed in false positive cases;
- Number of complications and deaths resulting from diagnostic procedures;
- Radiation exposure measured in mSv per participant due to test result-directed evaluations
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) and Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS) will also be used (in addition to the above HES, CWT and DIDs data) for health care resource utilization objectives.
The NHS-Galleri trial has the following Secondary Objective: "Evaluate the performance (overall episode sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three rounds."
Participants who have had cancer prior to enrolment may be at risk of a recurrence. Previous research has demonstrated the Galleri MCED is capable of detecting cancer recurrence (1). As NDRS registers primary cancers (and not cancer recurrences), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are keen to establish when there is evidence that a patient has had a recurrence of their cancer. This is to complete a sensitivity analysis for the Positive Predictive Value (PPV) of the test in which the detection of a recurrence will be considered a True Positive (this is in contrast to the main analysis in which, because there is no new cancer registration, it is considered a False Positive). GRAIL Bio UK Ltd believe this analysis will help provide a more complete description of test performance.
(1) Schrag D, et al. Presentation at European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) Congress; September 9-13, 2022.
For the purposes of this analysis, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd will share the Study IDs of a small number of consented NHS-Galleri participants with NHS England for review as to whether these participants have a cancer recurrence. NHS England will convert the study IDs into internal patient IDs and provide an expert clinical review of each case to determine whether a patient has a recurrence. NHS England will do this based on the NDRS Datasets already listed in this Data Sharing Agreement.
***************************
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPI&E)
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to develop the participant facing materials and on questionnaires, and including specific questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised Data with GRAIL Inc (US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials, survey feedback on the participant experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in QMUL's Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (previously located at King’s College London) has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trial, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously strategies for equity of access and taken steps to ensure that under-represented minorities were actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, which identified and actively sent invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
UK GDPR Legal Basis for the Processing of Personal Data:
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as joint Controller, is using Article 6(1)(f) "processing is necessary for the purposes of the legitimate interests pursued by the controller or by a third party except where such interests are overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject which require protection of Personal Data, in particular where the data subject is a child." Processing Personal Data is necessary for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd’s legitimate interests which are described in this application. The Data to which access is requested are proportionate and necessary to achieve those interests. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has completed a legitimate interests assessment (LIA) and are satisfied that the interests of the data subjects do not override their legitimate interests; that they would reasonably expect the processing and it would not cause unjustified harm. The data subjects interests and fundamental rights are protected through appropriate minimisation of fields and patient records being processed; protection of the Data in a secure environment, and guaranteeing secure destruction at any stage at the request of NHS England and/or after a defined period on completion of the project.
Additionally (as health Data is a special category of Personal Data), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd is using Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
QMUL, as joint Controller, is using Article 6:1(e): Specific task in the ‘public interest’ or task that has a clear basis in law, and additionally (as health Data is a special category of Personal Data) Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
Organisation Roles and Responsibilities:
• GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are a joint Controller and Lead for this DSA, who also process the Data. It is responsible for sponsoring and funding the trial, as well as the building and maintenance of the Clinical Records Management System.
• QMUL are a joint Controller who also process the Data and are responsible for implementing the trial and for primary objective analysis. The Principal Investigator and the Cancer Prevention Trial Unit (CPTU) are based at QMUL.
• GRAIL Inc. is the manufacturer of the MCED test, Galleri (Registered Trademark), and has set up the above UK subsidiary, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, which is the sponsor of the NHS-Galleri trial. GRAIL Inc. will be receiving pseudonymised record-level NHS England Data from GRAIL BIO UK Ltd, and are therefore listed as a Processor in this DSA.
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS England therefore do not consider them to be a Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that QMUL's Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS England therefore do not consider them to be a Controller.
In the future, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd may receive commercial benefit (including intangible or indirect commercial benefits such as positive publicity) from the successful outcomes of the trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and the NHS have entered into a partnership whereby the Galleri test will be piloted in clinical trials within the NHS in England. If the test is shown to work as intended in these clinical trials, the NHS may purchase the test from GRAIL and make the test routinely available in the future to benefit patient.
Processing activities
Patient Identifiable Data (PID) referred to in section 5a (above) will be stored in the Clinical Records Management System (“CRMS”) hosted on Amazon Web Service (AWS UK). NHS England record-level pseudonymised Data referred to in section 5a (above) will be stored in a secure S3 folder (S3 is a type of file storage system in a cloud platform) hosted on Amazon Web Service (AWS UK).
METHODOLOGY
1. The PID referenced in the cohort will be securely transferred from the CRMS as an encrypted dataset (AES 256) to Arrow Business Communications Limited (ARO)'s sFTP server. From there, QMUL downloads the cohort into ARO's Trusted Research Environment (TRE) and transfers to NHS England via the sFTP portal over Health and Social Care Network (HSCN). Data is stored on the ARO environment (for a maximum of 1 week for confirmation of successful receipt by NDRS before being deleted).
2. QMUL will provide a cohort of approximately 140,000 records (in total), including a pseudo-Study ID, plus the identifiers: NHS Number, Date of Birth, Sex and Post Code along with first recruitment date and withdrawal date (if applicable) to NHS England via a Secure Electronic File Transfer Service (SEFT) or other secure, NHS England approved file transfer mechanism.
3. An encryption key is sent from the QMUL team to the CRMS system for encrypting the dataset, allowing for the participants identified in that dataset to be flagged for following by NDRS. Only the QMUL team controls the ability to decrypt the dataset.
4. The NDRS team will use the identifiers to extract record-level pseudonymised Data and return the requested Data extracts to the ARO system operated by QMUL via SEFT or other secure, NHS England approved file transfer mechanism. All Data from NHS England will contain only the pseudo-study ID for linkage. All other personal identifiable Data will be removed prior to the transfer.
5. The QMUL team will download the resultant record-level pseudonymised data sets into the ARO environment and upload to Amazon Web Services S3 (UK Cloud platform) for analysis.
6. The QMUL team will access and analyse the NHS England Data held on the QMUL ARO environment via remote access using QMUL-owned devices.
7. Sub study analysis - Cancer Recurrences
- GRAIL Bio UK Ltd will share the Study IDs of a small number of consented NHS-Galleri participants with NHS England.
- NHS England will convert the study IDs into internal patient IDs and provide an expert clinical review of each case to determine whether a patient has a recurrence. NHS England will do this based on the NDRS Datasets already listed in this Data Sharing Agreement.
- NHS England will provide the following pseudonymised record-level data file to GRAIL Bio UK Ltd:
• Source of information for recurrence: (e.g. from pathology, imaging, COSD etc).
• Date of recurrence: defined as date associated with earliest source of information suggesting recurrence.
• Linked pseudo_id to primary tumour (where possible).
• Pseudonymised Study ID
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd have been made aware that this sub-study analysis is derived from clinical review and opinion undertaken by Data Analysists in the NHS England's NDRS Team.
***************************
STORAGE AND PROCESSING LOCATIONS
Amazon Web Services (AWS UK) supply IT infrastructure for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and are therefore listed as a Processor. They supply support to the system, but do not access Data. Therefore, any access to the data held under this DSA would be considered a breach of the DSA. This includes granting of access to the database[s] containing the Data. AWS UK use only UK data centres and provides a private cloud platform which hosts the Clinical Records Management System (“CRMS”) which was developed and is managed by GRAIL Bio UK Ltd. The record-level pseudonymised Data extracts referred to in section 3b and 5a of this Data Sharing Agreement will be stored in secure S3 folders which are hosted on Amazon Web Service (AWS UK). The PID will be stored separately in the CRMS. Only authorised study team members and substantive employees of GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and QMUL have access to NHS England record-level pseudonymised Data stored in the secure S3 folders hosted by AWS in the United Kingdom. Enrolled participants consented to the transfer and storage of their health Data to GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and QMUL for the purposes of processing the pseudonymised Data extracts for this DSA.
ARO supply IT infrastructure for QMUL's Trusted Research Environment and are therefore listed as a Processor. They supply a managed system, but do not access Data. Therefore, any access to the Data by ARO held under this DSA would be considered a breach of the DSA. They manage access to the file system with instruction from QMUL. Data is stored on the Trusted Research Environment (for agreed time-limited duration) both PID and pseudonymised and NDRS extract.
Amazon Web Services, Inc (USA) supply IT infrastructure for GRAIL Inc. and are therefore listed as a Processor. They supply support to the system, but do not access Data. Therefore, any access to the Data held under this DSA by Amazon Web Services, Inc. (USA) would be considered a breach of the DSA. This includes granting of access to the database[s] containing the Data. Enrolled participants also consent, as expressly stated in the consent form and participant information sheet, to the transfer of their pseudonymised health Data to GRAIL Inc. in the US for purposes permitted by the study participant consent form. The pseudonymised Data will be transferred by GRAIL Bio UK Ltd from the secure S3 folder hosted on Amazon Web Service (AWS UK) to a secure S3 folder hosted on Amazon Web Services, Inc. (USA). The transfer will be undertaken using a secure, encrypted network connection.
The NHS England pseudonymised record-level Data from the datasets referenced herein will be accessible only to those substantive employees with appropriate and authorized access at (i) GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, (ii) QMUL and (iii) GRAIL Inc. Record level pseudonymised Data will be stored in the secure AWS S3 folders (for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and GRAIL Inc.) and ARO TRE (for QMUL). QMUL are non-commercial collaborators and in order to provide academic independent analysis for scientific rigor of the study, it is necessary for QMUL to have an independent copy of the dataset in ARO TRE. Access to cloud systems where the statistical analysis is performed only from organisation owned/managed devices (whether QMUL, or GRAIL to ARO or AWS respectively). Statistical data analysis will be carried out on organisation-owned and managed devices, either directly in person or remotely, using an appropriate statistical package. To remotely access the devices requires a secure 2-factor authenticator (Virtual Private Network (VPN) and users are then able to securely access the server on the organisation's cloud platform. All data analysis will be conducted within the confines of the organisation's cloud platform, and Data will not be downloaded to remote devices for storage or processing.
An Independent Data Monitoring Committee (IDMC) will be utilized to assess the progress of the clinical study, the safety data, and key endpoints to provide recommendations to the study Sponsor on whether to continue, modify, or stop the study. The IDMC is intended to provide additional assurance of participant safety and study integrity. Members of the IDMC include a clinician(s) with expertise in relevant clinical specialties, and at least one biostatistician knowledgeable about statistical methods for clinical studies and sequential analysis of study data.
NHS England record-level Data may not be shared with other organisations or countries outside of those stated in this agreement (i.e. USA and UK). PID will be stored for 10 years following completion of the study and record-level pseudonymised Data will be stored for 10 years following completion of the study. All other research data will be stored for a period of 10 years following completion of the study in accordance with regulatory requirements (e.g. UK Policy Framework for Health and Social Care Research), data sharing agreements with NHS bodies, and in line with participant consent. Record-level NHS England Data may be linked with other datasets held by the Data Processors or Data Controllers on the understanding that the risk of re-identification is minimised and the linkage is undertaken expressly for the purpose of medical research. GRAIL Inc. is not permitted to attempt to re-identify individuals.
HES and ECDS DISCLOSURE CONTROL / SMALL NUMBER SUPPRESSION
In order to protect patient confidentiality, when presenting results calculated from HES record level data, outputs will contain only aggregate level data with small numbers suppressed in line with HES Analysis Guide. When publishing HES data, data processors must make sure that:
· National-level figures only may be presented unrounded, without small number suppression
· cell values from 1 to 7 (inclusive) are suppressed at a sub-national level to prevent possible identification of individuals from small counts within the table.
· Zeros (0) do not need to be suppressed.
· All other counts will be rounded to the nearest 5.
Data will not be made available to any third parties other than those specified except in the form of aggregated outputs with small numbers suppressed in line with the HES Analysis Guide.
Expected output
All outputs will be aggregated with small number suppressed as per the HES analysis guide or according to the specific data set's suppression guidance.
The results of the NHS-Galleri trial outputs will be published in peer-reviewed publications, presented at conferences, and used by NHS England in their decisions around implementation of the test within the NHS. The interim analysis, which will include analysis of a key secondary objective, which was completed in Q1 2024. The primary objective readout is expected by the end of 2025 or beginning of 2026. Planned dissemination activities will aim to enable the engagement with the scientific and policy making communities to ensure that knowledge developed by this research can benefit these communities to help the NHS detect cancer early, when it is easier to treat.
Expected measurable benefits
The use of the datasets referenced herein will be used for the primary and secondary objective analyses of the NHS-Galleri trial. If the trial is successful, it is anticipated that there will be future health benefits to individuals within the NHS.
Multi-cancer early detection (MCED) testing is a novel screening paradigm, and assessment of the use and impact of the test alongside current standards of care is necessary to establish clinical utility and enable integration into clinical practice. This will be the first randomised controlled trial in the UK statistically powered to assess the test performance and clinical utility, including harms and benefits, of a multi-cancer early detection test when used in population screening. Due to the scale of this study (expecting approximately 140,000 participants in total to enrol), and the speed with which participants will be enrolled and the results analysed, local data collection for primary and secondary objective analyses is not practical and may overburden already strained NHS hospitals. As such, the study analyses depend entirely on central NHS datasets.
In its Long-Term Plan[a], published in January 2019, NHS England set an ambition to achieve a significant shift in the proportion of cancers diagnosed at an early stage by 2028 - that 75% of people with cancer will be diagnosed at stage I or II. Patients diagnosed early, at stages I and II, have the best chance of curative treatment and long-term survival. This study aims to determine whether the MCED test can provide a meaningful contribution towards achieving that ambition, which would have substantial impacts on cancer treatment and the survival of these patients within the NHS. If the study is successful, it is hoped that the NHS will adopt the test for individuals meeting the test’s intended use (currently, adults with an elevated risk of cancer, such as those aged 50 and older), which could impact the lives of millions of individuals within the NHS.
[a] https://www.longtermplan.nhs.uk/publication/nhs-long-term-plan/
The results of this study are expected by 2026 and a full health economic assessment will accompany the trial. Urgent measures need to be put in place to ramp up cancer screening programmes and innovative technologies such as MCED testing may provide a meaningful contribution towards earlier detection of cancers for the UK population. The magnitude of the impact of this invitation strategy will be measured by the success of participant recruitment into the NHS-Galleri trial. It is expected that the success of participant recruitment and knowledge gathered during this trial will inform the future implementation of the test in the NHS for early cancer detection.
Benefits reported so far
The Processors continue to receive NHS England Data to undertake ongoing data analysis for the study, but at the present time there are no Yielded Benefits to report under this amendment. This is because, as stated above, the outputs are not due until the end of 2026.
Datasets on the current version
Legal basis for provision: Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(2)(c)
| Dataset | Type of data | Sensitivity | Frequency | Confidential data |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) | Identifiable | Non-Sensitive | Ongoing | Consent (Reasonable Expectation) |
| NDRS Cancer Registrations | Identifiable | Sensitive | Ongoing | Consent (Reasonable Expectation) |
| NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments only) | Identifiable | Non-Sensitive | Ongoing | Consent (Reasonable Expectation) |
| NDRS Linked DIDs | Identifiable | Non-Sensitive | Ongoing | Consent (Reasonable Expectation) |
| NDRS Linked HES APC | Identifiable | Non-Sensitive | Ongoing | Consent (Reasonable Expectation) |
| NDRS Linked HES Outpatient | Identifiable | Non-Sensitive | Ongoing | Consent (Reasonable Expectation) |
| NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS) | Identifiable | Non-Sensitive | Ongoing | Consent (Reasonable Expectation) |
| NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations | Identifiable | Sensitive | Ongoing | Consent (Reasonable Expectation) |
| NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Dataset (SACT) | Identifiable | Sensitive | Ongoing | Consent (Reasonable Expectation) |
Files released
Files released counts only files released externally by DARS. Access granted in NHS England's own systems, such as its Secure Data Environment, is not included.
Patient opt-outs were not applied to any of the 140 files released under this agreement, across every version. About opt-outs
Files released against version 7.2 of this agreement, summarised by dataset.
| Dataset | Files | First released | Last released | Opt-outs applied |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NDRS Cancer Registrations | 6 | November 2025 | July 2026 | No |
| NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations | 4 | December 2025 | July 2026 | No |
| Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) | 2 | December 2025 | July 2026 | No |
| NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments only) | 2 | December 2025 | July 2026 | No |
| NDRS Linked DIDs | 2 | December 2025 | July 2026 | No |
| NDRS Linked HES APC | 2 | December 2025 | July 2026 | No |
| NDRS Linked HES Outpatient | 2 | December 2025 | July 2026 | No |
| NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS) | 2 | December 2025 | July 2026 | No |
| NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Dataset (SACT) | 2 | December 2025 | July 2026 | No |
Version history
The register lists each renewal of this agreement as a separate row. This site has 8 versions.
DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v7.2 24 October 2025 to 29 March 2030
- Title
- NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request
- Commercial
- Yes
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 9
- Files released
- 24
Datasets: Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS); NDRS Cancer Registrations; NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments only); NDRS Linked DIDs; NDRS Linked HES APC; NDRS Linked HES Outpatient; NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS); NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations; NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Dataset (SACT)
What changed from DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v6.4
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Start date | 2025-10-24 |
Objective for processing
[89 paragraphs unchanged]
KCL will be subcontracted by QMUL to perform certain work related to the trial. KCL are not a Controller in this Data Sharing Agreement as they do not make any decisions determining the purposes and means of the processing in the NHS Galleri study, but, rather, remain under the direction of QMUL. No NHS England Data, as described in this Data Sharing Agreement, will be stored at KCL but will be accessed by substantive employees of KCL under affiliate QMUL staff status and subject to a Data Processor Agreement between QMUL and KCL (see Section 5b Processing activities for more details).
[2 paragraphs unchanged]
Processing activities
[22 paragraphs unchanged]
The NHS England pseudonymised record-level Data from the datasets referenced herein will be accessible only to those substantive employees with appropriate and authorized access at (i)
King’s College London, (ii)
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd,
(iii)
(ii)
QMUL and
(iv)
(iii)
GRAIL Inc. Record level
pseudonymized
pseudonymised
Data will be stored in the secure AWS S3 folders (for GRAIL
[49 words unchanged]
where the statistical analysis is performed only from organisation owned/managed devices (whether
King’s College London, or
QMUL, or GRAIL to ARO or AWS respectively). Statistical data analysis will
[63 words unchanged]
Data will not be downloaded to remote devices for storage or processing.
[9 paragraphs unchanged]
Unchanged: Expected output, Expected measurable benefits, Benefits reported.
DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v6.4 4 October 2024 to 29 March 2030
- Title
- NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request
- Commercial
- Yes
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 9
- Files released
- 39
Datasets: Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS); NDRS Cancer Registrations; NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments only); NDRS Linked DIDs; NDRS Linked HES APC; NDRS Linked HES Outpatient; NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS); NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations; NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Dataset (SACT)
What changed from DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v5.2
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Start date | 2024-10-04 |
Data controllers:
+ QUEEN MARY UNIVERSITY OF LONDON · − KING'S COLLEGE LONDON
Objective for processing
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and
King’s College
Queen Mary University
London
(KCL),
(QMUL),
as joint Controllers, are requesting access to NHS England pseudonymised record-level Data in order to carry out follow-up analysis based on a cohort of patients who
are being
were
recruited to a clinical trial called ‘NHS-Galleri’ following being invited to participate if they
are
were
found to meet the required eligibility criteria.
Note that members of the team running the trial are based at the Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) at
King's College London.
QMUL.
For the sake of consistency, and as
King's College London
QMUL
is listed as a Controller, when referring to
King's College London
QMUL
throughout the application, this encompasses the team at CPTU from
King’s College London. *** New for Version 5 of this agreement: Some members of the trial team will also be based at Queen Mary University of London (QMUL) from December 2023 - please see further details in this section below***
QMUL.
[32 paragraphs unchanged]
11) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms following the third screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, for a pre-specified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
11) Assess the impact on cancer-specific mortality:
12) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms for all cancer types at
a) (Endpoint powered) Assess the potential for avoidance/postponement of cancer death by comparing the rates of death from cancer with-specific mortality rates among individuals receiving a positive MCED test at any of the 3 screening rounds in the intervention arm with that among individuals retrospectively testing positive at any of the 3 screening rounds in the control arm, at 3 years after the last study visit (retrospectively testing all samples from cancer deaths in the control arm).
a) 3 years and
b) (Endpoint not powered) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms for all cancer types at a) 3 years and b) 6 years after the last study visit.
b) 6 years after the last study visit.
12) Compare the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers following the second blood draw and 12 months of follow-up, with prevalent cases excluded.
13) Compare the absolute numbers of stage
III and
IV cancers following the
second
third
blood draw and
12
an average 16-18
months of follow-up, with
prevalent
cases
from the first and second screenings
excluded.
14) Compare the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers following the third blood draw and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, with cases from the first and second screenings excluded.
14) Assess the impact of use of the MCED test across three annual timepoints on healthcare resource utilization for cancer diagnosis and treatment.
15) Assess the impact of use of the MCED test across three annual timepoints on healthcare resource utilization for cancer diagnosis and treatment.
15) Assess the potential impact of overdiagnosis by comparing the cumulative incidence (Kaplan-Meier curves) of cancers diagnosed after a positive baseline MCED test up to 36-48 months after randomization between the intervention and control arms (retrospectively testing baseline samples from all participants diagnosed with cancer in the control arm).
16) Assess the potential impact of overdiagnosis by comparing the cumulative incidence (Kaplan-Meier curves) of cancers diagnosed after a positive baseline MCED test up to 36-48 months after randomization between the intervention and control arms (retrospectively testing baseline samples from all participants diagnosed with cancer in the control arm).
[32 paragraphs unchanged]
**** New for Version 5 of this agreement - November 2023 ****
[6 paragraphs unchanged]
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to
[11 words unchanged]
questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised Data with GRAIL
LLC
Inc
(US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials,
[5 words unchanged]
experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in
QMUL's Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (previously located at King’s College London) has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within
the
Kings College London Cancer
course of the trial, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
Prevention Trials Unit has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trial, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously strategies for equity of access and taken steps to ensure that under-represented minorities were actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, which identified and actively sent invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously, strategies for equity of access and has several plans underway to ensure that under-represented minorities are actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, that will identify and actively send invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
[3 paragraphs unchanged]
King’s College London,
QMUL,
as joint Controller, is using Article 6:1(e): Specific task in the ‘public
[34 words unchanged]
scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
• GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are a
jointController
joint Controller
and Lead for this DSA, who also process the Data. It is
[8 words unchanged]
well as the building and maintenance of the Clinical Records Management System.
•
King’s College London
QMUL
are a joint Controller who also process the Data and are responsible for implementing the trial and for primary objective analysis.
The Principal Investigator and the Cancer Prevention Trial Unit (CPTU) are based at QMUL.
•
GRAIL, Limited Liability Company (LLC). are
GRAIL Inc. is
the
manufacturers
manufacturer
of the MCED test, Galleri (Registered Trademark), and has set up the above UK subsidiary, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, which is the sponsor of the NHS-Galleri trial.
GRAIL, LLC
GRAIL Inc.
will be receiving pseudonymised record-level NHS England Data from
King’s College London,
GRAIL BIO UK Ltd,
and are therefore listed as a Processor in this DSA.
****New for Version 5 of this Data Sharing Agreement - November 2023:****
KCL will be subcontracted by QMUL to perform certain work related to the trial. KCL are not a Controller in this Data Sharing Agreement as they do not make any decisions determining the purposes and means of the processing in the NHS Galleri study, but, rather, remain under the direction of QMUL. No NHS England Data, as described in this Data Sharing Agreement, will be stored at KCL but will be accessed by substantive employees of KCL under affiliate QMUL staff status and subject to a Data Processor Agreement between QMUL and KCL (see Section 5b Processing activities for more details).
• Queen Mary, University of London (QMUL) is added as a named processor to this Data Sharing Agreement. It is planned for the start of December 2023 that the clinical research agreement GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has with King’s College London's Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) will novate to QMUL. This means that the current KCL CPTU trial staff working on NHS Galleri (including Patient Liaison, Clinical Project Managers and Clinical Trial Assistants) will cease employment at King’s College London and take up substantive employment with QMUL.
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS England therefore do not consider them to be a Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that QMUL's Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS England therefore do not consider them to be a Controller.
King’s College London will be subcontracted by QMUL to continue to work on NHS Galleri including allowing QMUL CPTU trial staff to access KCL facilities (software, equipment and data) under security and data control conditions that are appropriate for the data and facilities being accessed. Such subcontract will approximately last until August 2024, the end of the operational phase of the NHS Galleri study. Additionally, statisticians substantively employed by QMUL will access and analyse the NHS England Data.
To further clarify, pursuant to the Novation Agreement, QMUL shall be a Processor of GRAIL Bio UK Ltd. Further, QMUL has entered into a subcontract and a sub-data processing agreement with KCL in connection with the services KCL will provide to QMUL in relation to storing and managing the data for the NHS Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as Controller, shall have responsibility for ensuring all processing requirements and obligations flow down to QMUL and to KCL respectively. These processing requirements and obligations shall include ensuring QMUL and KCL are fully aware of their processing obligations as set out in this Data Sharing Agreement, including NHS England auditing obligations.
QMUL are not considered a Controller in this Data Sharing Agreement as they do not make any decisions determining the purposes and means of the processing in the NHS Galleri study. NHS England Data, as described in this Data Sharing Agreement, will not leave KCL secure servers but will be accessed by substantive employees of QMUL under affiliate KCL staff status and subject to a Data Processor Agreement between King’s College London and QMUL (see Section 5b Processing activities for more details).
At the end of the Operational Phase of NHS Galleri (approximately the end of 2024), the subcontracting agreement between King’s College London and QMUL referenced above will end. To reflect this change an amendment to this Data Sharing Agreement will be submitted by the Controllers at such time.
***************************
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS England therefore do not consider them to be a Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that King’s College London Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS Englandl therefore do not consider them to be a Controller.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Processing activities
[2 paragraphs unchanged]
1. The PID referenced in the cohort will be securely transferred from the CRMS as an encrypted dataset (AES 256) to
AIMES Management Services Limited's
Arrow Business Communications Limited (ARO)'s
sFTP server. From there,
King's College London
QMUL
downloads the cohort into
AIMES
ARO's
Trusted Research Environment (TRE) and transfers to NHS England via the sFTP portal over Health and Social Care Network (HSCN). Data is stored on the
AIMES Trusted Research Environment
ARO environment
(for a maximum of 1 week for confirmation of successful receipt by NDRS before being deleted).
2.
Kings College London
QMUL
will provide a cohort of approximately 140,000 records (in total), including a
[32 words unchanged]
Transfer Service (SEFT) or other secure, NHS England approved file transfer mechanism.
3. An encryption key is sent from the
King’s College London
QMUL
team to the CRMS system for encrypting the dataset, allowing for the participants identified in that dataset to be flagged for following by NDRS. Only the
King's College London
QMUL
team controls the ability to decrypt the dataset.
4. The NDRS team will use the identifiers to extract record-level pseudonymised Data and return the requested Data extracts to
King's College London
the ARO system operated by QMUL
via SEFT or other secure, NHS England approved file transfer mechanism. All
[12 words unchanged]
All other personal identifiable Data will be removed prior to the transfer.
5. The
King's College London
QMUL
team will download the resultant record-level pseudonymised data sets into the
AIMES Trusted Research Environment
ARO environment
and upload to Amazon Web Services S3 (UK Cloud platform) for analysis.
***New for Version 5 of this Data Sharing Agreement - October 2023:***
6. The QMUL team will access and analyse the NHS England Data held on the QMUL ARO environment via remote access using QMUL-owned devices.
6. The Queen Mary, University of London team will access and analyse the NHS England Data held on the King's College London AIMES Trusted Research Environment via remote access using King's College London owned devices, and the QMUL team are not permitted to download Data to King's College London owned devices or QMUL servers.
[11 paragraphs unchanged]
Amazon Web Services (AWS UK) supply IT infrastructure for GRAIL Bio UK
[122 words unchanged]
Only authorised study team members and substantive employees of GRAIL Bio UK
Ltd, King's College London
Ltd
and
Queen Mary, University of London
QMUL
have access to NHS England record-level pseudonymised Data stored in the secure S3 folders hosted by AWS in the United Kingdom. Enrolled participants
consent
consented
to the transfer and storage of their health Data to GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and
King's College London
QMUL
for the purposes of processing the pseudonymised Data extracts for this DSA.
AIMES Management Services Limited
ARO
supply IT infrastructure for
King's College London's
QMUL's
Trusted Research Environment and are therefore listed as a Processor. They supply a managed system, but do not access Data. Therefore, any access to the Data by
AIMES Management Services Limited
ARO
held under this DSA would be considered a breach of the DSA. They manage access to the file system with instruction from
King’s College London. Enrolled participants consent to the transfer and storage of their identifiable data to King's College London for the purposes of sending identifiers to NHS England's NDRS team for data extraction via the sFTP portal over Health and Social Care Network (HSCN).
QMUL.
Data is stored on the Trusted Research Environment (for agreed time-limited duration) both PID and pseudonymised and NDRS extract.
Amazon Web Services, Inc (USA) supply IT infrastructure for
GRAIL, LLC
GRAIL Inc.
and are therefore listed as a Processor. They supply support to the
[53 words unchanged]
participant information sheet, to the transfer of their pseudonymised health Data to
GRAIL, LLC
GRAIL Inc.
in the US for purposes permitted by the study participant consent form.
[34 words unchanged]
(USA). The transfer will be undertaken using a secure, encrypted network connection.
The NHS England pseudonymised record-level Data from the datasets referenced herein will
[11 words unchanged]
access at (i) King’s College London, (ii) GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, (iii)
Queen Mary, University of London,
QMUL
and (iv)
GRAIL, LLC.
GRAIL Inc.
Record level pseudonymized Data will be stored in the secure AWS S3 folders (for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and
GRAIL, LLC)
GRAIL Inc.)
and
AIMES
ARO
TRE (for
King’s College London and Queen Mary, University of London). King’s College London
QMUL). QMUL
are non-commercial collaborators and in order to provide academic independent analysis for scientific rigor of the study, it is necessary for
King’s College London
QMUL
to have an independent copy of the dataset in
AIMES
ARO
TRE. Access to cloud systems where the statistical analysis is performed only from organisation owned/managed devices (whether King’s College London, or
Queen Mary, University of London,
QMUL,
or GRAIL to
AIMES
ARO
or AWS respectively). Statistical data analysis will be carried out on organisation-owned
[58 words unchanged]
Data will not be downloaded to remote devices for storage or processing.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
NHS England record-level Data may not be shared with other organisations or
[112 words unchanged]
and the linkage is undertaken expressly for the purpose of medical research.
GRAIL, LLC
GRAIL Inc.
is not permitted to attempt to re-identify individuals.
[7 paragraphs unchanged]
Expected output
[1 paragraph unchanged]
The results of the NHS-Galleri trial outputs will be published in peer-reviewed
[20 words unchanged]
The interim analysis, which will include analysis of a key secondary objective,
is expected by the end of 2023 or beginning of
which was completed in Q1
2024. The primary objective readout is expected by the end of 2025
[33 words unchanged]
help the NHS detect cancer early, when it is easier to treat.
Unchanged: Expected measurable benefits, Benefits reported.
Objective for processing
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and Queen Mary University London (QMUL), as joint Controllers, are requesting access to NHS England pseudonymised record-level Data in order to carry out follow-up analysis based on a cohort of patients who were recruited to a clinical trial called ‘NHS-Galleri’ following being invited to participate if they were found to meet the required eligibility criteria.
Note that members of the team running the trial are based at the Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) at QMUL. For the sake of consistency, and as QMUL is listed as a Controller, when referring to QMUL throughout the application, this encompasses the team at CPTU from QMUL.
A new Multi-Cancer Early Detection (MCED) test has been developed that can detect many types of cancer from a single blood sample. This test is called Galleri (Registered Trademark). This trial aims to find out whether it is better at detecting cancer early, compared to other tests that the NHS currently uses. The purpose of NHS-Galleri is to demonstrate the clinical utility of the MCED blood test for individuals in a general screening population in a real world NHS setting. The rationale behind this trial is that MCED is a novel screening paradigm, and assessment of the use and impact of test results is necessary to enable integration into clinical practice. This will be the first randomised, double blind, controlled trial statistically powered to assess clinical utility of a MCED test.
Recruitment to the trial has been aided by NHS England's DigiTrials team via a sister Data Sharing Agreement (DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H) and took place over 10 – 12 months from August 2021 with a recruitment target of 140,000 people. Recruitment successfully completed and the target was met. Different geographic areas were targeted for recruitment, beginning with North-West England. Recruitment in a particular area lasted for 4 – 6 weeks, before moving on to another area. Recruitment was managed through mobile units on scheduled routes around a particular area. Batches of invitations were constructed to target whatever area the mobile units were in at the time of writing out to potential participants. Potential participants were only contacted once and there were no follow-ups sent after the original invitation letter.
Requesting Not to Take Part in Trial:
In addition to the National Data Opt-out, members of the public were able to specifically request not to be contacted for the NHS-Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd promoted this information via the dedicated trial website (nhs-galleri.org) and NHS England did the same via a dedicated page on its website (https://digital.nhs.uk/services/nhs-digitrials/nhs-galleri-trial). There was also an option for people to register their request not to take part in NHS-Galleri by telephone. NHS England records these requests not to take part and ensure that anyone who has registered for this will be excluded from the cohort selection and as a result their details will not be on the list for invitations to be sent.
• Primary Objective of the NHS-Galleri Trial:
- For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual test and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a. For a prespecified group of cancer types, including lung, head and neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver / bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary and bladder.
b. For all cancer types, excluding prostate cancer.
c. For all cancer types.
• Secondary Objectives of the NHS-Galleri Trial:
1) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of advanced cancers (defined as a cancer diagnosed at stage III or IV or one that results in a cancer-specific death) in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a) First, evaluate for a statistically significant difference in a prespecified group of primary cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
b) If a statistically significant reduction in absolute numbers is found, continue by evaluating for a difference in all cancer types excluding prostate cancer.
c) If the above evaluations are both significant, evaluate for a difference in all cancer types.
2) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a difference in the proportion of stage I and II cancers between the two arms of the study in the third testing round (i.e. for cancers diagnosed with an average 16-18 months of follow-up after the third test).
3) Evaluate the performance (overall sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three intervals of testing.
4) Evaluate the safety, including harms, of the testing pathway in the intervention arm among individuals with positive MCED test results.
a) Assess participant-reported anxiety among those receiving a positive MCED test result following the initial blood draw at various time points.
b) Examine the radiation exposure by participants associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures following a positive MCED test result
c) Describe the number and type of invasive procedures performed, and number of complications and deaths associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures.
5) Determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following the initial screening round and 12 months of follow-up (excluding cancers identified by the test performed at the 12-month visit)
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer;
c) For all cancer types.
6) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer
c) For all cancer types.
7) Determine whether there is a statistically significant difference in cancer detection rates in the two arms of the study with 12 months follow-up after the first test.
8) Model the expected differences in cancer-specific mortality at 7 years post-randomisation based on cancers diagnosed within an average of 40-42 months of randomisation.
9) Summarize stage distribution per cancer type for the two arms, and compare the absolute numbers of stage IV alone as well as stage III and IV cancers, following the third screening and an average 16-18* months of follow-up.
10) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers, excluding breast, cervical, and colorectal (i.e., those without a standard of care screening modality) as compared to the control arm following the third annual screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up.
11) Assess the impact on cancer-specific mortality:
a) (Endpoint powered) Assess the potential for avoidance/postponement of cancer death by comparing the rates of death from cancer with-specific mortality rates among individuals receiving a positive MCED test at any of the 3 screening rounds in the intervention arm with that among individuals retrospectively testing positive at any of the 3 screening rounds in the control arm, at 3 years after the last study visit (retrospectively testing all samples from cancer deaths in the control arm).
b) (Endpoint not powered) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms for all cancer types at a) 3 years and b) 6 years after the last study visit.
12) Compare the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers following the second blood draw and 12 months of follow-up, with prevalent cases excluded.
13) Compare the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers following the third blood draw and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, with cases from the first and second screenings excluded.
14) Assess the impact of use of the MCED test across three annual timepoints on healthcare resource utilization for cancer diagnosis and treatment.
15) Assess the potential impact of overdiagnosis by comparing the cumulative incidence (Kaplan-Meier curves) of cancers diagnosed after a positive baseline MCED test up to 36-48 months after randomization between the intervention and control arms (retrospectively testing baseline samples from all participants diagnosed with cancer in the control arm).
NHS ENGLAND DATA SETS REQUESTED:
> NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations
> NDRS Cancer Registry
> NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT)
> NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS)
> NDRS Linked Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC)
> NDRS Linked HES Outpatients (OP)
> NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) (Treatments and Referrals)
> NDRS Linked Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) (provided Summer 2022 onward)
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) (provided Summer 2022 onward)
FREQUENCY - every 6 months beginning March 2022 (Rapid Registrations every 2 months from March 2022).
FROM AUGUST 2022 (Version 2 of this Data Sharing Agreement)) - Frequency of drops
> NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) - no change
> NDRS Linked HES APC - no change
> NDRS Linked HES Outpatients (OP) - no change
> NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) (Treatments and Referrals) - no change
> NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS) – No change
> NDRS Linked Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> NDRS Linked Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations - Rapid Registrations will be provided every month rather than every two months from August 2022 to enable frequent monitoring of cancer diagnoses in the study.
> NDRS Cancer Registry - will be provided every month rather than every other month from August 2022 to enable frequent reporting of cancer diagnoses in the study and use the data as a filter for participant invitations for annual follow up timepoints. Expand historic gold standard registration field selection for 1995-2021 and addition of field to allow the trial team to distinguish provisional from finalised gold standard tumours. These changes are required for primary and secondary analysis. Data will be used to characterize the cohort for risk factors (prior cancers), and also assess test performance in a subpopulation of cancer survivors. The Status of Registration is required to enable accurate reporting and filtering of provisional data vs finalized data to internal and external stakeholders, and the interim analysis in the study. Death fields added to dataset specification for analysis of key secondary endpoints in the study. Death Data will also be used for reporting subject disposition in the analysis. Death Data, while requested with the Cancer Registry Data, should include information on all participants in the cohort (including participants that have not been diagnosed with cancer).
JUSTIFICATION FOR DATA SETS REQUESTED AND DATA MINIMISATION
> Cancer Registry and Rapid Registrations - These central NHS England datasets will be the sole source for the data required for primary and secondary objectives analyses in the study. They will be used to identify Primary endpoints, which are incidence and stage at diagnosis for cancer types that are stage-able (e.g., with available staging systems). Cancer is defined as any of the following cancers:
- Invasive solid cancer, excluding non-melanoma skin cancer
- Haematologic malignancies, including lymphoma, lymphoid leukemia, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, myeloid neoplasms (including myelodysplastic and myeloproliferative neoplasms with behaviour code 3 based on ICD-O-3.2*).
[*The International Classification of Diseases for Oncology, Third Edition (ICD-O-3) is the standard classification system for the registration of cancers in the United States (and most areas of the world) and contains widely-accepted histologic categories of brain tumors.]
The Cancer Registry will also be used to identify cohort characteristics/baseline risk - Personal history of cancer assessed using limited set of data fields. Historical cancer data dating back to 1995 will be available.
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Outpatients (OP), Admitted Patient Care (APC) and Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS), Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT) and Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Will be used to identify Secondary endpoints (including safety objectives). Among all test positive cases, number of follow-up procedures and number of invasive procedures (including all biopsies, surgical interventions, bronchoscopy, thoracoscopy and endoscopy) to achieve diagnostic resolution (i.e. cancer diagnosis, non-cancer diagnosis, or no diagnosis and discharge from the diagnostic follow-up). Will also identify:
- Number and type of invasive procedures performed in false positive cases;
- Number of complications and deaths resulting from diagnostic procedures;
- Radiation exposure measured in mSv per participant due to test result-directed evaluations
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) and Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS) will also be used (in addition to the above HES, CWT and DIDs data) for health care resource utilization objectives.
The NHS-Galleri trial has the following Secondary Objective: "Evaluate the performance (overall episode sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three rounds."
Participants who have had cancer prior to enrolment may be at risk of a recurrence. Previous research has demonstrated the Galleri MCED is capable of detecting cancer recurrence (1). As NDRS registers primary cancers (and not cancer recurrences), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are keen to establish when there is evidence that a patient has had a recurrence of their cancer. This is to complete a sensitivity analysis for the Positive Predictive Value (PPV) of the test in which the detection of a recurrence will be considered a True Positive (this is in contrast to the main analysis in which, because there is no new cancer registration, it is considered a False Positive). GRAIL Bio UK Ltd believe this analysis will help provide a more complete description of test performance.
(1) Schrag D, et al. Presentation at European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) Congress; September 9-13, 2022.
For the purposes of this analysis, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd will share the Study IDs of a small number of consented NHS-Galleri participants with NHS England for review as to whether these participants have a cancer recurrence. NHS England will convert the study IDs into internal patient IDs and provide an expert clinical review of each case to determine whether a patient has a recurrence. NHS England will do this based on the NDRS Datasets already listed in this Data Sharing Agreement.
***************************
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPI&E)
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to develop the participant facing materials and on questionnaires, and including specific questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised Data with GRAIL Inc (US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials, survey feedback on the participant experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in QMUL's Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (previously located at King’s College London) has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trial, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously strategies for equity of access and taken steps to ensure that under-represented minorities were actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, which identified and actively sent invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
UK GDPR Legal Basis for the Processing of Personal Data:
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as joint Controller, is using Article 6(1)(f) "processing is necessary for the purposes of the legitimate interests pursued by the controller or by a third party except where such interests are overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject which require protection of Personal Data, in particular where the data subject is a child." Processing Personal Data is necessary for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd’s legitimate interests which are described in this application. The Data to which access is requested are proportionate and necessary to achieve those interests. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has completed a legitimate interests assessment (LIA) and are satisfied that the interests of the data subjects do not override their legitimate interests; that they would reasonably expect the processing and it would not cause unjustified harm. The data subjects interests and fundamental rights are protected through appropriate minimisation of fields and patient records being processed; protection of the Data in a secure environment, and guaranteeing secure destruction at any stage at the request of NHS England and/or after a defined period on completion of the project.
Additionally (as health Data is a special category of Personal Data), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd is using Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
QMUL, as joint Controller, is using Article 6:1(e): Specific task in the ‘public interest’ or task that has a clear basis in law, and additionally (as health Data is a special category of Personal Data) Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
Organisation Roles and Responsibilities:
• GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are a joint Controller and Lead for this DSA, who also process the Data. It is responsible for sponsoring and funding the trial, as well as the building and maintenance of the Clinical Records Management System.
• QMUL are a joint Controller who also process the Data and are responsible for implementing the trial and for primary objective analysis. The Principal Investigator and the Cancer Prevention Trial Unit (CPTU) are based at QMUL.
• GRAIL Inc. is the manufacturer of the MCED test, Galleri (Registered Trademark), and has set up the above UK subsidiary, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, which is the sponsor of the NHS-Galleri trial. GRAIL Inc. will be receiving pseudonymised record-level NHS England Data from GRAIL BIO UK Ltd, and are therefore listed as a Processor in this DSA.
KCL will be subcontracted by QMUL to perform certain work related to the trial. KCL are not a Controller in this Data Sharing Agreement as they do not make any decisions determining the purposes and means of the processing in the NHS Galleri study, but, rather, remain under the direction of QMUL. No NHS England Data, as described in this Data Sharing Agreement, will be stored at KCL but will be accessed by substantive employees of KCL under affiliate QMUL staff status and subject to a Data Processor Agreement between QMUL and KCL (see Section 5b Processing activities for more details).
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS England therefore do not consider them to be a Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that QMUL's Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS England therefore do not consider them to be a Controller.
In the future, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd may receive commercial benefit (including intangible or indirect commercial benefits such as positive publicity) from the successful outcomes of the trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and the NHS have entered into a partnership whereby the Galleri test will be piloted in clinical trials within the NHS in England. If the test is shown to work as intended in these clinical trials, the NHS may purchase the test from GRAIL and make the test routinely available in the future to benefit patient.
Expected output
All outputs will be aggregated with small number suppressed as per the HES analysis guide or according to the specific data set's suppression guidance.
The results of the NHS-Galleri trial outputs will be published in peer-reviewed publications, presented at conferences, and used by NHS England in their decisions around implementation of the test within the NHS. The interim analysis, which will include analysis of a key secondary objective, which was completed in Q1 2024. The primary objective readout is expected by the end of 2025 or beginning of 2026. Planned dissemination activities will aim to enable the engagement with the scientific and policy making communities to ensure that knowledge developed by this research can benefit these communities to help the NHS detect cancer early, when it is easier to treat.
Benefits reported
The Processors continue to receive NHS England Data to undertake ongoing data analysis for the study, but at the present time there are no Yielded Benefits to report under this amendment. This is because, as stated above, the outputs are not due until the end of 2026.
DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v5.2 7 December 2023 to 29 March 2030
- Title
- NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request
- Commercial
- Yes
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 9
- Files released
- 38
Datasets: Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS); NDRS Cancer Registrations; NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments only); NDRS Linked DIDs; NDRS Linked HES APC; NDRS Linked HES Outpatient; NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS); NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations; NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Dataset (SACT)
What changed from DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v4.2
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Start date | 2023-12-07 |
Objective for processing
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and King’s College London (KCL), as joint
data controllers,
Controllers,
are requesting access to
NHS England
pseudonymised record-level
data
Data
in order to carry out follow-up analysis based on a cohort of
[14 words unchanged]
to participate if they are found to meet the required eligibility criteria.
Note that members of the team running the trial are based at
[12 words unchanged]
sake of consistency, and as King's College London is listed as a
data controller,
Controller,
when referring to King's College London throughout the application, this encompasses the team at
CPTU.
CPTU from King’s College London. *** New for Version 5 of this agreement: Some members of the trial team will also be based at Queen Mary University of London (QMUL) from December 2023 - please see further details in this section below***
Background, Purpose and Rationale behind NHS-Galleri:
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Recruitment to the trial has been aided by NHS
Digital's Digi-Trials
England's DigiTrials
team via a sister
application, DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H,
Data Sharing Agreement (DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H)
and took place over 10 – 12 months from August 2021 with
[11 words unchanged]
target was met. Different geographic areas were targeted for recruitment, beginning with
North-west
North-West
England. Recruitment in a particular area lasted for 4 – 6 weeks,
[47 words unchanged]
once and there were no follow-ups sent after the original invitation letter.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
In addition to the National Data Opt-out, members of the public were
[15 words unchanged]
Ltd promoted this information via the dedicated trial website (nhs-galleri.org) and NHS
Digital
England
did the same via a dedicated page on its website (https://digital.nhs.uk/services/nhs-digitrials/nhs-galleri-trial). There
[7 words unchanged]
register their request not to take part in NHS-Galleri by telephone. NHS
Digital
England
records these requests not to take part and ensure that anyone who
[16 words unchanged]
details will not be on the list for invitations to be sent.
Objectives
• Primary Objective
of the
NHS-Galleri
Trial:
• Primary Objective:
[4 paragraphs unchanged]
• Secondary
Objectives:
Objectives of the NHS-Galleri Trial:
[30 paragraphs unchanged]
NHS ENGLAND
DATA SETS REQUESTED:
[10 paragraphs unchanged]
FROM AUGUST 2022 (Version 2 of this
agreement)
Data Sharing Agreement))
- Frequency of drops
[10 paragraphs unchanged]
> Cancer Registry and Rapid Registrations - These central NHS
England
datasets will be the sole source for the data required for primary and secondary objectives analyses in the
Study. Will
study. They will
be used to identify Primary endpoints, which are incidence and stage at
[9 words unchanged]
available staging systems). Cancer is defined as any of the following cancers:
[9 paragraphs unchanged]
**** New for Version 5 of this agreement - November 2023 ****
The NHS-Galleri trial has the following Secondary Objective: "Evaluate the performance (overall episode sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three rounds."
Participants who have had cancer prior to enrolment may be at risk of a recurrence. Previous research has demonstrated the Galleri MCED is capable of detecting cancer recurrence (1). As NDRS registers primary cancers (and not cancer recurrences), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are keen to establish when there is evidence that a patient has had a recurrence of their cancer. This is to complete a sensitivity analysis for the Positive Predictive Value (PPV) of the test in which the detection of a recurrence will be considered a True Positive (this is in contrast to the main analysis in which, because there is no new cancer registration, it is considered a False Positive). GRAIL Bio UK Ltd believe this analysis will help provide a more complete description of test performance.
(1) Schrag D, et al. Presentation at European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) Congress; September 9-13, 2022.
For the purposes of this analysis, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd will share the Study IDs of a small number of consented NHS-Galleri participants with NHS England for review as to whether these participants have a cancer recurrence. NHS England will convert the study IDs into internal patient IDs and provide an expert clinical review of each case to determine whether a patient has a recurrence. NHS England will do this based on the NDRS Datasets already listed in this Data Sharing Agreement.
***************************
[2 paragraphs unchanged]
Prevention Trials Unit has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the
trail,
trial,
as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
UK
GDPR Legal Basis for the Processing of Personal Data:
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as joint
Data
Controller, is using Article 6(1)(f) "processing is necessary for the purposes of
[22 words unchanged]
fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject which require protection of
personal data,
Personal Data,
in particular where the data subject is a child." Processing
personal data
Personal Data
is necessary for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd’s legitimate interests which are described in this application. The
data
Data
to which access is requested are proportionate and necessary to achieve those interests. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has completed a legitimate interests assessment (LIA) and
NHS Digital
are satisfied that the interests of the data subjects do not override
[27 words unchanged]
appropriate minimisation of fields and patient records being processed; protection of the
data
Data
in a secure environment, and guaranteeing secure destruction at any stage at the request of NHS
Digital or
England and/or
after a defined period on completion of the project.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
King’s College London, as joint
Data
Controller, is using Article 6:1(e): Specific task in the ‘public interest’ or task that has a clear basis in law, and additionally (as health
data
Data
is a special category of Personal Data) Article 9:2(j): Special category data
[7 words unchanged]
scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
• GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are a
joint Data Controller
jointController
and Lead for this
agreement,
DSA,
who also process the
data.
Data.
It is responsible for sponsoring and funding the trial, as well as the building and maintenance of the Clinical Records Management System.
• King’s College London are a joint
Data
Controller who also process the
data
Data
and are responsible for implementing the trial and for primary objective analysis.
• GRAIL, Limited Liability Company (LLC). are the manufacturers of the MCED
[20 words unchanged]
of the NHS-Galleri trial. GRAIL, LLC will be receiving pseudonymised record-level NHS
Digital data
England Data
from King’s College London, and are therefore listed as a
Data
Processor in this
agreement.
DSA.
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that King’s College London Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller.
****New for Version 5 of this Data Sharing Agreement - November 2023:****
• Queen Mary, University of London (QMUL) is added as a named processor to this Data Sharing Agreement. It is planned for the start of December 2023 that the clinical research agreement GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has with King’s College London's Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) will novate to QMUL. This means that the current KCL CPTU trial staff working on NHS Galleri (including Patient Liaison, Clinical Project Managers and Clinical Trial Assistants) will cease employment at King’s College London and take up substantive employment with QMUL.
King’s College London will be subcontracted by QMUL to continue to work on NHS Galleri including allowing QMUL CPTU trial staff to access KCL facilities (software, equipment and data) under security and data control conditions that are appropriate for the data and facilities being accessed. Such subcontract will approximately last until August 2024, the end of the operational phase of the NHS Galleri study. Additionally, statisticians substantively employed by QMUL will access and analyse the NHS England Data.
To further clarify, pursuant to the Novation Agreement, QMUL shall be a Processor of GRAIL Bio UK Ltd. Further, QMUL has entered into a subcontract and a sub-data processing agreement with KCL in connection with the services KCL will provide to QMUL in relation to storing and managing the data for the NHS Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as Controller, shall have responsibility for ensuring all processing requirements and obligations flow down to QMUL and to KCL respectively. These processing requirements and obligations shall include ensuring QMUL and KCL are fully aware of their processing obligations as set out in this Data Sharing Agreement, including NHS England auditing obligations.
QMUL are not considered a Controller in this Data Sharing Agreement as they do not make any decisions determining the purposes and means of the processing in the NHS Galleri study. NHS England Data, as described in this Data Sharing Agreement, will not leave KCL secure servers but will be accessed by substantive employees of QMUL under affiliate KCL staff status and subject to a Data Processor Agreement between King’s College London and QMUL (see Section 5b Processing activities for more details).
At the end of the Operational Phase of NHS Galleri (approximately the end of 2024), the subcontracting agreement between King’s College London and QMUL referenced above will end. To reflect this change an amendment to this Data Sharing Agreement will be submitted by the Controllers at such time.
***************************
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS England therefore do not consider them to be a Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that King’s College London Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS Englandl therefore do not consider them to be a Controller.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Processing activities
Patient Identifiable Data (PID) referred to in section 5a (above) will be stored in the Clinical Records Management System (“CRMS”) hosted on Amazon Web Service (AWS UK). NHS
Digital
England
record-level pseudonymised
data
Data
referred to in section 5a (above) will be stored in a secure
[9 words unchanged]
system in a cloud platform) hosted on Amazon Web Service (AWS UK).
[1 paragraph unchanged]
1. The PID referenced in the cohort will be securely transferred from
[21 words unchanged]
the cohort into AIMES Trusted Research Environment (TRE) and transfers to NHS
Digital
England
via the sFTP portal over Health and Social Care Network (HSCN). Data
[12 words unchanged]
1 week for confirmation of successful receipt by NDRS before being deleted).
2. Kings College London will provide a cohort of approximately 140,000 records
[13 words unchanged]
Birth, Sex and Post Code along with first recruitment date and withdrawal
data
date
(if applicable) to NHS
Digital
England
via a Secure Electronic File Transfer Service (SEFT) or other secure, NHS
Digital
England
approved file transfer mechanism.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
4. The NDRS team will use the identifiers to extract record-level pseudonymised
data
Data
and return the requested
data
Data
extracts to King's College London via SEFT or other secure, NHS
Digital
England
approved file transfer mechanism. All
data
Data
from NHS
Digital
England
will contain only the pseudo-study ID for linkage. All other personal identifiable
data
Data
will be removed prior to the transfer.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
***New for Version 5 of this Data Sharing Agreement - October 2023:***
6. The Queen Mary, University of London team will access and analyse the NHS England Data held on the King's College London AIMES Trusted Research Environment via remote access using King's College London owned devices, and the QMUL team are not permitted to download Data to King's College London owned devices or QMUL servers.
7. Sub study analysis - Cancer Recurrences
- GRAIL Bio UK Ltd will share the Study IDs of a small number of consented NHS-Galleri participants with NHS England.
- NHS England will convert the study IDs into internal patient IDs and provide an expert clinical review of each case to determine whether a patient has a recurrence. NHS England will do this based on the NDRS Datasets already listed in this Data Sharing Agreement.
- NHS England will provide the following pseudonymised record-level data file to GRAIL Bio UK Ltd:
• Source of information for recurrence: (e.g. from pathology, imaging, COSD etc).
• Date of recurrence: defined as date associated with earliest source of information suggesting recurrence.
• Linked pseudo_id to primary tumour (where possible).
• Pseudonymised Study ID
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd have been made aware that this sub-study analysis is derived from clinical review and opinion undertaken by Data Analysists in the NHS England's NDRS Team.
***************************
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Amazon Web Services (AWS UK) supply IT infrastructure for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and are therefore listed as
data processors.
a Processor.
They supply support to the system, but do not access
data.
Data.
Therefore, any access to the data held under this
agreement
DSA
would be considered a breach of the
agreement.
DSA.
This includes granting of access to the database[s] containing the
data.
Data.
AWS UK use only UK data centres and provides a private cloud
[11 words unchanged]
developed and is managed by GRAIL Bio UK Ltd. The record-level pseudonymised
data
Data
extracts referred to in section
3b and
5a
(above)
of this Data Sharing Agreement
will be stored in secure S3 folders which are hosted on Amazon
[6 words unchanged]
will be stored separately in the CRMS. Only authorised study team members
and substantive employees
of GRAIL Bio UK
Ltd and
Ltd,
King's College
London and Queen Mary, University of
London have access to NHS
Digital
England
record-level pseudonymised
data
Data
stored in the secure S3 folders hosted by AWS in the United Kingdom. Enrolled participants consent to the transfer and storage of their health
data
Data
to GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and King's College London for the purposes of processing the pseudonymised
data
Data
extracts for this
application.
DSA.
AIMES Management Services Limited supply IT infrastructure for King's College London's Trusted Research Environment and are therefore listed as
data processors.
a Processor.
They supply a managed system, but do not access
data.
Data.
Therefore, any access to the
data
Data by AIMES Management Services Limited
held under this
agreement
DSA
would be considered a breach of the
agreement.
DSA.
They manage access to the file system with instruction from King’s College
[13 words unchanged]
to King's College London for the purposes of sending identifiers to NHS
Digital's
England's
NDRS team for data extraction via the sFTP portal over Health and
[11 words unchanged]
Environment (for agreed time-limited duration) both PID and pseudonymised and NDRS extract.
Amazon Web Services, Inc (USA) supply IT infrastructure for GRAIL, LLC and are therefore listed as
data processors.
a Processor.
They supply support to the system, but do not access
data.
Data.
Therefore, any access to the
data
Data
held under this
agreement
DSA by Amazon Web Services, Inc. (USA)
would be considered a breach of the
agreement.
DSA.
This includes granting of access to the database[s] containing the
data.
Data.
Enrolled participants also consent, as expressly stated in the consent form and participant information sheet, to the transfer of their pseudonymised health
data
Data
to GRAIL, LLC in the US for purposes permitted by the study participant consent form. The pseudonymised
data
Data
will be transferred by GRAIL Bio UK Ltd from the secure S3
[19 words unchanged]
(USA). The transfer will be undertaken using a secure, encrypted network connection.
The NHS
Digital
England
pseudonymised record-level
data
Data
from the datasets referenced herein will be accessible only to those substantive employees with appropriate and authorized access at (i) King’s College London, (ii) GRAIL Bio UK Ltd,
(iii) Queen Mary, University of London,
and
(iii)
(iv)
GRAIL,
LLC, plus one King’s College London study member - who is not substantively employed by King’s College London (see special condition).
LLC.
Record level pseudonymized
data
Data
will be stored in the secure AWS S3 folders (for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and GRAIL, LLC) and AIMES TRE (for King’s College
London and Queen Mary, University of
London). King’s College London are non-commercial collaborators and in order to provide
[33 words unchanged]
statistical analysis is performed only from organisation owned/managed devices (whether King’s College
London
London, or Queen Mary, University of London,
or GRAIL to AIMES or AWS respectively). Statistical data analysis will be
[50 words unchanged]
will be conducted within the confines of the organisation's cloud platform, and
Data
will not be downloaded to remote devices for storage or processing.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
NHS
Digital
England
record-level
data
Data
may not be shared with other organisations or countries outside of those
[11 words unchanged]
stored for 10 years following completion of the study and record-level pseudonymised
data
Data
will be stored for 10 years following completion of the study. All
[34 words unchanged]
agreements with NHS bodies, and in line with participant consent. Record-level NHS
Digital data
England Data
may be linked with other datasets held by the Data Processors or
[22 words unchanged]
medical research. GRAIL, LLC is not permitted to attempt to re-identify individuals.
[7 paragraphs unchanged]
Expected measurable benefits
The use of the datasets referenced herein will be used for the
[16 words unchanged]
anticipated that there will be future health benefits to individuals within the
NHS
NHS.
[4 paragraphs unchanged]
Benefits reported
Version 4:
The
Data
Processors continue to receive NHS
Digital data
England Data
to undertake ongoing data analysis for the study, but at the present time there are no Yielded Benefits to report under this amendment.
This is because, as stated above, the outputs are not due until the end of 2026.
Unchanged: Expected output.
Objective for processing
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and King’s College London (KCL), as joint Controllers, are requesting access to NHS England pseudonymised record-level Data in order to carry out follow-up analysis based on a cohort of patients who are being recruited to a clinical trial called ‘NHS-Galleri’ following being invited to participate if they are found to meet the required eligibility criteria.
Note that members of the team running the trial are based at the Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) at King's College London. For the sake of consistency, and as King's College London is listed as a Controller, when referring to King's College London throughout the application, this encompasses the team at CPTU from King’s College London. *** New for Version 5 of this agreement: Some members of the trial team will also be based at Queen Mary University of London (QMUL) from December 2023 - please see further details in this section below***
A new Multi-Cancer Early Detection (MCED) test has been developed that can detect many types of cancer from a single blood sample. This test is called Galleri (Registered Trademark). This trial aims to find out whether it is better at detecting cancer early, compared to other tests that the NHS currently uses. The purpose of NHS-Galleri is to demonstrate the clinical utility of the MCED blood test for individuals in a general screening population in a real world NHS setting. The rationale behind this trial is that MCED is a novel screening paradigm, and assessment of the use and impact of test results is necessary to enable integration into clinical practice. This will be the first randomised, double blind, controlled trial statistically powered to assess clinical utility of a MCED test.
Recruitment to the trial has been aided by NHS England's DigiTrials team via a sister Data Sharing Agreement (DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H) and took place over 10 – 12 months from August 2021 with a recruitment target of 140,000 people. Recruitment successfully completed and the target was met. Different geographic areas were targeted for recruitment, beginning with North-West England. Recruitment in a particular area lasted for 4 – 6 weeks, before moving on to another area. Recruitment was managed through mobile units on scheduled routes around a particular area. Batches of invitations were constructed to target whatever area the mobile units were in at the time of writing out to potential participants. Potential participants were only contacted once and there were no follow-ups sent after the original invitation letter.
Requesting Not to Take Part in Trial:
In addition to the National Data Opt-out, members of the public were able to specifically request not to be contacted for the NHS-Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd promoted this information via the dedicated trial website (nhs-galleri.org) and NHS England did the same via a dedicated page on its website (https://digital.nhs.uk/services/nhs-digitrials/nhs-galleri-trial). There was also an option for people to register their request not to take part in NHS-Galleri by telephone. NHS England records these requests not to take part and ensure that anyone who has registered for this will be excluded from the cohort selection and as a result their details will not be on the list for invitations to be sent.
• Primary Objective of the NHS-Galleri Trial:
- For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual test and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a. For a prespecified group of cancer types, including lung, head and neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver / bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary and bladder.
b. For all cancer types, excluding prostate cancer.
c. For all cancer types.
• Secondary Objectives of the NHS-Galleri Trial:
1) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of advanced cancers (defined as a cancer diagnosed at stage III or IV or one that results in a cancer-specific death) in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a) First, evaluate for a statistically significant difference in a prespecified group of primary cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
b) If a statistically significant reduction in absolute numbers is found, continue by evaluating for a difference in all cancer types excluding prostate cancer.
c) If the above evaluations are both significant, evaluate for a difference in all cancer types.
2) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a difference in the proportion of stage I and II cancers between the two arms of the study in the third testing round (i.e. for cancers diagnosed with an average 16-18 months of follow-up after the third test).
3) Evaluate the performance (overall sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three intervals of testing.
4) Evaluate the safety, including harms, of the testing pathway in the intervention arm among individuals with positive MCED test results.
a) Assess participant-reported anxiety among those receiving a positive MCED test result following the initial blood draw at various time points.
b) Examine the radiation exposure by participants associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures following a positive MCED test result
c) Describe the number and type of invasive procedures performed, and number of complications and deaths associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures.
5) Determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following the initial screening round and 12 months of follow-up (excluding cancers identified by the test performed at the 12-month visit)
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer;
c) For all cancer types.
6) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer
c) For all cancer types.
7) Determine whether there is a statistically significant difference in cancer detection rates in the two arms of the study with 12 months follow-up after the first test.
8) Model the expected differences in cancer-specific mortality at 7 years post-randomisation based on cancers diagnosed within an average of 40-42 months of randomisation.
9) Summarize stage distribution per cancer type for the two arms, and compare the absolute numbers of stage IV alone as well as stage III and IV cancers, following the third screening and an average 16-18* months of follow-up.
10) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers, excluding breast, cervical, and colorectal (i.e., those without a standard of care screening modality) as compared to the control arm following the third annual screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up.
11) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms following the third screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, for a pre-specified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
12) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms for all cancer types at
a) 3 years and
b) 6 years after the last study visit.
13) Compare the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers following the second blood draw and 12 months of follow-up, with prevalent cases excluded.
14) Compare the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers following the third blood draw and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, with cases from the first and second screenings excluded.
15) Assess the impact of use of the MCED test across three annual timepoints on healthcare resource utilization for cancer diagnosis and treatment.
16) Assess the potential impact of overdiagnosis by comparing the cumulative incidence (Kaplan-Meier curves) of cancers diagnosed after a positive baseline MCED test up to 36-48 months after randomization between the intervention and control arms (retrospectively testing baseline samples from all participants diagnosed with cancer in the control arm).
NHS ENGLAND DATA SETS REQUESTED:
> NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations
> NDRS Cancer Registry
> NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT)
> NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS)
> NDRS Linked Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC)
> NDRS Linked HES Outpatients (OP)
> NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) (Treatments and Referrals)
> NDRS Linked Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) (provided Summer 2022 onward)
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) (provided Summer 2022 onward)
FREQUENCY - every 6 months beginning March 2022 (Rapid Registrations every 2 months from March 2022).
FROM AUGUST 2022 (Version 2 of this Data Sharing Agreement)) - Frequency of drops
> NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) - no change
> NDRS Linked HES APC - no change
> NDRS Linked HES Outpatients (OP) - no change
> NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) (Treatments and Referrals) - no change
> NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS) – No change
> NDRS Linked Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> NDRS Linked Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations - Rapid Registrations will be provided every month rather than every two months from August 2022 to enable frequent monitoring of cancer diagnoses in the study.
> NDRS Cancer Registry - will be provided every month rather than every other month from August 2022 to enable frequent reporting of cancer diagnoses in the study and use the data as a filter for participant invitations for annual follow up timepoints. Expand historic gold standard registration field selection for 1995-2021 and addition of field to allow the trial team to distinguish provisional from finalised gold standard tumours. These changes are required for primary and secondary analysis. Data will be used to characterize the cohort for risk factors (prior cancers), and also assess test performance in a subpopulation of cancer survivors. The Status of Registration is required to enable accurate reporting and filtering of provisional data vs finalized data to internal and external stakeholders, and the interim analysis in the study. Death fields added to dataset specification for analysis of key secondary endpoints in the study. Death Data will also be used for reporting subject disposition in the analysis. Death Data, while requested with the Cancer Registry Data, should include information on all participants in the cohort (including participants that have not been diagnosed with cancer).
JUSTIFICATION FOR DATA SETS REQUESTED AND DATA MINIMISATION
> Cancer Registry and Rapid Registrations - These central NHS England datasets will be the sole source for the data required for primary and secondary objectives analyses in the study. They will be used to identify Primary endpoints, which are incidence and stage at diagnosis for cancer types that are stage-able (e.g., with available staging systems). Cancer is defined as any of the following cancers:
- Invasive solid cancer, excluding non-melanoma skin cancer
- Haematologic malignancies, including lymphoma, lymphoid leukemia, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, myeloid neoplasms (including myelodysplastic and myeloproliferative neoplasms with behaviour code 3 based on ICD-O-3.2*).
[*The International Classification of Diseases for Oncology, Third Edition (ICD-O-3) is the standard classification system for the registration of cancers in the United States (and most areas of the world) and contains widely-accepted histologic categories of brain tumors.]
The Cancer Registry will also be used to identify cohort characteristics/baseline risk - Personal history of cancer assessed using limited set of data fields. Historical cancer data dating back to 1995 will be available.
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Outpatients (OP), Admitted Patient Care (APC) and Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS), Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT) and Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Will be used to identify Secondary endpoints (including safety objectives). Among all test positive cases, number of follow-up procedures and number of invasive procedures (including all biopsies, surgical interventions, bronchoscopy, thoracoscopy and endoscopy) to achieve diagnostic resolution (i.e. cancer diagnosis, non-cancer diagnosis, or no diagnosis and discharge from the diagnostic follow-up). Will also identify:
- Number and type of invasive procedures performed in false positive cases;
- Number of complications and deaths resulting from diagnostic procedures;
- Radiation exposure measured in mSv per participant due to test result-directed evaluations
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) and Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS) will also be used (in addition to the above HES, CWT and DIDs data) for health care resource utilization objectives.
**** New for Version 5 of this agreement - November 2023 ****
The NHS-Galleri trial has the following Secondary Objective: "Evaluate the performance (overall episode sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three rounds."
Participants who have had cancer prior to enrolment may be at risk of a recurrence. Previous research has demonstrated the Galleri MCED is capable of detecting cancer recurrence (1). As NDRS registers primary cancers (and not cancer recurrences), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are keen to establish when there is evidence that a patient has had a recurrence of their cancer. This is to complete a sensitivity analysis for the Positive Predictive Value (PPV) of the test in which the detection of a recurrence will be considered a True Positive (this is in contrast to the main analysis in which, because there is no new cancer registration, it is considered a False Positive). GRAIL Bio UK Ltd believe this analysis will help provide a more complete description of test performance.
(1) Schrag D, et al. Presentation at European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) Congress; September 9-13, 2022.
For the purposes of this analysis, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd will share the Study IDs of a small number of consented NHS-Galleri participants with NHS England for review as to whether these participants have a cancer recurrence. NHS England will convert the study IDs into internal patient IDs and provide an expert clinical review of each case to determine whether a patient has a recurrence. NHS England will do this based on the NDRS Datasets already listed in this Data Sharing Agreement.
***************************
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPI&E)
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to develop the participant facing materials and on questionnaires, and including specific questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised Data with GRAIL LLC (US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials, survey feedback on the participant experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in the Kings College London Cancer
Prevention Trials Unit has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trial, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously, strategies for equity of access and has several plans underway to ensure that under-represented minorities are actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, that will identify and actively send invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
UK GDPR Legal Basis for the Processing of Personal Data:
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as joint Controller, is using Article 6(1)(f) "processing is necessary for the purposes of the legitimate interests pursued by the controller or by a third party except where such interests are overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject which require protection of Personal Data, in particular where the data subject is a child." Processing Personal Data is necessary for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd’s legitimate interests which are described in this application. The Data to which access is requested are proportionate and necessary to achieve those interests. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has completed a legitimate interests assessment (LIA) and are satisfied that the interests of the data subjects do not override their legitimate interests; that they would reasonably expect the processing and it would not cause unjustified harm. The data subjects interests and fundamental rights are protected through appropriate minimisation of fields and patient records being processed; protection of the Data in a secure environment, and guaranteeing secure destruction at any stage at the request of NHS England and/or after a defined period on completion of the project.
Additionally (as health Data is a special category of Personal Data), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd is using Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
King’s College London, as joint Controller, is using Article 6:1(e): Specific task in the ‘public interest’ or task that has a clear basis in law, and additionally (as health Data is a special category of Personal Data) Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
Organisation Roles and Responsibilities:
• GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are a jointController and Lead for this DSA, who also process the Data. It is responsible for sponsoring and funding the trial, as well as the building and maintenance of the Clinical Records Management System.
• King’s College London are a joint Controller who also process the Data and are responsible for implementing the trial and for primary objective analysis.
• GRAIL, Limited Liability Company (LLC). are the manufacturers of the MCED test, Galleri (Registered Trademark), and has set up the above UK subsidiary, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, which is the sponsor of the NHS-Galleri trial. GRAIL, LLC will be receiving pseudonymised record-level NHS England Data from King’s College London, and are therefore listed as a Processor in this DSA.
****New for Version 5 of this Data Sharing Agreement - November 2023:****
• Queen Mary, University of London (QMUL) is added as a named processor to this Data Sharing Agreement. It is planned for the start of December 2023 that the clinical research agreement GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has with King’s College London's Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) will novate to QMUL. This means that the current KCL CPTU trial staff working on NHS Galleri (including Patient Liaison, Clinical Project Managers and Clinical Trial Assistants) will cease employment at King’s College London and take up substantive employment with QMUL.
King’s College London will be subcontracted by QMUL to continue to work on NHS Galleri including allowing QMUL CPTU trial staff to access KCL facilities (software, equipment and data) under security and data control conditions that are appropriate for the data and facilities being accessed. Such subcontract will approximately last until August 2024, the end of the operational phase of the NHS Galleri study. Additionally, statisticians substantively employed by QMUL will access and analyse the NHS England Data.
To further clarify, pursuant to the Novation Agreement, QMUL shall be a Processor of GRAIL Bio UK Ltd. Further, QMUL has entered into a subcontract and a sub-data processing agreement with KCL in connection with the services KCL will provide to QMUL in relation to storing and managing the data for the NHS Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as Controller, shall have responsibility for ensuring all processing requirements and obligations flow down to QMUL and to KCL respectively. These processing requirements and obligations shall include ensuring QMUL and KCL are fully aware of their processing obligations as set out in this Data Sharing Agreement, including NHS England auditing obligations.
QMUL are not considered a Controller in this Data Sharing Agreement as they do not make any decisions determining the purposes and means of the processing in the NHS Galleri study. NHS England Data, as described in this Data Sharing Agreement, will not leave KCL secure servers but will be accessed by substantive employees of QMUL under affiliate KCL staff status and subject to a Data Processor Agreement between King’s College London and QMUL (see Section 5b Processing activities for more details).
At the end of the Operational Phase of NHS Galleri (approximately the end of 2024), the subcontracting agreement between King’s College London and QMUL referenced above will end. To reflect this change an amendment to this Data Sharing Agreement will be submitted by the Controllers at such time.
***************************
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS England therefore do not consider them to be a Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that King’s College London Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS Englandl therefore do not consider them to be a Controller.
In the future, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd may receive commercial benefit (including intangible or indirect commercial benefits such as positive publicity) from the successful outcomes of the trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and the NHS have entered into a partnership whereby the Galleri test will be piloted in clinical trials within the NHS in England. If the test is shown to work as intended in these clinical trials, the NHS may purchase the test from GRAIL and make the test routinely available in the future to benefit patient.
Expected output
All outputs will be aggregated with small number suppressed as per the HES analysis guide or according to the specific data set's suppression guidance.
The results of the NHS-Galleri trial outputs will be published in peer-reviewed publications, presented at conferences, and used by NHS England in their decisions around implementation of the test within the NHS. The interim analysis, which will include analysis of a key secondary objective, is expected by the end of 2023 or beginning of 2024. The primary objective readout is expected by the end of 2025 or beginning of 2026. Planned dissemination activities will aim to enable the engagement with the scientific and policy making communities to ensure that knowledge developed by this research can benefit these communities to help the NHS detect cancer early, when it is easier to treat.
Benefits reported
The Processors continue to receive NHS England Data to undertake ongoing data analysis for the study, but at the present time there are no Yielded Benefits to report under this amendment. This is because, as stated above, the outputs are not due until the end of 2026.
DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v4.2 14 February 2023 to 29 March 2030
- Title
- NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request
- Commercial
- Yes
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 9
- Files released
- 34
Datasets: Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS); NDRS Cancer Registrations; NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments only); NDRS Linked DIDs; NDRS Linked HES APC; NDRS Linked HES Outpatient; NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS); NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations; NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Dataset (SACT)
What changed from DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v3.2
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Start date | 2023-02-14 | |
| End date | 2030-03-29 | |
| NDRS Cancer Registrations: sensitivity | Sensitive | |
| NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations: sensitivity | Sensitive | |
| NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Dataset (SACT): sensitivity | Sensitive |
Benefits reported
Version
3:
4:
The Data Processors continue to receive NHS Digital data to undertake ongoing
[8 words unchanged]
present time there are no Yielded Benefits to report under this amendment.
Unchanged: Objective for processing, Processing activities, Expected output, Expected measurable benefits.
Objective for processing
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and King’s College London (KCL), as joint data controllers, are requesting access to pseudonymised record-level data in order to carry out follow-up analysis based on a cohort of patients who are being recruited to a clinical trial called ‘NHS-Galleri’ following being invited to participate if they are found to meet the required eligibility criteria.
Note that members of the team running the trial are based at the Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) at King's College London. For the sake of consistency, and as King's College London is listed as a data controller, when referring to King's College London throughout the application, this encompasses the team at CPTU.
Background, Purpose and Rationale behind NHS-Galleri:
A new Multi-Cancer Early Detection (MCED) test has been developed that can detect many types of cancer from a single blood sample. This test is called Galleri (Registered Trademark). This trial aims to find out whether it is better at detecting cancer early, compared to other tests that the NHS currently uses. The purpose of NHS-Galleri is to demonstrate the clinical utility of the MCED blood test for individuals in a general screening population in a real world NHS setting. The rationale behind this trial is that MCED is a novel screening paradigm, and assessment of the use and impact of test results is necessary to enable integration into clinical practice. This will be the first randomised, double blind, controlled trial statistically powered to assess clinical utility of a MCED test.
Recruitment to the trial has been aided by NHS Digital's Digi-Trials team via a sister application, DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H, and took place over 10 – 12 months from August 2021 with a recruitment target of 140,000 people. Recruitment successfully completed and the target was met. Different geographic areas were targeted for recruitment, beginning with North-west England. Recruitment in a particular area lasted for 4 – 6 weeks, before moving on to another area. Recruitment was managed through mobile units on scheduled routes around a particular area. Batches of invitations were constructed to target whatever area the mobile units were in at the time of writing out to potential participants. Potential participants were only contacted once and there were no follow-ups sent after the original invitation letter.
Requesting Not to Take Part in Trial:
In addition to the National Data Opt-out, members of the public were able to specifically request not to be contacted for the NHS-Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd promoted this information via the dedicated trial website (nhs-galleri.org) and NHS Digital did the same via a dedicated page on its website (https://digital.nhs.uk/services/nhs-digitrials/nhs-galleri-trial). There was also an option for people to register their request not to take part in NHS-Galleri by telephone. NHS Digital records these requests not to take part and ensure that anyone who has registered for this will be excluded from the cohort selection and as a result their details will not be on the list for invitations to be sent.
Objectives of the Trial:
• Primary Objective:
- For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual test and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a. For a prespecified group of cancer types, including lung, head and neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver / bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary and bladder.
b. For all cancer types, excluding prostate cancer.
c. For all cancer types.
• Secondary Objectives:
1) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of advanced cancers (defined as a cancer diagnosed at stage III or IV or one that results in a cancer-specific death) in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a) First, evaluate for a statistically significant difference in a prespecified group of primary cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
b) If a statistically significant reduction in absolute numbers is found, continue by evaluating for a difference in all cancer types excluding prostate cancer.
c) If the above evaluations are both significant, evaluate for a difference in all cancer types.
2) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a difference in the proportion of stage I and II cancers between the two arms of the study in the third testing round (i.e. for cancers diagnosed with an average 16-18 months of follow-up after the third test).
3) Evaluate the performance (overall sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three intervals of testing.
4) Evaluate the safety, including harms, of the testing pathway in the intervention arm among individuals with positive MCED test results.
a) Assess participant-reported anxiety among those receiving a positive MCED test result following the initial blood draw at various time points.
b) Examine the radiation exposure by participants associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures following a positive MCED test result
c) Describe the number and type of invasive procedures performed, and number of complications and deaths associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures.
5) Determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following the initial screening round and 12 months of follow-up (excluding cancers identified by the test performed at the 12-month visit)
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer;
c) For all cancer types.
6) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer
c) For all cancer types.
7) Determine whether there is a statistically significant difference in cancer detection rates in the two arms of the study with 12 months follow-up after the first test.
8) Model the expected differences in cancer-specific mortality at 7 years post-randomisation based on cancers diagnosed within an average of 40-42 months of randomisation.
9) Summarize stage distribution per cancer type for the two arms, and compare the absolute numbers of stage IV alone as well as stage III and IV cancers, following the third screening and an average 16-18* months of follow-up.
10) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers, excluding breast, cervical, and colorectal (i.e., those without a standard of care screening modality) as compared to the control arm following the third annual screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up.
11) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms following the third screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, for a pre-specified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
12) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms for all cancer types at
a) 3 years and
b) 6 years after the last study visit.
13) Compare the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers following the second blood draw and 12 months of follow-up, with prevalent cases excluded.
14) Compare the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers following the third blood draw and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, with cases from the first and second screenings excluded.
15) Assess the impact of use of the MCED test across three annual timepoints on healthcare resource utilization for cancer diagnosis and treatment.
16) Assess the potential impact of overdiagnosis by comparing the cumulative incidence (Kaplan-Meier curves) of cancers diagnosed after a positive baseline MCED test up to 36-48 months after randomization between the intervention and control arms (retrospectively testing baseline samples from all participants diagnosed with cancer in the control arm).
DATA SETS REQUESTED:
> NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations
> NDRS Cancer Registry
> NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT)
> NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS)
> NDRS Linked Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC)
> NDRS Linked HES Outpatients (OP)
> NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) (Treatments and Referrals)
> NDRS Linked Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) (provided Summer 2022 onward)
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) (provided Summer 2022 onward)
FREQUENCY - every 6 months beginning March 2022 (Rapid Registrations every 2 months from March 2022).
FROM AUGUST 2022 (Version 2 of this agreement) - Frequency of drops
> NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) - no change
> NDRS Linked HES APC - no change
> NDRS Linked HES Outpatients (OP) - no change
> NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) (Treatments and Referrals) - no change
> NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS) – No change
> NDRS Linked Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> NDRS Linked Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations - Rapid Registrations will be provided every month rather than every two months from August 2022 to enable frequent monitoring of cancer diagnoses in the study.
> NDRS Cancer Registry - will be provided every month rather than every other month from August 2022 to enable frequent reporting of cancer diagnoses in the study and use the data as a filter for participant invitations for annual follow up timepoints. Expand historic gold standard registration field selection for 1995-2021 and addition of field to allow the trial team to distinguish provisional from finalised gold standard tumours. These changes are required for primary and secondary analysis. Data will be used to characterize the cohort for risk factors (prior cancers), and also assess test performance in a subpopulation of cancer survivors. The Status of Registration is required to enable accurate reporting and filtering of provisional data vs finalized data to internal and external stakeholders, and the interim analysis in the study. Death fields added to dataset specification for analysis of key secondary endpoints in the study. Death data will also be used for reporting subject disposition in the analysis. Death data, while requested with the cancer registry data, should include information on all participants in the cohort (including participants that have not been diagnosed with cancer).
JUSTIFICATION FOR DATA SETS REQUESTED AND DATA MINIMISATION
> Cancer Registry and Rapid Registrations - These central NHS datasets will be the sole source for the data required for primary and secondary objectives analyses in the Study. Will be used to identify Primary endpoints, which are incidence and stage at diagnosis for cancer types that are stage-able (e.g., with available staging systems). Cancer is defined as any of the following cancers:
- Invasive solid cancer, excluding non-melanoma skin cancer
- Haematologic malignancies, including lymphoma, lymphoid leukemia, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, myeloid neoplasms (including myelodysplastic and myeloproliferative neoplasms with behaviour code 3 based on ICD-O-3.2*).
[*The International Classification of Diseases for Oncology, Third Edition (ICD-O-3) is the standard classification system for the registration of cancers in the United States (and most areas of the world) and contains widely-accepted histologic categories of brain tumors.]
The Cancer Registry will also be used to identify cohort characteristics/baseline risk - Personal history of cancer assessed using limited set of data fields. Historical cancer data dating back to 1995 will be available.
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Outpatients (OP), Admitted Patient Care (APC) and Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS), Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT) and Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Will be used to identify Secondary endpoints (including safety objectives). Among all test positive cases, number of follow-up procedures and number of invasive procedures (including all biopsies, surgical interventions, bronchoscopy, thoracoscopy and endoscopy) to achieve diagnostic resolution (i.e. cancer diagnosis, non-cancer diagnosis, or no diagnosis and discharge from the diagnostic follow-up). Will also identify:
- Number and type of invasive procedures performed in false positive cases;
- Number of complications and deaths resulting from diagnostic procedures;
- Radiation exposure measured in mSv per participant due to test result-directed evaluations
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) and Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS) will also be used (in addition to the above HES, CWT and DIDs data) for health care resource utilization objectives.
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPI&E)
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to develop the participant facing materials and on questionnaires, and including specific questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised data with GRAIL LLC (US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials, survey feedback on the participant experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in the Kings College London Cancer
Prevention Trials Unit has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trail, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously, strategies for equity of access and has several plans underway to ensure that under-represented minorities are actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, that will identify and actively send invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
GDPR Legal Basis for the Processing of Personal Data:
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as joint Data Controller, is using Article 6(1)(f) "processing is necessary for the purposes of the legitimate interests pursued by the controller or by a third party except where such interests are overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject which require protection of personal data, in particular where the data subject is a child." Processing personal data is necessary for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd’s legitimate interests which are described in this application. The data to which access is requested are proportionate and necessary to achieve those interests. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has completed a legitimate interests assessment (LIA) and NHS Digital are satisfied that the interests of the data subjects do not override their legitimate interests; that they would reasonably expect the processing and it would not cause unjustified harm. The data subjects interests and fundamental rights are protected through appropriate minimisation of fields and patient records being processed; protection of the data in a secure environment, and guaranteeing secure destruction at any stage at the request of NHS Digital or after a defined period on completion of the project.
Additionally (as health data is a special category of Personal Data), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd is using Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
King’s College London, as joint Data Controller, is using Article 6:1(e): Specific task in the ‘public interest’ or task that has a clear basis in law, and additionally (as health data is a special category of Personal Data) Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
Organisation Roles and Responsibilities:
• GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are a joint Data Controller and Lead for this agreement, who also process the data. It is responsible for sponsoring and funding the trial, as well as the building and maintenance of the Clinical Records Management System.
• King’s College London are a joint Data Controller who also process the data and are responsible for implementing the trial and for primary objective analysis.
• GRAIL, Limited Liability Company (LLC). are the manufacturers of the MCED test, Galleri (Registered Trademark), and has set up the above UK subsidiary, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, which is the sponsor of the NHS-Galleri trial. GRAIL, LLC will be receiving pseudonymised record-level NHS Digital data from King’s College London, and are therefore listed as a Data Processor in this agreement.
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that King’s College London Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller.
In the future, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd may receive commercial benefit (including intangible or indirect commercial benefits such as positive publicity) from the successful outcomes of the trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and the NHS have entered into a partnership whereby the Galleri test will be piloted in clinical trials within the NHS in England. If the test is shown to work as intended in these clinical trials, the NHS may purchase the test from GRAIL and make the test routinely available in the future to benefit patient.
Expected output
All outputs will be aggregated with small number suppressed as per the HES analysis guide or according to the specific data set's suppression guidance.
The results of the NHS-Galleri trial outputs will be published in peer-reviewed publications, presented at conferences, and used by NHS England in their decisions around implementation of the test within the NHS. The interim analysis, which will include analysis of a key secondary objective, is expected by the end of 2023 or beginning of 2024. The primary objective readout is expected by the end of 2025 or beginning of 2026. Planned dissemination activities will aim to enable the engagement with the scientific and policy making communities to ensure that knowledge developed by this research can benefit these communities to help the NHS detect cancer early, when it is easier to treat.
Benefits reported
Version 4: The Data Processors continue to receive NHS Digital data to undertake ongoing data analysis for the study, but at the present time there are no Yielded Benefits to report under this amendment.
DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v3.2 16 January 2023 to 29 March 2023
- Title
- NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request
- Commercial
- Yes
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 9
- Files released
- 5
Datasets: Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS); NDRS Cancer Registrations; NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments only); NDRS Linked DIDs; NDRS Linked HES APC; NDRS Linked HES Outpatient; NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS); NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations; NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Dataset (SACT)
What changed from DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v2.2
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Start date | 2023-01-16 | |
| End date | 2023-03-29 |
Datasets:
+ NDRS Cancer Registrations; + NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments only); + NDRS Linked DIDs; + NDRS Linked HES APC; + NDRS Linked HES Outpatient; + NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS); + NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations; + NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Dataset (SACT) · − Cancer Registration Data; − Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) Data Set; − Diagnostic Imaging Data Set (DID); − Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC); − Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP); − Radiotherapy Data Set; − Rapid Cancer Registrations Data Set; − Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set
Objective for processing
[45 paragraphs unchanged]
>
NDRS
Rapid
Cancer
Registrations
Cancer Data Set
>
NDRS
Cancer Registry
>
NDRS
Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT)
>
NDRS National
Radiotherapy
Data set
Dataset
(RTDS)
>
NDRS Linked
Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC)
>
NDRS Linked
HES Outpatients (OP)
>
NDRS Linked
Cancer Waiting Times
(CWT)
(Treatments and Referrals)
(CWT)
>
NDRS Linked
Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS)
(To be released
(provided
Summer 2022 onward)
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS)
(To be released
(provided
Summer 2022 onward)
[1 paragraph unchanged]
************** CHANGES
FROM AUGUST 2022 (Version 2 of this agreement)
**************
- Frequency of drops
>
NDRS
Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) - no change
>
Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC)
NDRS Linked HES APC
- no change
>
NDRS Linked
HES Outpatients (OP) - no change
>
NDRS Linked
Cancer Waiting Times
(CWT)
(Treatments and Referrals)
(CWT)
- no change
>
NDRS National
Radiotherapy
Data Set
Dataset (RTDS)
– No change
>
NDRS Linked
Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
>
NDRS Linked
Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
>
NDRS
Rapid
Cancer
Registrations
Cancer Data Set
- Rapid Registrations will be provided every month rather than every two months from August 2022 to enable frequent monitoring of cancer diagnoses in the study.
>
NDRS
Cancer Registry - will be provided every month rather than every other
[161 words unchanged]
in the cohort (including participants that have not been diagnosed with cancer).
**************
[25 paragraphs unchanged]
Benefits reported
-
Version 3: The Data Processors continue to receive NHS Digital data to undertake ongoing data analysis for the study, but at the present time there are no Yielded Benefits to report under this amendment.
Unchanged: Processing activities, Expected output, Expected measurable benefits.
Objective for processing
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and King’s College London (KCL), as joint data controllers, are requesting access to pseudonymised record-level data in order to carry out follow-up analysis based on a cohort of patients who are being recruited to a clinical trial called ‘NHS-Galleri’ following being invited to participate if they are found to meet the required eligibility criteria.
Note that members of the team running the trial are based at the Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) at King's College London. For the sake of consistency, and as King's College London is listed as a data controller, when referring to King's College London throughout the application, this encompasses the team at CPTU.
Background, Purpose and Rationale behind NHS-Galleri:
A new Multi-Cancer Early Detection (MCED) test has been developed that can detect many types of cancer from a single blood sample. This test is called Galleri (Registered Trademark). This trial aims to find out whether it is better at detecting cancer early, compared to other tests that the NHS currently uses. The purpose of NHS-Galleri is to demonstrate the clinical utility of the MCED blood test for individuals in a general screening population in a real world NHS setting. The rationale behind this trial is that MCED is a novel screening paradigm, and assessment of the use and impact of test results is necessary to enable integration into clinical practice. This will be the first randomised, double blind, controlled trial statistically powered to assess clinical utility of a MCED test.
Recruitment to the trial has been aided by NHS Digital's Digi-Trials team via a sister application, DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H, and took place over 10 – 12 months from August 2021 with a recruitment target of 140,000 people. Recruitment successfully completed and the target was met. Different geographic areas were targeted for recruitment, beginning with North-west England. Recruitment in a particular area lasted for 4 – 6 weeks, before moving on to another area. Recruitment was managed through mobile units on scheduled routes around a particular area. Batches of invitations were constructed to target whatever area the mobile units were in at the time of writing out to potential participants. Potential participants were only contacted once and there were no follow-ups sent after the original invitation letter.
Requesting Not to Take Part in Trial:
In addition to the National Data Opt-out, members of the public were able to specifically request not to be contacted for the NHS-Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd promoted this information via the dedicated trial website (nhs-galleri.org) and NHS Digital did the same via a dedicated page on its website (https://digital.nhs.uk/services/nhs-digitrials/nhs-galleri-trial). There was also an option for people to register their request not to take part in NHS-Galleri by telephone. NHS Digital records these requests not to take part and ensure that anyone who has registered for this will be excluded from the cohort selection and as a result their details will not be on the list for invitations to be sent.
Objectives of the Trial:
• Primary Objective:
- For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual test and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a. For a prespecified group of cancer types, including lung, head and neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver / bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary and bladder.
b. For all cancer types, excluding prostate cancer.
c. For all cancer types.
• Secondary Objectives:
1) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of advanced cancers (defined as a cancer diagnosed at stage III or IV or one that results in a cancer-specific death) in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a) First, evaluate for a statistically significant difference in a prespecified group of primary cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
b) If a statistically significant reduction in absolute numbers is found, continue by evaluating for a difference in all cancer types excluding prostate cancer.
c) If the above evaluations are both significant, evaluate for a difference in all cancer types.
2) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a difference in the proportion of stage I and II cancers between the two arms of the study in the third testing round (i.e. for cancers diagnosed with an average 16-18 months of follow-up after the third test).
3) Evaluate the performance (overall sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three intervals of testing.
4) Evaluate the safety, including harms, of the testing pathway in the intervention arm among individuals with positive MCED test results.
a) Assess participant-reported anxiety among those receiving a positive MCED test result following the initial blood draw at various time points.
b) Examine the radiation exposure by participants associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures following a positive MCED test result
c) Describe the number and type of invasive procedures performed, and number of complications and deaths associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures.
5) Determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following the initial screening round and 12 months of follow-up (excluding cancers identified by the test performed at the 12-month visit)
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer;
c) For all cancer types.
6) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer
c) For all cancer types.
7) Determine whether there is a statistically significant difference in cancer detection rates in the two arms of the study with 12 months follow-up after the first test.
8) Model the expected differences in cancer-specific mortality at 7 years post-randomisation based on cancers diagnosed within an average of 40-42 months of randomisation.
9) Summarize stage distribution per cancer type for the two arms, and compare the absolute numbers of stage IV alone as well as stage III and IV cancers, following the third screening and an average 16-18* months of follow-up.
10) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers, excluding breast, cervical, and colorectal (i.e., those without a standard of care screening modality) as compared to the control arm following the third annual screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up.
11) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms following the third screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, for a pre-specified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
12) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms for all cancer types at
a) 3 years and
b) 6 years after the last study visit.
13) Compare the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers following the second blood draw and 12 months of follow-up, with prevalent cases excluded.
14) Compare the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers following the third blood draw and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, with cases from the first and second screenings excluded.
15) Assess the impact of use of the MCED test across three annual timepoints on healthcare resource utilization for cancer diagnosis and treatment.
16) Assess the potential impact of overdiagnosis by comparing the cumulative incidence (Kaplan-Meier curves) of cancers diagnosed after a positive baseline MCED test up to 36-48 months after randomization between the intervention and control arms (retrospectively testing baseline samples from all participants diagnosed with cancer in the control arm).
DATA SETS REQUESTED:
> NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations
> NDRS Cancer Registry
> NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT)
> NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS)
> NDRS Linked Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC)
> NDRS Linked HES Outpatients (OP)
> NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) (Treatments and Referrals)
> NDRS Linked Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) (provided Summer 2022 onward)
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) (provided Summer 2022 onward)
FREQUENCY - every 6 months beginning March 2022 (Rapid Registrations every 2 months from March 2022).
FROM AUGUST 2022 (Version 2 of this agreement) - Frequency of drops
> NDRS Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) - no change
> NDRS Linked HES APC - no change
> NDRS Linked HES Outpatients (OP) - no change
> NDRS Linked Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) (Treatments and Referrals) - no change
> NDRS National Radiotherapy Dataset (RTDS) – No change
> NDRS Linked Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> NDRS Linked Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> NDRS Rapid Cancer Registrations - Rapid Registrations will be provided every month rather than every two months from August 2022 to enable frequent monitoring of cancer diagnoses in the study.
> NDRS Cancer Registry - will be provided every month rather than every other month from August 2022 to enable frequent reporting of cancer diagnoses in the study and use the data as a filter for participant invitations for annual follow up timepoints. Expand historic gold standard registration field selection for 1995-2021 and addition of field to allow the trial team to distinguish provisional from finalised gold standard tumours. These changes are required for primary and secondary analysis. Data will be used to characterize the cohort for risk factors (prior cancers), and also assess test performance in a subpopulation of cancer survivors. The Status of Registration is required to enable accurate reporting and filtering of provisional data vs finalized data to internal and external stakeholders, and the interim analysis in the study. Death fields added to dataset specification for analysis of key secondary endpoints in the study. Death data will also be used for reporting subject disposition in the analysis. Death data, while requested with the cancer registry data, should include information on all participants in the cohort (including participants that have not been diagnosed with cancer).
JUSTIFICATION FOR DATA SETS REQUESTED AND DATA MINIMISATION
> Cancer Registry and Rapid Registrations - These central NHS datasets will be the sole source for the data required for primary and secondary objectives analyses in the Study. Will be used to identify Primary endpoints, which are incidence and stage at diagnosis for cancer types that are stage-able (e.g., with available staging systems). Cancer is defined as any of the following cancers:
- Invasive solid cancer, excluding non-melanoma skin cancer
- Haematologic malignancies, including lymphoma, lymphoid leukemia, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, myeloid neoplasms (including myelodysplastic and myeloproliferative neoplasms with behaviour code 3 based on ICD-O-3.2*).
[*The International Classification of Diseases for Oncology, Third Edition (ICD-O-3) is the standard classification system for the registration of cancers in the United States (and most areas of the world) and contains widely-accepted histologic categories of brain tumors.]
The Cancer Registry will also be used to identify cohort characteristics/baseline risk - Personal history of cancer assessed using limited set of data fields. Historical cancer data dating back to 1995 will be available.
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Outpatients (OP), Admitted Patient Care (APC) and Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS), Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT) and Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Will be used to identify Secondary endpoints (including safety objectives). Among all test positive cases, number of follow-up procedures and number of invasive procedures (including all biopsies, surgical interventions, bronchoscopy, thoracoscopy and endoscopy) to achieve diagnostic resolution (i.e. cancer diagnosis, non-cancer diagnosis, or no diagnosis and discharge from the diagnostic follow-up). Will also identify:
- Number and type of invasive procedures performed in false positive cases;
- Number of complications and deaths resulting from diagnostic procedures;
- Radiation exposure measured in mSv per participant due to test result-directed evaluations
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) and Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS) will also be used (in addition to the above HES, CWT and DIDs data) for health care resource utilization objectives.
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPI&E)
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to develop the participant facing materials and on questionnaires, and including specific questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised data with GRAIL LLC (US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials, survey feedback on the participant experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in the Kings College London Cancer
Prevention Trials Unit has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trail, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously, strategies for equity of access and has several plans underway to ensure that under-represented minorities are actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, that will identify and actively send invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
GDPR Legal Basis for the Processing of Personal Data:
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as joint Data Controller, is using Article 6(1)(f) "processing is necessary for the purposes of the legitimate interests pursued by the controller or by a third party except where such interests are overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject which require protection of personal data, in particular where the data subject is a child." Processing personal data is necessary for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd’s legitimate interests which are described in this application. The data to which access is requested are proportionate and necessary to achieve those interests. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has completed a legitimate interests assessment (LIA) and NHS Digital are satisfied that the interests of the data subjects do not override their legitimate interests; that they would reasonably expect the processing and it would not cause unjustified harm. The data subjects interests and fundamental rights are protected through appropriate minimisation of fields and patient records being processed; protection of the data in a secure environment, and guaranteeing secure destruction at any stage at the request of NHS Digital or after a defined period on completion of the project.
Additionally (as health data is a special category of Personal Data), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd is using Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
King’s College London, as joint Data Controller, is using Article 6:1(e): Specific task in the ‘public interest’ or task that has a clear basis in law, and additionally (as health data is a special category of Personal Data) Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
Organisation Roles and Responsibilities:
• GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are a joint Data Controller and Lead for this agreement, who also process the data. It is responsible for sponsoring and funding the trial, as well as the building and maintenance of the Clinical Records Management System.
• King’s College London are a joint Data Controller who also process the data and are responsible for implementing the trial and for primary objective analysis.
• GRAIL, Limited Liability Company (LLC). are the manufacturers of the MCED test, Galleri (Registered Trademark), and has set up the above UK subsidiary, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, which is the sponsor of the NHS-Galleri trial. GRAIL, LLC will be receiving pseudonymised record-level NHS Digital data from King’s College London, and are therefore listed as a Data Processor in this agreement.
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that King’s College London Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller.
In the future, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd may receive commercial benefit (including intangible or indirect commercial benefits such as positive publicity) from the successful outcomes of the trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and the NHS have entered into a partnership whereby the Galleri test will be piloted in clinical trials within the NHS in England. If the test is shown to work as intended in these clinical trials, the NHS may purchase the test from GRAIL and make the test routinely available in the future to benefit patient.
Expected output
All outputs will be aggregated with small number suppressed as per the HES analysis guide or according to the specific data set's suppression guidance.
The results of the NHS-Galleri trial outputs will be published in peer-reviewed publications, presented at conferences, and used by NHS England in their decisions around implementation of the test within the NHS. The interim analysis, which will include analysis of a key secondary objective, is expected by the end of 2023 or beginning of 2024. The primary objective readout is expected by the end of 2025 or beginning of 2026. Planned dissemination activities will aim to enable the engagement with the scientific and policy making communities to ensure that knowledge developed by this research can benefit these communities to help the NHS detect cancer early, when it is easier to treat.
Benefits reported
Version 3: The Data Processors continue to receive NHS Digital data to undertake ongoing data analysis for the study, but at the present time there are no Yielded Benefits to report under this amendment.
DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v2.2 18 August 2022 to 29 March 2030
- Title
- NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request
- Commercial
- Yes
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 9
- Files released
- 0
Datasets: Cancer Registration Data; Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) Data Set; Diagnostic Imaging Data Set (DID); Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS); Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC); Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP); Radiotherapy Data Set; Rapid Cancer Registrations Data Set; Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set
What changed from DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v1.2
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Start date | 2022-08-18 |
Objective for processing
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Note that
all
members of the team running the trial are based at the Cancer
[27 words unchanged]
King's College London throughout the application, this encompasses the team at CPTU.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
A new Multi-Cancer Early Detection (MCED) test has been developed that can
[16 words unchanged]
Trademark). This trial aims to find out whether it is better at
discovering
detecting
cancer early, compared to other tests that the NHS currently uses. The
[66 words unchanged]
controlled trial statistically powered to assess clinical utility of a MCED test.
Recruitment to the trial
is being
has been
aided by NHS Digital's Digi-Trials team via a sister application, DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H, and
is taking
took
place over 10 – 12 months from August 2021 with a recruitment target of 140,000 people.
Recruitment successfully completed and the target was met.
Different
geographic
areas
are being
were
targeted for recruitment, beginning with North-west England. Recruitment in a particular area
will last
lasted
for 4 – 6 weeks, before moving on to another area. Recruitment
is being
was
managed through mobile units on scheduled routes around a particular area. Batches of invitations
are being
were
constructed to target whatever area the mobile units
will be
were
in at the time of writing out to potential participants. Potential participants
will
were
only
be
contacted once and there
will be
were
no follow-ups sent after the original invitation letter.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
In addition to the National Data Opt-out, members of the public
are
were
able to specifically request not to be contacted for the NHS-Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd
have
promoted this information via the dedicated trial website (nhs-galleri.org) and NHS Digital
have done
did
the same via a dedicated page on its website (https://digital.nhs.uk/services/nhs-digitrials/nhs-galleri-trial). There
is
was
also an option for people to register their request not to take part in NHS-Galleri by telephone. NHS Digital
is recording
records
these requests not to take part and
ensuring
ensure
that anyone who has registered for this will be excluded from the
[7 words unchanged]
details will not be on the list for invitations to be sent.
[43 paragraphs unchanged]
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) (released Summer 2022 onwards)
[2 paragraphs unchanged]
> Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS)
(released
(To be released
Summer 2022
onwards)
onward)
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPI&E)
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) (To be released Summer 2022 onward)
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to develop the participant facing materials and on questionnaires, and including specific questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised data with GRAIL LLC (US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials, survey feedback on the participant experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in the Kings College London Cancer
FREQUENCY - every 6 months beginning March 2022 (Rapid Registrations every 2 months from March 2022).
Prevention Trials Unit has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trail, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
************** CHANGES FROM AUGUST 2022 (Version 2 of this agreement) **************
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously, strategies for equity of access and has several plans underway to ensure that under-represented minorities are actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, that will identify and actively send invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) - no change
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC) - no change
> HES Outpatients (OP) - no change
> Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT) - no change
> Radiotherapy Data Set – No change
> Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> Rapid Registrations Cancer Data Set - Rapid Registrations will be provided every month rather than every two months from August 2022 to enable frequent monitoring of cancer diagnoses in the study.
> Cancer Registry - will be provided every month rather than every other month from August 2022 to enable frequent reporting of cancer diagnoses in the study and use the data as a filter for participant invitations for annual follow up timepoints. Expand historic gold standard registration field selection for 1995-2021 and addition of field to allow the trial team to distinguish provisional from finalised gold standard tumours. These changes are required for primary and secondary analysis. Data will be used to characterize the cohort for risk factors (prior cancers), and also assess test performance in a subpopulation of cancer survivors. The Status of Registration is required to enable accurate reporting and filtering of provisional data vs finalized data to internal and external stakeholders, and the interim analysis in the study. Death fields added to dataset specification for analysis of key secondary endpoints in the study. Death data will also be used for reporting subject disposition in the analysis. Death data, while requested with the cancer registry data, should include information on all participants in the cohort (including participants that have not been diagnosed with cancer).
**************
[11 paragraphs unchanged]
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPI&E)
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to develop the participant facing materials and on questionnaires, and including specific questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised data with GRAIL LLC (US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials, survey feedback on the participant experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in the Kings College London Cancer
Prevention Trials Unit has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trail, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously, strategies for equity of access and has several plans underway to ensure that under-represented minorities are actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, that will identify and actively send invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
[10 paragraphs unchanged]
Processing activities
[7 paragraphs unchanged]
***FREQUENCY - every 6 months beginning March 2022 (Rapid Registrations every 2 months from March 2022). ***
N.B. Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) and Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) will be released from released Summer 2022 onwards.
[14 paragraphs unchanged]
Unchanged: Expected output, Expected measurable benefits, Benefits reported.
Objective for processing
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and King’s College London (KCL), as joint data controllers, are requesting access to pseudonymised record-level data in order to carry out follow-up analysis based on a cohort of patients who are being recruited to a clinical trial called ‘NHS-Galleri’ following being invited to participate if they are found to meet the required eligibility criteria.
Note that members of the team running the trial are based at the Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) at King's College London. For the sake of consistency, and as King's College London is listed as a data controller, when referring to King's College London throughout the application, this encompasses the team at CPTU.
Background, Purpose and Rationale behind NHS-Galleri:
A new Multi-Cancer Early Detection (MCED) test has been developed that can detect many types of cancer from a single blood sample. This test is called Galleri (Registered Trademark). This trial aims to find out whether it is better at detecting cancer early, compared to other tests that the NHS currently uses. The purpose of NHS-Galleri is to demonstrate the clinical utility of the MCED blood test for individuals in a general screening population in a real world NHS setting. The rationale behind this trial is that MCED is a novel screening paradigm, and assessment of the use and impact of test results is necessary to enable integration into clinical practice. This will be the first randomised, double blind, controlled trial statistically powered to assess clinical utility of a MCED test.
Recruitment to the trial has been aided by NHS Digital's Digi-Trials team via a sister application, DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H, and took place over 10 – 12 months from August 2021 with a recruitment target of 140,000 people. Recruitment successfully completed and the target was met. Different geographic areas were targeted for recruitment, beginning with North-west England. Recruitment in a particular area lasted for 4 – 6 weeks, before moving on to another area. Recruitment was managed through mobile units on scheduled routes around a particular area. Batches of invitations were constructed to target whatever area the mobile units were in at the time of writing out to potential participants. Potential participants were only contacted once and there were no follow-ups sent after the original invitation letter.
Requesting Not to Take Part in Trial:
In addition to the National Data Opt-out, members of the public were able to specifically request not to be contacted for the NHS-Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd promoted this information via the dedicated trial website (nhs-galleri.org) and NHS Digital did the same via a dedicated page on its website (https://digital.nhs.uk/services/nhs-digitrials/nhs-galleri-trial). There was also an option for people to register their request not to take part in NHS-Galleri by telephone. NHS Digital records these requests not to take part and ensure that anyone who has registered for this will be excluded from the cohort selection and as a result their details will not be on the list for invitations to be sent.
Objectives of the Trial:
• Primary Objective:
- For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual test and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a. For a prespecified group of cancer types, including lung, head and neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver / bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary and bladder.
b. For all cancer types, excluding prostate cancer.
c. For all cancer types.
• Secondary Objectives:
1) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of advanced cancers (defined as a cancer diagnosed at stage III or IV or one that results in a cancer-specific death) in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a) First, evaluate for a statistically significant difference in a prespecified group of primary cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
b) If a statistically significant reduction in absolute numbers is found, continue by evaluating for a difference in all cancer types excluding prostate cancer.
c) If the above evaluations are both significant, evaluate for a difference in all cancer types.
2) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a difference in the proportion of stage I and II cancers between the two arms of the study in the third testing round (i.e. for cancers diagnosed with an average 16-18 months of follow-up after the third test).
3) Evaluate the performance (overall sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three intervals of testing.
4) Evaluate the safety, including harms, of the testing pathway in the intervention arm among individuals with positive MCED test results.
a) Assess participant-reported anxiety among those receiving a positive MCED test result following the initial blood draw at various time points.
b) Examine the radiation exposure by participants associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures following a positive MCED test result
c) Describe the number and type of invasive procedures performed, and number of complications and deaths associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures.
5) Determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following the initial screening round and 12 months of follow-up (excluding cancers identified by the test performed at the 12-month visit)
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer;
c) For all cancer types.
6) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer
c) For all cancer types.
7) Determine whether there is a statistically significant difference in cancer detection rates in the two arms of the study with 12 months follow-up after the first test.
8) Model the expected differences in cancer-specific mortality at 7 years post-randomisation based on cancers diagnosed within an average of 40-42 months of randomisation.
9) Summarize stage distribution per cancer type for the two arms, and compare the absolute numbers of stage IV alone as well as stage III and IV cancers, following the third screening and an average 16-18* months of follow-up.
10) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers, excluding breast, cervical, and colorectal (i.e., those without a standard of care screening modality) as compared to the control arm following the third annual screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up.
11) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms following the third screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, for a pre-specified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
12) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms for all cancer types at
a) 3 years and
b) 6 years after the last study visit.
13) Compare the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers following the second blood draw and 12 months of follow-up, with prevalent cases excluded.
14) Compare the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers following the third blood draw and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, with cases from the first and second screenings excluded.
15) Assess the impact of use of the MCED test across three annual timepoints on healthcare resource utilization for cancer diagnosis and treatment.
16) Assess the potential impact of overdiagnosis by comparing the cumulative incidence (Kaplan-Meier curves) of cancers diagnosed after a positive baseline MCED test up to 36-48 months after randomization between the intervention and control arms (retrospectively testing baseline samples from all participants diagnosed with cancer in the control arm).
DATA SETS REQUESTED:
> Rapid Registrations Cancer Data Set
> Cancer Registry
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT)
> Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS)
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC)
> HES Outpatients (OP)
> Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT)
> Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) (To be released Summer 2022 onward)
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) (To be released Summer 2022 onward)
FREQUENCY - every 6 months beginning March 2022 (Rapid Registrations every 2 months from March 2022).
************** CHANGES FROM AUGUST 2022 (Version 2 of this agreement) **************
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) - no change
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC) - no change
> HES Outpatients (OP) - no change
> Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT) - no change
> Radiotherapy Data Set – No change
> Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) - Released August 2022 on bi-annual basis as planned.
> Rapid Registrations Cancer Data Set - Rapid Registrations will be provided every month rather than every two months from August 2022 to enable frequent monitoring of cancer diagnoses in the study.
> Cancer Registry - will be provided every month rather than every other month from August 2022 to enable frequent reporting of cancer diagnoses in the study and use the data as a filter for participant invitations for annual follow up timepoints. Expand historic gold standard registration field selection for 1995-2021 and addition of field to allow the trial team to distinguish provisional from finalised gold standard tumours. These changes are required for primary and secondary analysis. Data will be used to characterize the cohort for risk factors (prior cancers), and also assess test performance in a subpopulation of cancer survivors. The Status of Registration is required to enable accurate reporting and filtering of provisional data vs finalized data to internal and external stakeholders, and the interim analysis in the study. Death fields added to dataset specification for analysis of key secondary endpoints in the study. Death data will also be used for reporting subject disposition in the analysis. Death data, while requested with the cancer registry data, should include information on all participants in the cohort (including participants that have not been diagnosed with cancer).
**************
JUSTIFICATION FOR DATA SETS REQUESTED AND DATA MINIMISATION
> Cancer Registry and Rapid Registrations - These central NHS datasets will be the sole source for the data required for primary and secondary objectives analyses in the Study. Will be used to identify Primary endpoints, which are incidence and stage at diagnosis for cancer types that are stage-able (e.g., with available staging systems). Cancer is defined as any of the following cancers:
- Invasive solid cancer, excluding non-melanoma skin cancer
- Haematologic malignancies, including lymphoma, lymphoid leukemia, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, myeloid neoplasms (including myelodysplastic and myeloproliferative neoplasms with behaviour code 3 based on ICD-O-3.2*).
[*The International Classification of Diseases for Oncology, Third Edition (ICD-O-3) is the standard classification system for the registration of cancers in the United States (and most areas of the world) and contains widely-accepted histologic categories of brain tumors.]
The Cancer Registry will also be used to identify cohort characteristics/baseline risk - Personal history of cancer assessed using limited set of data fields. Historical cancer data dating back to 1995 will be available.
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Outpatients (OP), Admitted Patient Care (APC) and Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS), Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT) and Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Will be used to identify Secondary endpoints (including safety objectives). Among all test positive cases, number of follow-up procedures and number of invasive procedures (including all biopsies, surgical interventions, bronchoscopy, thoracoscopy and endoscopy) to achieve diagnostic resolution (i.e. cancer diagnosis, non-cancer diagnosis, or no diagnosis and discharge from the diagnostic follow-up). Will also identify:
- Number and type of invasive procedures performed in false positive cases;
- Number of complications and deaths resulting from diagnostic procedures;
- Radiation exposure measured in mSv per participant due to test result-directed evaluations
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) and Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS) will also be used (in addition to the above HES, CWT and DIDs data) for health care resource utilization objectives.
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPI&E)
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to develop the participant facing materials and on questionnaires, and including specific questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised data with GRAIL LLC (US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials, survey feedback on the participant experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in the Kings College London Cancer
Prevention Trials Unit has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trail, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously, strategies for equity of access and has several plans underway to ensure that under-represented minorities are actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, that will identify and actively send invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
GDPR Legal Basis for the Processing of Personal Data:
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as joint Data Controller, is using Article 6(1)(f) "processing is necessary for the purposes of the legitimate interests pursued by the controller or by a third party except where such interests are overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject which require protection of personal data, in particular where the data subject is a child." Processing personal data is necessary for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd’s legitimate interests which are described in this application. The data to which access is requested are proportionate and necessary to achieve those interests. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has completed a legitimate interests assessment (LIA) and NHS Digital are satisfied that the interests of the data subjects do not override their legitimate interests; that they would reasonably expect the processing and it would not cause unjustified harm. The data subjects interests and fundamental rights are protected through appropriate minimisation of fields and patient records being processed; protection of the data in a secure environment, and guaranteeing secure destruction at any stage at the request of NHS Digital or after a defined period on completion of the project.
Additionally (as health data is a special category of Personal Data), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd is using Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
King’s College London, as joint Data Controller, is using Article 6:1(e): Specific task in the ‘public interest’ or task that has a clear basis in law, and additionally (as health data is a special category of Personal Data) Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
Organisation Roles and Responsibilities:
• GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are a joint Data Controller and Lead for this agreement, who also process the data. It is responsible for sponsoring and funding the trial, as well as the building and maintenance of the Clinical Records Management System.
• King’s College London are a joint Data Controller who also process the data and are responsible for implementing the trial and for primary objective analysis.
• GRAIL, Limited Liability Company (LLC). are the manufacturers of the MCED test, Galleri (Registered Trademark), and has set up the above UK subsidiary, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, which is the sponsor of the NHS-Galleri trial. GRAIL, LLC will be receiving pseudonymised record-level NHS Digital data from King’s College London, and are therefore listed as a Data Processor in this agreement.
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that King’s College London Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller.
In the future, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd may receive commercial benefit (including intangible or indirect commercial benefits such as positive publicity) from the successful outcomes of the trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and the NHS have entered into a partnership whereby the Galleri test will be piloted in clinical trials within the NHS in England. If the test is shown to work as intended in these clinical trials, the NHS may purchase the test from GRAIL and make the test routinely available in the future to benefit patient.
Expected output
All outputs will be aggregated with small number suppressed as per the HES analysis guide or according to the specific data set's suppression guidance.
The results of the NHS-Galleri trial outputs will be published in peer-reviewed publications, presented at conferences, and used by NHS England in their decisions around implementation of the test within the NHS. The interim analysis, which will include analysis of a key secondary objective, is expected by the end of 2023 or beginning of 2024. The primary objective readout is expected by the end of 2025 or beginning of 2026. Planned dissemination activities will aim to enable the engagement with the scientific and policy making communities to ensure that knowledge developed by this research can benefit these communities to help the NHS detect cancer early, when it is easier to treat.
Benefits reported
-
DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v1.2 30 March 2022 to 29 March 2030
- Title
- NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request
- Commercial
- Yes
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 9
- Files released
- 0
Datasets: Cancer Registration Data; Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) Data Set; Diagnostic Imaging Data Set (DID); Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS); Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC); Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP); Radiotherapy Data Set; Rapid Cancer Registrations Data Set; Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set
What changed from DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v0.4
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Title | NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request | |
| Start date | 2022-03-30 | |
| End date | 2030-03-29 |
Objective for processing
[3 paragraphs unchanged]
A new Multi-Cancer Early Detection (MCED) test has been developed that can detect many types of cancer from a single blood sample. This test is called
Galleri™ and this
Galleri (Registered Trademark). This
trial aims to find out whether it is better at discovering cancer
[77 words unchanged]
controlled trial statistically powered to assess clinical utility of a MCED test.
[72 paragraphs unchanged]
• GRAIL, Limited Liability Company (LLC). are the manufacturers of the MCED test,
Galleri™,
Galleri (Registered Trademark),
and has set up the above UK subsidiary, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd,
[21 words unchanged]
London, and are therefore listed as a Data Processor in this agreement.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
In the future, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd may receive commercial benefit (including
[18 words unchanged]
UK Ltd and the NHS have entered into a partnership whereby the
Galleri™
Galleri
test will be piloted in clinical trials within the NHS in England.
[21 words unchanged]
and make the test routinely available in the future to benefit patient.
Processing activities
[7 paragraphs unchanged]
***FREQUENCY - every 6 months beginning March 2022 (Rapid Registrations every 2 months from
January
March
2022). ***
[15 paragraphs unchanged]
Unchanged: Expected output, Expected measurable benefits, Benefits reported.
Objective for processing
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and King’s College London (KCL), as joint data controllers, are requesting access to pseudonymised record-level data in order to carry out follow-up analysis based on a cohort of patients who are being recruited to a clinical trial called ‘NHS-Galleri’ following being invited to participate if they are found to meet the required eligibility criteria.
Note that all members of the team running the trial are based at the Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) at King's College London. For the sake of consistency, and as King's College London is listed as a data controller, when referring to King's College London throughout the application, this encompasses the team at CPTU.
Background, Purpose and Rationale behind NHS-Galleri:
A new Multi-Cancer Early Detection (MCED) test has been developed that can detect many types of cancer from a single blood sample. This test is called Galleri (Registered Trademark). This trial aims to find out whether it is better at discovering cancer early, compared to other tests that the NHS currently uses. The purpose of NHS-Galleri is to demonstrate the clinical utility of the MCED blood test for individuals in a general screening population in a real world NHS setting. The rationale behind this trial is that MCED is a novel screening paradigm, and assessment of the use and impact of test results is necessary to enable integration into clinical practice. This will be the first randomised, double blind, controlled trial statistically powered to assess clinical utility of a MCED test.
Recruitment to the trial is being aided by NHS Digital's Digi-Trials team via a sister application, DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H, and is taking place over 10 – 12 months from August 2021 with a recruitment target of 140,000 people. Different areas are being targeted for recruitment, beginning with North-west England. Recruitment in a particular area will last for 4 – 6 weeks, before moving on to another area. Recruitment is being managed through mobile units on scheduled routes around a particular area. Batches of invitations are being constructed to target whatever area the mobile units will be in at the time of writing out to potential participants. Potential participants will only be contacted once and there will be no follow-ups sent after the original invitation letter.
Requesting Not to Take Part in Trial:
In addition to the National Data Opt-out, members of the public are able to specifically request not to be contacted for the NHS-Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd have promoted this information via the dedicated trial website (nhs-galleri.org) and NHS Digital have done the same via a dedicated page on its website (https://digital.nhs.uk/services/nhs-digitrials/nhs-galleri-trial). There is also an option for people to register their request not to take part in NHS-Galleri by telephone. NHS Digital is recording these requests not to take part and ensuring that anyone who has registered for this will be excluded from the cohort selection and as a result their details will not be on the list for invitations to be sent.
Objectives of the Trial:
• Primary Objective:
- For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual test and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a. For a prespecified group of cancer types, including lung, head and neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver / bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary and bladder.
b. For all cancer types, excluding prostate cancer.
c. For all cancer types.
• Secondary Objectives:
1) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of advanced cancers (defined as a cancer diagnosed at stage III or IV or one that results in a cancer-specific death) in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a) First, evaluate for a statistically significant difference in a prespecified group of primary cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
b) If a statistically significant reduction in absolute numbers is found, continue by evaluating for a difference in all cancer types excluding prostate cancer.
c) If the above evaluations are both significant, evaluate for a difference in all cancer types.
2) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a difference in the proportion of stage I and II cancers between the two arms of the study in the third testing round (i.e. for cancers diagnosed with an average 16-18 months of follow-up after the third test).
3) Evaluate the performance (overall sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three intervals of testing.
4) Evaluate the safety, including harms, of the testing pathway in the intervention arm among individuals with positive MCED test results.
a) Assess participant-reported anxiety among those receiving a positive MCED test result following the initial blood draw at various time points.
b) Examine the radiation exposure by participants associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures following a positive MCED test result
c) Describe the number and type of invasive procedures performed, and number of complications and deaths associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures.
5) Determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following the initial screening round and 12 months of follow-up (excluding cancers identified by the test performed at the 12-month visit)
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer;
c) For all cancer types.
6) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer
c) For all cancer types.
7) Determine whether there is a statistically significant difference in cancer detection rates in the two arms of the study with 12 months follow-up after the first test.
8) Model the expected differences in cancer-specific mortality at 7 years post-randomisation based on cancers diagnosed within an average of 40-42 months of randomisation.
9) Summarize stage distribution per cancer type for the two arms, and compare the absolute numbers of stage IV alone as well as stage III and IV cancers, following the third screening and an average 16-18* months of follow-up.
10) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers, excluding breast, cervical, and colorectal (i.e., those without a standard of care screening modality) as compared to the control arm following the third annual screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up.
11) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms following the third screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, for a pre-specified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
12) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms for all cancer types at
a) 3 years and
b) 6 years after the last study visit.
13) Compare the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers following the second blood draw and 12 months of follow-up, with prevalent cases excluded.
14) Compare the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers following the third blood draw and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, with cases from the first and second screenings excluded.
15) Assess the impact of use of the MCED test across three annual timepoints on healthcare resource utilization for cancer diagnosis and treatment.
16) Assess the potential impact of overdiagnosis by comparing the cumulative incidence (Kaplan-Meier curves) of cancers diagnosed after a positive baseline MCED test up to 36-48 months after randomization between the intervention and control arms (retrospectively testing baseline samples from all participants diagnosed with cancer in the control arm).
DATA SETS REQUESTED:
> Rapid Registrations Cancer Data Set
> Cancer Registry
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT)
> Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS)
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC)
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) (released Summer 2022 onwards)
> HES Outpatients (OP)
> Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT)
> Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) (released Summer 2022 onwards)
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPI&E)
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to develop the participant facing materials and on questionnaires, and including specific questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised data with GRAIL LLC (US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials, survey feedback on the participant experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in the Kings College London Cancer
Prevention Trials Unit has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trail, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously, strategies for equity of access and has several plans underway to ensure that under-represented minorities are actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, that will identify and actively send invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
JUSTIFICATION FOR DATA SETS REQUESTED AND DATA MINIMISATION
> Cancer Registry and Rapid Registrations - These central NHS datasets will be the sole source for the data required for primary and secondary objectives analyses in the Study. Will be used to identify Primary endpoints, which are incidence and stage at diagnosis for cancer types that are stage-able (e.g., with available staging systems). Cancer is defined as any of the following cancers:
- Invasive solid cancer, excluding non-melanoma skin cancer
- Haematologic malignancies, including lymphoma, lymphoid leukemia, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, myeloid neoplasms (including myelodysplastic and myeloproliferative neoplasms with behaviour code 3 based on ICD-O-3.2*).
[*The International Classification of Diseases for Oncology, Third Edition (ICD-O-3) is the standard classification system for the registration of cancers in the United States (and most areas of the world) and contains widely-accepted histologic categories of brain tumors.]
The Cancer Registry will also be used to identify cohort characteristics/baseline risk - Personal history of cancer assessed using limited set of data fields. Historical cancer data dating back to 1995 will be available.
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Outpatients (OP), Admitted Patient Care (APC) and Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS), Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT) and Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Will be used to identify Secondary endpoints (including safety objectives). Among all test positive cases, number of follow-up procedures and number of invasive procedures (including all biopsies, surgical interventions, bronchoscopy, thoracoscopy and endoscopy) to achieve diagnostic resolution (i.e. cancer diagnosis, non-cancer diagnosis, or no diagnosis and discharge from the diagnostic follow-up). Will also identify:
- Number and type of invasive procedures performed in false positive cases;
- Number of complications and deaths resulting from diagnostic procedures;
- Radiation exposure measured in mSv per participant due to test result-directed evaluations
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) and Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS) will also be used (in addition to the above HES, CWT and DIDs data) for health care resource utilization objectives.
GDPR Legal Basis for the Processing of Personal Data:
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as joint Data Controller, is using Article 6(1)(f) "processing is necessary for the purposes of the legitimate interests pursued by the controller or by a third party except where such interests are overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject which require protection of personal data, in particular where the data subject is a child." Processing personal data is necessary for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd’s legitimate interests which are described in this application. The data to which access is requested are proportionate and necessary to achieve those interests. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has completed a legitimate interests assessment (LIA) and NHS Digital are satisfied that the interests of the data subjects do not override their legitimate interests; that they would reasonably expect the processing and it would not cause unjustified harm. The data subjects interests and fundamental rights are protected through appropriate minimisation of fields and patient records being processed; protection of the data in a secure environment, and guaranteeing secure destruction at any stage at the request of NHS Digital or after a defined period on completion of the project.
Additionally (as health data is a special category of Personal Data), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd is using Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
King’s College London, as joint Data Controller, is using Article 6:1(e): Specific task in the ‘public interest’ or task that has a clear basis in law, and additionally (as health data is a special category of Personal Data) Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
Organisation Roles and Responsibilities:
• GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are a joint Data Controller and Lead for this agreement, who also process the data. It is responsible for sponsoring and funding the trial, as well as the building and maintenance of the Clinical Records Management System.
• King’s College London are a joint Data Controller who also process the data and are responsible for implementing the trial and for primary objective analysis.
• GRAIL, Limited Liability Company (LLC). are the manufacturers of the MCED test, Galleri (Registered Trademark), and has set up the above UK subsidiary, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, which is the sponsor of the NHS-Galleri trial. GRAIL, LLC will be receiving pseudonymised record-level NHS Digital data from King’s College London, and are therefore listed as a Data Processor in this agreement.
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that King’s College London Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller.
In the future, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd may receive commercial benefit (including intangible or indirect commercial benefits such as positive publicity) from the successful outcomes of the trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and the NHS have entered into a partnership whereby the Galleri test will be piloted in clinical trials within the NHS in England. If the test is shown to work as intended in these clinical trials, the NHS may purchase the test from GRAIL and make the test routinely available in the future to benefit patient.
Expected output
All outputs will be aggregated with small number suppressed as per the HES analysis guide or according to the specific data set's suppression guidance.
The results of the NHS-Galleri trial outputs will be published in peer-reviewed publications, presented at conferences, and used by NHS England in their decisions around implementation of the test within the NHS. The interim analysis, which will include analysis of a key secondary objective, is expected by the end of 2023 or beginning of 2024. The primary objective readout is expected by the end of 2025 or beginning of 2026. Planned dissemination activities will aim to enable the engagement with the scientific and policy making communities to ensure that knowledge developed by this research can benefit these communities to help the NHS detect cancer early, when it is easier to treat.
Benefits reported
-
DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v0.4 9 February 2022 to 8 February 2023
- Title
- GRAIL's NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request
- Commercial
- Yes
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 9
- Files released
- 0
Datasets: Cancer Registration Data; Cancer Waiting Times (CWT) Data Set; Diagnostic Imaging Data Set (DID); Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS); Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC); Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP); Radiotherapy Data Set; Rapid Cancer Registrations Data Set; Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set
Objective for processing
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and King’s College London (KCL), as joint data controllers, are requesting access to pseudonymised record-level data in order to carry out follow-up analysis based on a cohort of patients who are being recruited to a clinical trial called ‘NHS-Galleri’ following being invited to participate if they are found to meet the required eligibility criteria.
Note that all members of the team running the trial are based at the Cancer Prevention Trials Unit (CPTU) at King's College London. For the sake of consistency, and as King's College London is listed as a data controller, when referring to King's College London throughout the application, this encompasses the team at CPTU.
Background, Purpose and Rationale behind NHS-Galleri:
A new Multi-Cancer Early Detection (MCED) test has been developed that can detect many types of cancer from a single blood sample. This test is called Galleri™ and this trial aims to find out whether it is better at discovering cancer early, compared to other tests that the NHS currently uses. The purpose of NHS-Galleri is to demonstrate the clinical utility of the MCED blood test for individuals in a general screening population in a real world NHS setting. The rationale behind this trial is that MCED is a novel screening paradigm, and assessment of the use and impact of test results is necessary to enable integration into clinical practice. This will be the first randomised, double blind, controlled trial statistically powered to assess clinical utility of a MCED test.
Recruitment to the trial is being aided by NHS Digital's Digi-Trials team via a sister application, DARS-NIC-456778-J0G3H, and is taking place over 10 – 12 months from August 2021 with a recruitment target of 140,000 people. Different areas are being targeted for recruitment, beginning with North-west England. Recruitment in a particular area will last for 4 – 6 weeks, before moving on to another area. Recruitment is being managed through mobile units on scheduled routes around a particular area. Batches of invitations are being constructed to target whatever area the mobile units will be in at the time of writing out to potential participants. Potential participants will only be contacted once and there will be no follow-ups sent after the original invitation letter.
Requesting Not to Take Part in Trial:
In addition to the National Data Opt-out, members of the public are able to specifically request not to be contacted for the NHS-Galleri Trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd have promoted this information via the dedicated trial website (nhs-galleri.org) and NHS Digital have done the same via a dedicated page on its website (https://digital.nhs.uk/services/nhs-digitrials/nhs-galleri-trial). There is also an option for people to register their request not to take part in NHS-Galleri by telephone. NHS Digital is recording these requests not to take part and ensuring that anyone who has registered for this will be excluded from the cohort selection and as a result their details will not be on the list for invitations to be sent.
Objectives of the Trial:
• Primary Objective:
- For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual test and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a. For a prespecified group of cancer types, including lung, head and neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver / bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary and bladder.
b. For all cancer types, excluding prostate cancer.
c. For all cancer types.
• Secondary Objectives:
1) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of advanced cancers (defined as a cancer diagnosed at stage III or IV or one that results in a cancer-specific death) in the intervention arm as compared to the control arm following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test, using a fixed-sequence strategy as below:
a) First, evaluate for a statistically significant difference in a prespecified group of primary cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
b) If a statistically significant reduction in absolute numbers is found, continue by evaluating for a difference in all cancer types excluding prostate cancer.
c) If the above evaluations are both significant, evaluate for a difference in all cancer types.
2) For cancers that are routinely staged, determine whether there is a difference in the proportion of stage I and II cancers between the two arms of the study in the third testing round (i.e. for cancers diagnosed with an average 16-18 months of follow-up after the third test).
3) Evaluate the performance (overall sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and cancer signal origin accuracy) of the MCED test in the intervention arm after each annual round of testing and in aggregate across the three intervals of testing.
4) Evaluate the safety, including harms, of the testing pathway in the intervention arm among individuals with positive MCED test results.
a) Assess participant-reported anxiety among those receiving a positive MCED test result following the initial blood draw at various time points.
b) Examine the radiation exposure by participants associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures following a positive MCED test result
c) Describe the number and type of invasive procedures performed, and number of complications and deaths associated with follow-up diagnostic procedures.
5) Determine whether there is a statistically significant reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following the initial screening round and 12 months of follow-up (excluding cancers identified by the test performed at the 12-month visit)
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer;
c) For all cancer types.
6) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers diagnosed in the intervention arm compared to the control arm, following three annual tests and an average of 16-18 months follow-up after the third test
a) For a prespecified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder;
b) For all cancer types excluding prostate cancer
c) For all cancer types.
7) Determine whether there is a statistically significant difference in cancer detection rates in the two arms of the study with 12 months follow-up after the first test.
8) Model the expected differences in cancer-specific mortality at 7 years post-randomisation based on cancers diagnosed within an average of 40-42 months of randomisation.
9) Summarize stage distribution per cancer type for the two arms, and compare the absolute numbers of stage IV alone as well as stage III and IV cancers, following the third screening and an average 16-18* months of follow-up.
10) Determine whether there is a reduction in the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers, excluding breast, cervical, and colorectal (i.e., those without a standard of care screening modality) as compared to the control arm following the third annual screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up.
11) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms following the third screening and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, for a pre-specified group of cancer types: lung, head & neck, colorectal, pancreas, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, liver/bile duct, stomach, oesophagus, anus, lymphoma, ovary, and bladder.
12) Compare cancer-specific mortality in the intervention and control arms for all cancer types at
a) 3 years and
b) 6 years after the last study visit.
13) Compare the absolute numbers of stage IV cancers following the second blood draw and 12 months of follow-up, with prevalent cases excluded.
14) Compare the absolute numbers of stage III and IV cancers following the third blood draw and an average 16-18 months of follow-up, with cases from the first and second screenings excluded.
15) Assess the impact of use of the MCED test across three annual timepoints on healthcare resource utilization for cancer diagnosis and treatment.
16) Assess the potential impact of overdiagnosis by comparing the cumulative incidence (Kaplan-Meier curves) of cancers diagnosed after a positive baseline MCED test up to 36-48 months after randomization between the intervention and control arms (retrospectively testing baseline samples from all participants diagnosed with cancer in the control arm).
DATA SETS REQUESTED:
> Rapid Registrations Cancer Data Set
> Cancer Registry
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT)
> Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS)
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Admitted Patient Care (APC)
> Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) (released Summer 2022 onwards)
> HES Outpatients (OP)
> Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT)
> Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) (released Summer 2022 onwards)
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPI&E)
Ongoing PPI&E is conducted throughout the trial. Historical PPI&E was conducted to develop the participant facing materials and on questionnaires, and including specific questions to PPI groups around the sharing of pseudonymised data with GRAIL LLC (US). Ongoing PPI&E includes, for example, PPI&E on new participant facing materials, survey feedback on the participant experience, and questionnaires for follow-up of participants. An embedded behavioural scientist in the Kings College London Cancer
Prevention Trials Unit has been involved in, and will continue to be involved in, analysis of participant communications, and ethical and wellbeing issues within the course of the trail, as well as periodically advise the study organizers and other stakeholder on emerging themes.
In the setting up of the trial, GRAIL has taken seriously, strategies for equity of access and has several plans underway to ensure that under-represented minorities are actively recruited into the trial. Amongst this is the invitation strategy, that will identify and actively send invitations to a greater proportion of individuals from these minorities to take part in the trial. It is hoped that this will positively contribute towards equity of access and inform the provision of cancer services in these areas in the future.
JUSTIFICATION FOR DATA SETS REQUESTED AND DATA MINIMISATION
> Cancer Registry and Rapid Registrations - These central NHS datasets will be the sole source for the data required for primary and secondary objectives analyses in the Study. Will be used to identify Primary endpoints, which are incidence and stage at diagnosis for cancer types that are stage-able (e.g., with available staging systems). Cancer is defined as any of the following cancers:
- Invasive solid cancer, excluding non-melanoma skin cancer
- Haematologic malignancies, including lymphoma, lymphoid leukemia, myeloma/plasma cell neoplasm, myeloid neoplasms (including myelodysplastic and myeloproliferative neoplasms with behaviour code 3 based on ICD-O-3.2*).
[*The International Classification of Diseases for Oncology, Third Edition (ICD-O-3) is the standard classification system for the registration of cancers in the United States (and most areas of the world) and contains widely-accepted histologic categories of brain tumors.]
The Cancer Registry will also be used to identify cohort characteristics/baseline risk - Personal history of cancer assessed using limited set of data fields. Historical cancer data dating back to 1995 will be available.
> Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) Outpatients (OP), Admitted Patient Care (APC) and Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS), Cancer Waiting Times (Treatments and Referrals) (CWT) and Diagnostic Imaging Dataset (DIDS) - Will be used to identify Secondary endpoints (including safety objectives). Among all test positive cases, number of follow-up procedures and number of invasive procedures (including all biopsies, surgical interventions, bronchoscopy, thoracoscopy and endoscopy) to achieve diagnostic resolution (i.e. cancer diagnosis, non-cancer diagnosis, or no diagnosis and discharge from the diagnostic follow-up). Will also identify:
- Number and type of invasive procedures performed in false positive cases;
- Number of complications and deaths resulting from diagnostic procedures;
- Radiation exposure measured in mSv per participant due to test result-directed evaluations
> Systemic Anti-Cancer Therapy Data Set (SACT) and Radiotherapy Data set (RTDS) will also be used (in addition to the above HES, CWT and DIDs data) for health care resource utilization objectives.
GDPR Legal Basis for the Processing of Personal Data:
GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, as joint Data Controller, is using Article 6(1)(f) "processing is necessary for the purposes of the legitimate interests pursued by the controller or by a third party except where such interests are overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject which require protection of personal data, in particular where the data subject is a child." Processing personal data is necessary for GRAIL Bio UK Ltd’s legitimate interests which are described in this application. The data to which access is requested are proportionate and necessary to achieve those interests. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd has completed a legitimate interests assessment (LIA) and NHS Digital are satisfied that the interests of the data subjects do not override their legitimate interests; that they would reasonably expect the processing and it would not cause unjustified harm. The data subjects interests and fundamental rights are protected through appropriate minimisation of fields and patient records being processed; protection of the data in a secure environment, and guaranteeing secure destruction at any stage at the request of NHS Digital or after a defined period on completion of the project.
Additionally (as health data is a special category of Personal Data), GRAIL Bio UK Ltd is using Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
King’s College London, as joint Data Controller, is using Article 6:1(e): Specific task in the ‘public interest’ or task that has a clear basis in law, and additionally (as health data is a special category of Personal Data) Article 9:2(j): Special category data used for “Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research or statistical purposes”, with a basis in law.
Organisation Roles and Responsibilities:
• GRAIL Bio UK Ltd are a joint Data Controller and Lead for this agreement, who also process the data. It is responsible for sponsoring and funding the trial, as well as the building and maintenance of the Clinical Records Management System.
• King’s College London are a joint Data Controller who also process the data and are responsible for implementing the trial and for primary objective analysis.
• GRAIL, Limited Liability Company (LLC). are the manufacturers of the MCED test, Galleri™, and has set up the above UK subsidiary, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd, which is the sponsor of the NHS-Galleri trial. GRAIL, LLC will be receiving pseudonymised record-level NHS Digital data from King’s College London, and are therefore listed as a Data Processor in this agreement.
NHS England are listed as a strategic partner in relation to NHS-Galleri, but have no input into how the trial is run or determining the outcome. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller. Cancer Research UK appear on trial-related documentation by virtue of the fact that King’s College London Cancer Prevention Trials Unit are a Cancer Research UK Trials Unit. Cancer Research UK as an organisation in their own right have no involvement in the running of the trial, nor are they funding any of the trial activities. NHS Digital therefore do not consider them to be a Data Controller.
In the future, GRAIL Bio UK Ltd may receive commercial benefit (including intangible or indirect commercial benefits such as positive publicity) from the successful outcomes of the trial. GRAIL Bio UK Ltd and the NHS have entered into a partnership whereby the Galleri™ test will be piloted in clinical trials within the NHS in England. If the test is shown to work as intended in these clinical trials, the NHS may purchase the test from GRAIL and make the test routinely available in the future to benefit patient.
Expected output
All outputs will be aggregated with small number suppressed as per the HES analysis guide or according to the specific data set's suppression guidance.
The results of the NHS-Galleri trial outputs will be published in peer-reviewed publications, presented at conferences, and used by NHS England in their decisions around implementation of the test within the NHS. The interim analysis, which will include analysis of a key secondary objective, is expected by the end of 2023 or beginning of 2024. The primary objective readout is expected by the end of 2025 or beginning of 2026. Planned dissemination activities will aim to enable the engagement with the scientific and policy making communities to ensure that knowledge developed by this research can benefit these communities to help the NHS detect cancer early, when it is easier to treat.
Benefits reported
-
Register history
When this agreement appeared in, or was edited in, each monthly edition of the register. Built by comparing every edition this site holds.
-
March 2022 —
first listed. 1 version: DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v0.4
-
May 2022
1 version added: DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v1.2
-
September 2022
1 version added: DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v2.2
-
February 2023
1 version added: DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v3.2
-
April 2023
1 version added: DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v4.2
-
January 2024
1 version added: DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v5.2
-
January 2025
1 version added: DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v6.4
-
December 2025
1 version added: DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L-v7.2
Cite this page
NHS England (2026) Data Uses Register, September 2026 edition, agreement DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L, “NHS Galleri Clinical Trial Outcomes Data Request”. Read via NHS Data Access Explorer (unofficial), https://healthdatauses.uk/agreements/dars-nic-604847-s4b5l/ (accessed [date]).
This address stays the same, but the page is rebuilt with each monthly edition, so the citation names the edition it shows. Every edition's data is kept in the facts store.
Source: datausesregister_september2026.xlsx, September 2026 edition of the NHS England Data Uses Register. Search that workbook for DARS-NIC-604847-S4B5L to see the original rows.