General Health & Hospital Admissions in Children Born after ART; A Population Based Linkage Study
University College London (UCL) · Academic
In term In term in the September 2026 edition: the latest version runs to 25 February 2027.
- Reference
- DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5
- Current version
- v6.3
- Term of current version
- 26 February 2024 to 25 February 2027
- Start date
- Before 10 July 2018
- Data controller
- Sole Data Controller
- Commercial purposes
- No
- Sublicensing
- No
- Files released to date
- 1
Why the data was released
Objective for processing
University College London (UCL) requires access to data on maternal age at the time of birth for the existing study cohorts, consisting of children conceived after Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls.
Maternal age at the time of birth has been shown to significantly influence health outcomes in children. For example, several studies have shown that teenage pregnancies often result in infants with lower birth-weight, a greater risk of intrauterine growth restriction, preterm delivery and other adverse outcomes. While older maternal age is often associated with increased risk of preterm delivery, abnormal foetal presentation (such as spontaneous breech presentation), neonatal intraventricular haemorrhage, and increased risk of maternal cardiometabolic disease.
The aim of the study is to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls. Therefore, in this context, adjustment for key confounding factors such as maternal age at the time of birth is essential, particularly when analysing differences between ART and naturally conceived children in order to elucidate relative contribution of ART treatments and parental characteristics towards perinatal risks.
This project has already yielded the three cohorts mentioned above, and initial data management has been completed.
UCL is the controller as the organisation responsible for ensuring that the data will only be processed for the purpose described above.
The lawful basis for processing personal data under the UK GDPR is:
Article 6(1)(e) - processing is necessary for the performance of a task carried out in the public interest or in the exercise of official authority vested in the controller;
The lawful basis for processing special category data under the UK GDPR is:
Article 9(2)(j) - processing is necessary for archiving purposes in the public interest, scientific or historical research purposes or statistical purposes in accordance with Article 89(1) based on Union or Member State law which shall be proportionate to the aim pursued, respect the essence of the right to data protection and provide for suitable and specific measures to safeguard the fundamental rights and the interests of the data subject.
It is in the public interest because the programme of research facilitates the conduct of clinically relevant research into establishing if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
Amazon Web Services (AWS) is a processor acting under the instructions of UCL. AWS’ role is limited to secure back-up of data stored in UCL’s Data Safe Haven.
UCL uses offsite data centre services provided by VIRTUS data centre. VIRTUS does not have access to the data.
UCL (Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health) aim to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
The diagnoses which are to be investigated include:
a) Complications of Prematurity (such as respiratory distress syndrome, necrotizing enterocolitis, retinopathy of prematurity, intra-ventricular haemorrahges, per-ventricular leucomalacia)
b) Cerebral palsy
c) Congenital malformations
d) Asthma and allergic disease
e) Developmental delay/ and neuro-developmental problems
f) Death
g) Hospitalization rates and length of stay
These comparisons will help to provide robust risk estimates for this ever growing population. This is important as all of these potential risks have been suggested by previous research but have never been confirmed, as previous studies lacked the necessary power and design to do so.
The study cohorts, Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls, have been created using the criteria described in section 5b. The cohort numbers are 86,000 (ART Cohort), 23,000 (Sibling Cohort), and 172,000 (Controls Cohort).
Pseudonymised Hospital Episodes Statistics (HES) datasets (Outpatients, Admitted Patient care, Critical Care and A&E) and ONS mortality for the three study cohorts have been disseminated to UCL under a previous version of this agreement.
Manipulations carried out during ART treatment, including both supra-physiological ovarian stimulation and the manipulation of gametes and embryos in vitro, may lead to an increased risk of various adverse health outcomes in children born after ART. The Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) national database will be used to examine general health outcomes & hospital admissions (with an emphasis on long-term health outcomes e.g. burdens of peri-natal complications) in the three cohorts. Primary analyses will consider hospital admissions and recorded diagnoses, and further analyses will consider multiple admissions, length of stay and recorded medical interventions, stratifying for specific cause of infertility and type or means of assisted conception and whether conception arose from a fresh or frozen thawed embryo. Output variables will include all-cause and cause specific hospital admissions and recorded diagnoses, including all-cause and cause specific perinatal morbidity, congenital anomalies, cerebral palsy and epilepsy.
The rates of specific diagnoses will be compared to equivalent rates in both the matched and sibling control groups. In the first instance this will consider conditions chosen a priori including: Complications of Prematurity (Respiratory Distress Syndrome, Necrotising Enterocolitis, Retinopathy of Prematurity, Intra-ventricular Haemorrhage, Peri-ventricular Leucomalacia), Cerebral Palsy, Congenital malformations, Asthma, Allergic disease. Further analysis will consider multiple admissions, length of stay and recorded medical interventions. Subgroup analyses will stratify for duration and cause of parental infertility and type of ART (including fresh vs. cryopreserved cycles).
UCL does not require identifiable data from NHS England and will not pass any data on to third parties, including the HFEA.
Fertility clinics have been engaged in a campaign to inform patients of how their data may be used for research and how they could opt out. Families connected to ART have been consulted on what they would like research to achieve. These service user views are incorporated in UCL's study design.
This study is currently funded by the Wellcome Trust via an Individual Investigator Award in Science. The Wellcome Trust has no role in the design or conduct of the study, and will not be processing or accessing any data.
Processing activities
The ‘Maternal age at time of birth’ data request for the three study cohorts, is available in the Civil Registration – Births dataset.
The following processing activities have been completed:
1. NHS England will link the Civil Registration – Births dataset to the three study cohorts (consisting of children conceived after Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls).
2. NHS England will disseminate the ‘Maternal age at time of birth’ data field with the unique study ID for members of the three study cohorts to UCL.
3. UCL will match this data with the previously disseminated data from NHS England, via the unique study ID, for inclusion in the analysis.
4. The processing activities and conditions stated in this section below continue to apply (as per the previous version of this agreement).
The previous processing activities are stated below.
The data processing steps for creating the three study cohorts and dissemination the linked HES and ONS mortality is described below.
Data processing for this project has been designed to ensure that identifiable data are seen by the fewest number of people at secure locations in secure methods as possible.
A dataflow diagram has been supplied, but below is a short summary of the data flow and processes;
1. NHS England (NHSE) produces an extract of women who were treated with ART (produced from MR1208)
2. NHSE sends extract containing mothers details to ONS to match to births
3. ONS matches mothers to all births (ART children and non-ART siblings) and returns matched births to NHSE
4. HFEA sends NHSE HFEA births (containing unique ID number)
5. NHSE matches HFEA births (to ONS births and creates ART Cohort)
6. NHSE sends the ART Cohort to ONS who return two controls for each member, creating the Control Cohort. The control cohort was matched for age, sex and multiplicity.
7. NHSE links all remaining ONS births that match to HFEA mothers and creates Sibling Cohort.
8. NHSE sends member numbers of all unmatched HFEA births to UCL.
9. NHE links ART, Sibling and Control Cohorts to ONS mortality and HES data and removes identifiers
10. NHSE supplies de-identified data to UCL along with a deprivation score and unique study ID (this study ID cannot be used by UCL to re-identify).
11. UCL cleans the resulting de-identified datasets
12. UCL analyses the output
The final de-identified data-set is held securely at UCL, using UCL's data safe haven. This storage meets requirements under NHS England's Data Security and Protection Toolkit (DSPT)
Only individuals, working under appropriate supervision on behalf of data controller / processor within this agreement, who are subject to the same policies, procedures and sanctions as substantive employees will have access to the data and only for the purposes described in this document.
UCL have no requirement and will not attempt to re-identify the data.
Amazon Web Services provides cloud hosting services to UCL and will store the data as contracted by UCL. UCL uses offsite data centre services provided by VIRTUS data centre.
UCL will not share the data with any third parties.
NHS England reminds all organisations party to this agreement of the need to comply with the Data Sharing Framework Contract requirements, including those regarding the use (and purposes of that use) by “Personnel” (as defined within the Data Sharing Framework Contract ie: employees, agents and contractors of the Data Recipient who may have access to that data).
Expected output
The expected output includes completion of a scientific paper detailing robust risk estimates of the incidence of perinatal outcomes in children born after ART. Data analysis for this is currently underway and the manuscript is expected to be ready for submission by mid-2023. It is expected that this paper will be submitted to a broad medical peer-reviewed journal which may or may not be subscription only; however, abstracts of this work will be open access. The primary audience for these papers will be a scientific/ clinical audience, in order for clinicians to disseminate results to their service users. It is not possible to say exactly which journal will be the appropriate one for submission of these reports as this depends to some extent on the results of the study. However, previous findings from this study have been published in BMJ Open and the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, and it is expected that this report will also be submitted to a journal of similar quality and impact factor.
Findings will also be presented at the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology conference.
Additionally, the findings of this study will also be disseminated via a study website (https://liftresearchucl.com/)
Finally, a report detailing study findings will be prepared and submitted to the HFEA upon completion of all planned data analyses (target date early 2024).
Expected measurable benefits
With 2% of babies now born through ART every year, this research is important for those babies, their mothers and those parents considering ART, the clinicians that treat these patients and the healthcare system as a whole. There are still many questions over the best ART methods and the long term health outcomes for these children. This study will benefit patients and the healthcare system by providing robust analysis to help remove some of these uncertainties.
This research has clear public benefits and its outcomes will significantly add to the currently very limited body of research in this area.
The results will be used to provide information to ART stakeholder groups, including fertility experts, patients wishing to undergo ART, children born after ART and their families and public health workers.
Benefits from this study will include robust risk estimates for children born after assisted conception in comparison to both control groups (spontaneously conceived siblings and spontaneously conceived unrelated children). This information is crucial for;
i. counselling of families of children born after assisted conception
ii. couples who wish to have assisted conception
iii. informing practitioners of any increased health risks enabling early diagnosis
iv. future health service planning for this population
Benefits reported so far
Initial data analysis has been completed and a cohort profile paper has been published in BMJ Open (10.1136/bmjopen-2021-050931). The creation of this cohort will allow longitudinal monitoring of health and also facilitate exploration of additional outcomes through further linkages in the future.
Analysis of general health outcomes and hospital admissions has also been completed and published in the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology (DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajog.2022.07.032). The findings of this study showed that children born after ART were more likely to be hospitalized compared to those that are naturally conceived, with possible explanations including parental factors including underlying subfertility and increased concern. The initial findings of this study were presented at the Royal College of Pediatrics and Child Health conference in 2021 and the International Population Data Linkage Network conference in 2022. Additionally, the findings have also been presented at various in-house symposia and seminars held within UCL and also shared via the study website (https://liftresearchucl.com).
Analysis for a third paper comparing perinatal outcomes has also been completed and is currently undergoing peer review at BMJ Medicine. The findings of this paper showed that ART-conceived children showed modest increases in the risk of hospital admissions for conditions originating in the perinatal period when compared to the controls. Analysis by treatment type showed that frozen embryo transfers (ET) were associated with a reduced risk compared to those born from fresh ET, whilst being conceived via ICSI compared to IVF without ICSI had little impact.
Analysis for two additional papers are now currently underway. The first compares the risk of birth defects between ART-conceived children and naturally conceived controls, while the second aims to compare the risk of autism spectrum disorders and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder between ART and NC children. We expect these manuscripts to be ready for submission later this year.
The findings of these analyses will allow UCL to contextualize levels and trends of disease burden and hospitalization, contribute to prevention and targeted intervention efforts through risk stratification and identification of at-risk individuals or families, develop a better understanding of prognosis, contribute to policy development in the UK, inform existing health services, and allow wider health system resource planning and anticipation of future health resource needs.
Datasets on the current version
Legal basis for provision: Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(2)(a); Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(2)(a); Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(7)
| Dataset | Type of data | Sensitivity | Frequency | Confidential data |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Civil Registration - Births | Anonymised - ICO Code Compliant | Non-Sensitive | One-Off | Section 251 NHS Act 2006 |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Accident and Emergency (HES A and E) | Anonymised - ICO Code Compliant | Non-Sensitive | One-Off | Section 251 NHS Act 2006 |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC) | Anonymised - ICO Code Compliant | Non-Sensitive | One-Off | Section 251 NHS Act 2006 |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Critical Care (HES Critical Care) | Anonymised - ICO Code Compliant | Non-Sensitive | One-Off | Section 251 NHS Act 2006 |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP) | Anonymised - ICO Code Compliant | Non-Sensitive | One-Off | Section 251 NHS Act 2006 |
| MRIS - Bespoke | Anonymised - ICO Code Compliant | Non-Sensitive | One-Off | Section 251 NHS Act 2006 |
Files released
Files released counts only files released externally by DARS. Access granted in NHS England's own systems, such as its Secure Data Environment, is not included.
Patient opt-outs were applied to the one file released under this agreement. About opt-outs
No files recorded as released under the current version. 1 was released under earlier versions, shown in the version history.
Version history
The register lists each renewal of this agreement as a separate row. This site has 5 versions — earlier versions existed before this site's records begin.
DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v6.3 26 February 2024 to 25 February 2027
- Title
- General Health & Hospital Admissions in Children Born after ART; A Population Based Linkage Study
- Commercial
- No
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 6
- Files released
- 0
Datasets: Civil Registration - Births; Hospital Episode Statistics Accident and Emergency (HES A and E); Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC); Hospital Episode Statistics Critical Care (HES Critical Care); Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP); MRIS - Bespoke
What changed from DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v5.2
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Start date | 2024-02-26 | |
| End date | 2027-02-25 |
Objective for processing
[4 paragraphs unchanged]
No amendments to the research design, methodology or the scientific value of the study have been made since this was last reviewed by IGARD and NHS England.
[25 paragraphs unchanged]
Processing activities
[25 paragraphs unchanged] Amazon Web Services provides cloud hosting services to UCL and will store the data as contracted by UCL. UCL uses offsite data centre services provided by VIRTUS data centre. [2 paragraphs unchanged]
Benefits reported
This project has already produced the benefit of linking cohort members and their mothers, which has also enabled restricted access to more reliable identifiers of cohort members than was originally available from the HFEA. As per original data sharing agreement, these identifiers are currently being held by NHS England securely, but would allow future researchers to undertake important linkage work not possible before this project (when only very limited cohort identifiers were held by the HFEA despite their mandate to collect such comprehensive data). Such future access is subject to approvals from HFEA, CAG, HRA and NHS England. UCL have no access to this data.
Initial data analysis has been completed and a cohort profile paper has been published in BMJ Open (10.1136/bmjopen-2021-050931).
Creation
The creation
of this cohort will allow longitudinal monitoring of health and also facilitate exploration of additional outcomes through further linkages in the future.
Analysis of general health outcomes and hospital admissions has also been completed and
a manuscript has been submitted to
published in
the American Journal of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology and is currently undergoing peer review.
Gynecology (DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajog.2022.07.032).
The findings of this study showed that children born after ART were
[25 words unchanged]
initial findings of this study were presented at the Royal College of
Paediatrics
Pediatrics
and Child Health conference in 2021 and the International Population Data Linkage
[16 words unchanged]
seminars held within UCL and also shared via the study website (https://liftresearchucl.com).
Analysis for the third paper comparing perinatal outcomes is currently underway. Manuscript preparation has commenced and an initial draft has been shared with team members for feedback. UCL expect it to be ready for submission to a journal by mid-2023.
Analysis for a third paper comparing perinatal outcomes has also been completed and is currently undergoing peer review at BMJ Medicine. The findings of this paper showed that ART-conceived children showed modest increases in the risk of hospital admissions for conditions originating in the perinatal period when compared to the controls. Analysis by treatment type showed that frozen embryo transfers (ET) were associated with a reduced risk compared to those born from fresh ET, whilst being conceived via ICSI compared to IVF without ICSI had little impact.
Analysis for two additional papers are now currently underway. The first compares the risk of birth defects between ART-conceived children and naturally conceived controls, while the second aims to compare the risk of autism spectrum disorders and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder between ART and NC children. We expect these manuscripts to be ready for submission later this year.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Unchanged: Expected output, Expected measurable benefits.
DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v5.2 21 June 2023 to 9 July 2024
- Title
- General Health & Hospital Admissions in Children Born after ART; A Population Based Linkage Study
- Commercial
- No
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 6
- Files released
- 0
Datasets: Civil Registration - Births; Hospital Episode Statistics Accident and Emergency (HES A and E); Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC); Hospital Episode Statistics Critical Care (HES Critical Care); Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP); MRIS - Bespoke
What changed from DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v4.5
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Title | General Health & Hospital Admissions in Children Born after ART; A Population Based Linkage Study | |
| Start date | 2023-06-21 | |
| End date | 2024-07-09 | |
| Civil Registration - Births: legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(2)(a) | |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Accident and Emergency (HES A and E): legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(2)(a) | |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC): legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(2)(a) | |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Critical Care (HES Critical Care): legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(2)(a) | |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP): legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(2)(a) | |
| MRIS - Bespoke: legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(2)(a); Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(7) |
Objective for processing
University College London (UCL)
are requesting
requires
access to data on maternal age at the time of birth for
[13 words unchanged]
related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls.
[2 paragraphs unchanged]
UCL are requesting an extension of the agreement to allow further time to process this data.
This project has already yielded the three cohorts mentioned above, and initial data management has been completed.
However, due to the poor data quality of the maternal age at the time of birth data on the Hospital Episode Statistics dataset (>50% missing data), further data processing has been delayed considerably.
No amendments to the research design, methodology or the scientific value of the study have been made since this was last reviewed by IGARD and NHS
Digital.
England.
The legal basis for processing personal data for this purpose data at UCL falls under Article 6(1)(e) of the General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR), i.e. “a task carried out in the public interest”. It also falls under Article 9(2)(j), “processing is necessary for archiving purposes in the public interest, scientific or historical research purposes or statistical purposes”. It is in the public interest because the programme of research facilitates the conduct of clinically relevant research into establishing if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
UCL is the controller as the organisation responsible for ensuring that the data will only be processed for the purpose described above.
UCL are the sole Data Controller who also process data.
The lawful basis for processing personal data under the UK GDPR is:
UCL (Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health) wish to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
Article 6(1)(e) - processing is necessary for the performance of a task carried out in the public interest or in the exercise of official authority vested in the controller;
The lawful basis for processing special category data under the UK GDPR is:
Article 9(2)(j) - processing is necessary for archiving purposes in the public interest, scientific or historical research purposes or statistical purposes in accordance with Article 89(1) based on Union or Member State law which shall be proportionate to the aim pursued, respect the essence of the right to data protection and provide for suitable and specific measures to safeguard the fundamental rights and the interests of the data subject.
It is in the public interest because the programme of research facilitates the conduct of clinically relevant research into establishing if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
Amazon Web Services (AWS) is a processor acting under the instructions of UCL. AWS’ role is limited to secure back-up of data stored in UCL’s Data Safe Haven.
UCL uses offsite data centre services provided by VIRTUS data centre. VIRTUS does not have access to the data.
UCL (Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health) aim to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
[13 paragraphs unchanged]
UCL
is
does
not
requesting
require
identifiable data from NHS
Digital
England
and will not pass any data on to third parties, including the HFEA.
[2 paragraphs unchanged]
Processing activities
[2 paragraphs unchanged]
1. NHS
Digital
England
will link the Civil Registration – Births dataset to the three study
[10 words unchanged]
related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls).
2. NHS
Digital
England
will disseminate the ‘Maternal age at time of birth’ data field with the unique study ID for members of the three study cohorts to UCL.
3. UCL will match this data with the previously disseminated data from NHS
Digital,
England,
via the unique study ID, for inclusion in the analysis.
[5 paragraphs unchanged]
1. NHS
Digital (NHSD)
England (NHSE)
produces an extract of women who were treated with ART (produced from MR1208)
2.
NHSD
NHSE
sends extract containing mothers details to ONS to match to births
3. ONS matches mothers to all births (ART children and non-ART siblings) and returns matched births to
NHSD
NHSE
4. HFEA sends
NHSD
NHSE
HFEA births (containing unique ID number)
5.
NHSD
NHSE
matches HFEA births (to ONS births and creates ART Cohort)
6.
NHSD
NHSE
sends the ART Cohort to ONS who return two controls for each member, creating the Control Cohort. The control cohort was matched for age, sex and multiplicity.
7.
NHSD
NHSE
links all remaining ONS births that match to HFEA mothers and creates Sibling Cohort.
8.
NHSD
NHSE
sends member numbers of all unmatched HFEA births to UCL.
9.
NHD
NHE
links ART, Sibling and Control Cohorts to ONS mortality and HES data and removes identifiers
10.
NHSD
NHSE
supplies de-identified data to UCL along with a deprivation score and unique study ID (this study ID cannot be used by UCL to re-identify).
[2 paragraphs unchanged]
The final de-identified data-set is held securely at UCL, using UCL's data safe haven. This storage meets requirements under
NHS-Digital's
NHS England's
Data Security and Protection Toolkit (DSPT)
[2 paragraphs unchanged]
Amazon Web Services provides cloud hosting services to UCL and will store the data as contracted by UCL.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
NHS
Digital
England
reminds all organisations party to this agreement of the need to comply
[31 words unchanged]
contractors of the Data Recipient who may have access to that data).
Expected output
The expected output includes completion of a scientific paper detailing robust risk
[18 words unchanged]
underway and the manuscript is expected to be ready for submission by
the end of 2022.
mid-2023.
It is expected that this paper will be submitted to a broad
[102 words unchanged]
also be submitted to a journal of similar quality and impact factor.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Additionally, the findings of this study will also be disseminated via a study
website. This is currently under development and is expected to be completed by October 2022.
website (https://liftresearchucl.com/)
Finally, a report detailing study findings will be prepared and submitted to the HFEA upon completion of all planned data analyses (target date early
2023).
2024).
Benefits reported
This project has already produced the benefit of linking cohort members and
[23 words unchanged]
per original data sharing agreement, these identifiers are currently being held by
NHS-Digital
NHS England
securely, but would allow future researchers to undertake important linkage work not
[23 words unchanged]
Such future access is subject to approvals from HFEA, CAG, HRA and
NHS-Digital.
NHS England.
UCL have no access to this data. Initial data analysis has been
[24 words unchanged]
also facilitate exploration of additional outcomes through further linkages in the future.
Analysis of general health outcomes and hospital admissions has also been completed
[65 words unchanged]
the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health conference in 2021 and
will also presented at
the International Population Data Linkage Network conference
to be
in 2022. Additionally, the findings have also been presented at various in-house symposia and seminars
held
later this year. Analysis for
within UCL and also shared via
the
third paper comparing perinatal outcomes is currently underway and will be submitted for publication later this year.
study website (https://liftresearchucl.com).
Analysis for the third paper comparing perinatal outcomes is currently underway. Manuscript preparation has commenced and an initial draft has been shared with team members for feedback. UCL expect it to be ready for submission to a journal by mid-2023.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Unchanged: Expected measurable benefits.
Objective for processing
University College London (UCL) requires access to data on maternal age at the time of birth for the existing study cohorts, consisting of children conceived after Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls.
Maternal age at the time of birth has been shown to significantly influence health outcomes in children. For example, several studies have shown that teenage pregnancies often result in infants with lower birth-weight, a greater risk of intrauterine growth restriction, preterm delivery and other adverse outcomes. While older maternal age is often associated with increased risk of preterm delivery, abnormal foetal presentation (such as spontaneous breech presentation), neonatal intraventricular haemorrhage, and increased risk of maternal cardiometabolic disease.
The aim of the study is to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls. Therefore, in this context, adjustment for key confounding factors such as maternal age at the time of birth is essential, particularly when analysing differences between ART and naturally conceived children in order to elucidate relative contribution of ART treatments and parental characteristics towards perinatal risks.
This project has already yielded the three cohorts mentioned above, and initial data management has been completed.
No amendments to the research design, methodology or the scientific value of the study have been made since this was last reviewed by IGARD and NHS England.
UCL is the controller as the organisation responsible for ensuring that the data will only be processed for the purpose described above.
The lawful basis for processing personal data under the UK GDPR is:
Article 6(1)(e) - processing is necessary for the performance of a task carried out in the public interest or in the exercise of official authority vested in the controller;
The lawful basis for processing special category data under the UK GDPR is:
Article 9(2)(j) - processing is necessary for archiving purposes in the public interest, scientific or historical research purposes or statistical purposes in accordance with Article 89(1) based on Union or Member State law which shall be proportionate to the aim pursued, respect the essence of the right to data protection and provide for suitable and specific measures to safeguard the fundamental rights and the interests of the data subject.
It is in the public interest because the programme of research facilitates the conduct of clinically relevant research into establishing if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
Amazon Web Services (AWS) is a processor acting under the instructions of UCL. AWS’ role is limited to secure back-up of data stored in UCL’s Data Safe Haven.
UCL uses offsite data centre services provided by VIRTUS data centre. VIRTUS does not have access to the data.
UCL (Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health) aim to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
The diagnoses which are to be investigated include:
a) Complications of Prematurity (such as respiratory distress syndrome, necrotizing enterocolitis, retinopathy of prematurity, intra-ventricular haemorrahges, per-ventricular leucomalacia)
b) Cerebral palsy
c) Congenital malformations
d) Asthma and allergic disease
e) Developmental delay/ and neuro-developmental problems
f) Death
g) Hospitalization rates and length of stay
These comparisons will help to provide robust risk estimates for this ever growing population. This is important as all of these potential risks have been suggested by previous research but have never been confirmed, as previous studies lacked the necessary power and design to do so.
The study cohorts, Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls, have been created using the criteria described in section 5b. The cohort numbers are 86,000 (ART Cohort), 23,000 (Sibling Cohort), and 172,000 (Controls Cohort).
Pseudonymised Hospital Episodes Statistics (HES) datasets (Outpatients, Admitted Patient care, Critical Care and A&E) and ONS mortality for the three study cohorts have been disseminated to UCL under a previous version of this agreement.
Manipulations carried out during ART treatment, including both supra-physiological ovarian stimulation and the manipulation of gametes and embryos in vitro, may lead to an increased risk of various adverse health outcomes in children born after ART. The Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) national database will be used to examine general health outcomes & hospital admissions (with an emphasis on long-term health outcomes e.g. burdens of peri-natal complications) in the three cohorts. Primary analyses will consider hospital admissions and recorded diagnoses, and further analyses will consider multiple admissions, length of stay and recorded medical interventions, stratifying for specific cause of infertility and type or means of assisted conception and whether conception arose from a fresh or frozen thawed embryo. Output variables will include all-cause and cause specific hospital admissions and recorded diagnoses, including all-cause and cause specific perinatal morbidity, congenital anomalies, cerebral palsy and epilepsy.
The rates of specific diagnoses will be compared to equivalent rates in both the matched and sibling control groups. In the first instance this will consider conditions chosen a priori including: Complications of Prematurity (Respiratory Distress Syndrome, Necrotising Enterocolitis, Retinopathy of Prematurity, Intra-ventricular Haemorrhage, Peri-ventricular Leucomalacia), Cerebral Palsy, Congenital malformations, Asthma, Allergic disease. Further analysis will consider multiple admissions, length of stay and recorded medical interventions. Subgroup analyses will stratify for duration and cause of parental infertility and type of ART (including fresh vs. cryopreserved cycles).
UCL does not require identifiable data from NHS England and will not pass any data on to third parties, including the HFEA.
Fertility clinics have been engaged in a campaign to inform patients of how their data may be used for research and how they could opt out. Families connected to ART have been consulted on what they would like research to achieve. These service user views are incorporated in UCL's study design.
This study is currently funded by the Wellcome Trust via an Individual Investigator Award in Science. The Wellcome Trust has no role in the design or conduct of the study, and will not be processing or accessing any data.
Expected output
The expected output includes completion of a scientific paper detailing robust risk estimates of the incidence of perinatal outcomes in children born after ART. Data analysis for this is currently underway and the manuscript is expected to be ready for submission by mid-2023. It is expected that this paper will be submitted to a broad medical peer-reviewed journal which may or may not be subscription only; however, abstracts of this work will be open access. The primary audience for these papers will be a scientific/ clinical audience, in order for clinicians to disseminate results to their service users. It is not possible to say exactly which journal will be the appropriate one for submission of these reports as this depends to some extent on the results of the study. However, previous findings from this study have been published in BMJ Open and the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, and it is expected that this report will also be submitted to a journal of similar quality and impact factor.
Findings will also be presented at the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology conference.
Additionally, the findings of this study will also be disseminated via a study website (https://liftresearchucl.com/)
Finally, a report detailing study findings will be prepared and submitted to the HFEA upon completion of all planned data analyses (target date early 2024).
Benefits reported
This project has already produced the benefit of linking cohort members and their mothers, which has also enabled restricted access to more reliable identifiers of cohort members than was originally available from the HFEA. As per original data sharing agreement, these identifiers are currently being held by NHS England securely, but would allow future researchers to undertake important linkage work not possible before this project (when only very limited cohort identifiers were held by the HFEA despite their mandate to collect such comprehensive data). Such future access is subject to approvals from HFEA, CAG, HRA and NHS England. UCL have no access to this data. Initial data analysis has been completed and a cohort profile paper has been published in BMJ Open (10.1136/bmjopen-2021-050931). Creation of this cohort will allow longitudinal monitoring of health and also facilitate exploration of additional outcomes through further linkages in the future.
Analysis of general health outcomes and hospital admissions has also been completed and a manuscript has been submitted to the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology and is currently undergoing peer review. The findings of this study showed that children born after ART were more likely to be hospitalized compared to those that are naturally conceived, with possible explanations including parental factors including underlying subfertility and increased concern. The initial findings of this study were presented at the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health conference in 2021 and the International Population Data Linkage Network conference in 2022. Additionally, the findings have also been presented at various in-house symposia and seminars held within UCL and also shared via the study website (https://liftresearchucl.com).
Analysis for the third paper comparing perinatal outcomes is currently underway. Manuscript preparation has commenced and an initial draft has been shared with team members for feedback. UCL expect it to be ready for submission to a journal by mid-2023.
The findings of these analyses will allow UCL to contextualize levels and trends of disease burden and hospitalization, contribute to prevention and targeted intervention efforts through risk stratification and identification of at-risk individuals or families, develop a better understanding of prognosis, contribute to policy development in the UK, inform existing health services, and allow wider health system resource planning and anticipation of future health resource needs.
DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v4.5 17 August 2022 to 9 July 2023
- Title
- MR1318 - General Health & Hospital Admissions in Children Born after ART; A Population Based Linkage Study
- Commercial
- No
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 6
- Files released
- 0
Datasets: Civil Registration - Births; Hospital Episode Statistics Accident and Emergency (HES A and E); Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC); Hospital Episode Statistics Critical Care (HES Critical Care); Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP); MRIS - Bespoke
What changed from DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v3.4
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Start date | 2022-08-17 | |
| End date | 2023-07-09 | |
| Civil Registration - Births: legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 - s261(5)(d) | |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Accident and Emergency (HES A and E): legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 - s261(5)(d) | |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC): legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 - s261(5)(d) | |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Critical Care (HES Critical Care): legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 - s261(5)(d) | |
| Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP): legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 - s261(5)(d) | |
| MRIS - Bespoke: legal basis | Health and Social Care Act 2012 - s261(5)(d); Health and Social Care Act 2012 – s261(7) |
Objective for processing
[3 paragraphs unchanged]
Additionally,
UCL are
also
requesting
a one-year
an
extension of the agreement to allow further time to process this
data, once it has been made available.
data.
This project has already yielded the three cohorts mentioned above, and initial
[26 words unchanged]
Statistics dataset (>50% missing data), further data processing has been delayed considerably.
Therefore, UCL now request access to this variable only from the birth registrations dataset for the three study cohorts, along with an extension that will allow UCL the time to carry out the further data processing.
[14 paragraphs unchanged]
Psuedonymised
Pseudonymised
Hospital Episodes Statistics (HES) datasets (Outpatients, Admitted Patient care, Critical Care and
[9 words unchanged]
have been disseminated to UCL under a previous version of this agreement.
[5 paragraphs unchanged]
Processing activities
[1 paragraph unchanged]
The following
new
processing activities
are required:
have been completed:
[4 paragraphs unchanged]
NHS Digital are now the data controller for the Civil Registration Births dataset were previously this was controlled by the Office of National Statistics (ONS).
[4 paragraphs unchanged]
1.
NHSD
NHS Digital (NHSD)
produces an extract of women who were treated with ART (produced from MR1208)
[11 paragraphs unchanged]
The final de-identified data-set is held securely at UCL, using UCL's data safe haven. This storage
has IG approval from NHS-Digital via
meets requirements under NHS-Digital's
Data Security and Protection Toolkit (DSPT)
[4 paragraphs unchanged]
Expected output
Outputs will contain only aggregate level data with small numbers suppressed in line with the HES analysis guidance.
The expected output includes completion of a scientific paper detailing robust risk estimates of the incidence of perinatal outcomes in children born after ART. Data analysis for this is currently underway and the manuscript is expected to be ready for submission by the end of 2022. It is expected that this paper will be submitted to a broad medical peer-reviewed journal which may or may not be subscription only; however, abstracts of this work will be open access. The primary audience for these papers will be a scientific/ clinical audience, in order for clinicians to disseminate results to their service users. It is not possible to say exactly which journal will be the appropriate one for submission of these reports as this depends to some extent on the results of the study. However, previous findings from this study have been published in BMJ Open and the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, and it is expected that this report will also be submitted to a journal of similar quality and impact factor.
The expected outputs from this project include a number of scientific papers, detailing robust risk estimates for the outcomes under investigation (including hospitalization incidence, and incidence of specific diagnoses). It is expected these papers will be submitted by early 2021 and published shortly afterwards.
It is expected that these papers will be submitted to broad medical peer-reviewed journals which may or may not be subscription only, however abstracts of this work will be open access. The main audience for these papers will be a scientific/ clinical audience, in order that clinicians disseminate results to their service users.
Additionally the study will produce a report for the HFEA to publish open access on their website and disseminate via their networks (the fertility clinics, clinicians and directly to patients via these clinics and their website) aiming for September 2021.
It is aimed to also submit abstracts to the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health to further publicise results.
It is not possible to say exactly which journal will be the appropriate one for submission of these reports as this depends to some extent to the results the study will find. However, it is expected that these will be high quality journals. For example, work previously done linking this dataset to national cancer registries was published by the New England Journal of Medicine which has the highest impact factor of any medical journal (impact factor 59.6). (http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1301675#t=article). Further work undertaken in partnership with NHS-Digital is due to be published in the BMJ.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Additionally, the findings of this study will also be disseminated via a study website. This is currently under development and is expected to be completed by October 2022.
Finally, a report detailing study findings will be prepared and submitted to the HFEA upon completion of all planned data analyses (target date early 2023).
Benefits reported
The receipt of all data and data linkage processes have taken much longer than expected. The main benefits will be delivered once the dataset is analysed and outputs are produced.
This project has already produced the benefit of linking cohort members and their mothers, which has also enabled restricted access to more reliable identifiers of cohort members than was originally available from the HFEA. As per original data sharing agreement, these identifiers are currently being held by NHS-Digital securely, but would allow future researchers to undertake important linkage work not possible before this project (when only very limited cohort identifiers were held by the HFEA despite their mandate to collect such comprehensive data). Such future access is subject to approvals from HFEA, CAG, HRA and NHS-Digital. UCL have no access to this data. Initial data analysis has been completed and a cohort profile paper has been published in BMJ Open (10.1136/bmjopen-2021-050931). Creation of this cohort will allow longitudinal monitoring of health and also facilitate exploration of additional outcomes through further linkages in the future.
This project has already produced the benefit of linking cohort members and their mothers, which has also enabled restricted access to more reliable identifiers of cohort members than was originally available from the HFEA. As per original data sharing agreement, these identifiers are currently being held by NHS-Digital securely, but would allow future researchers to undertake important linkage work not possible before this project (when only very limited cohort identifiers were held by the HFEA despite their mandate to collect such comprehensive data). Such future access is subject to approvals from HFEA, CAG, HRA and NHS-Digital. UCL have no access to this data.
Analysis of general health outcomes and hospital admissions has also been completed and a manuscript has been submitted to the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology and is currently undergoing peer review. The findings of this study showed that children born after ART were more likely to be hospitalized compared to those that are naturally conceived, with possible explanations including parental factors including underlying subfertility and increased concern. The initial findings of this study were presented at the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health conference in 2021 and will also presented at the International Population Data Linkage Network conference to be held later this year. Analysis for the third paper comparing perinatal outcomes is currently underway and will be submitted for publication later this year.
The findings of these analyses will allow UCL to contextualize levels and trends of disease burden and hospitalization, contribute to prevention and targeted intervention efforts through risk stratification and identification of at-risk individuals or families, develop a better understanding of prognosis, contribute to policy development in the UK, inform existing health services, and allow wider health system resource planning and anticipation of future health resource needs.
Unchanged: Expected measurable benefits.
Objective for processing
University College London (UCL) are requesting access to data on maternal age at the time of birth for the existing study cohorts, consisting of children conceived after Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls.
Maternal age at the time of birth has been shown to significantly influence health outcomes in children. For example, several studies have shown that teenage pregnancies often result in infants with lower birth-weight, a greater risk of intrauterine growth restriction, preterm delivery and other adverse outcomes. While older maternal age is often associated with increased risk of preterm delivery, abnormal foetal presentation (such as spontaneous breech presentation), neonatal intraventricular haemorrhage, and increased risk of maternal cardiometabolic disease.
The aim of the study is to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls. Therefore, in this context, adjustment for key confounding factors such as maternal age at the time of birth is essential, particularly when analysing differences between ART and naturally conceived children in order to elucidate relative contribution of ART treatments and parental characteristics towards perinatal risks.
UCL are requesting an extension of the agreement to allow further time to process this data. This project has already yielded the three cohorts mentioned above, and initial data management has been completed. However, due to the poor data quality of the maternal age at the time of birth data on the Hospital Episode Statistics dataset (>50% missing data), further data processing has been delayed considerably.
No amendments to the research design, methodology or the scientific value of the study have been made since this was last reviewed by IGARD and NHS Digital.
The legal basis for processing personal data for this purpose data at UCL falls under Article 6(1)(e) of the General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR), i.e. “a task carried out in the public interest”. It also falls under Article 9(2)(j), “processing is necessary for archiving purposes in the public interest, scientific or historical research purposes or statistical purposes”. It is in the public interest because the programme of research facilitates the conduct of clinically relevant research into establishing if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
UCL are the sole Data Controller who also process data.
UCL (Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health) wish to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
The diagnoses which are to be investigated include:
a) Complications of Prematurity (such as respiratory distress syndrome, necrotizing enterocolitis, retinopathy of prematurity, intra-ventricular haemorrahges, per-ventricular leucomalacia)
b) Cerebral palsy
c) Congenital malformations
d) Asthma and allergic disease
e) Developmental delay/ and neuro-developmental problems
f) Death
g) Hospitalization rates and length of stay
These comparisons will help to provide robust risk estimates for this ever growing population. This is important as all of these potential risks have been suggested by previous research but have never been confirmed, as previous studies lacked the necessary power and design to do so.
The study cohorts, Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls, have been created using the criteria described in section 5b. The cohort numbers are 86,000 (ART Cohort), 23,000 (Sibling Cohort), and 172,000 (Controls Cohort).
Pseudonymised Hospital Episodes Statistics (HES) datasets (Outpatients, Admitted Patient care, Critical Care and A&E) and ONS mortality for the three study cohorts have been disseminated to UCL under a previous version of this agreement.
Manipulations carried out during ART treatment, including both supra-physiological ovarian stimulation and the manipulation of gametes and embryos in vitro, may lead to an increased risk of various adverse health outcomes in children born after ART. The Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) national database will be used to examine general health outcomes & hospital admissions (with an emphasis on long-term health outcomes e.g. burdens of peri-natal complications) in the three cohorts. Primary analyses will consider hospital admissions and recorded diagnoses, and further analyses will consider multiple admissions, length of stay and recorded medical interventions, stratifying for specific cause of infertility and type or means of assisted conception and whether conception arose from a fresh or frozen thawed embryo. Output variables will include all-cause and cause specific hospital admissions and recorded diagnoses, including all-cause and cause specific perinatal morbidity, congenital anomalies, cerebral palsy and epilepsy.
The rates of specific diagnoses will be compared to equivalent rates in both the matched and sibling control groups. In the first instance this will consider conditions chosen a priori including: Complications of Prematurity (Respiratory Distress Syndrome, Necrotising Enterocolitis, Retinopathy of Prematurity, Intra-ventricular Haemorrhage, Peri-ventricular Leucomalacia), Cerebral Palsy, Congenital malformations, Asthma, Allergic disease. Further analysis will consider multiple admissions, length of stay and recorded medical interventions. Subgroup analyses will stratify for duration and cause of parental infertility and type of ART (including fresh vs. cryopreserved cycles).
UCL is not requesting identifiable data from NHS Digital and will not pass any data on to third parties, including the HFEA.
Fertility clinics have been engaged in a campaign to inform patients of how their data may be used for research and how they could opt out. Families connected to ART have been consulted on what they would like research to achieve. These service user views are incorporated in UCL's study design.
This study is currently funded by the Wellcome Trust via an Individual Investigator Award in Science. The Wellcome Trust has no role in the design or conduct of the study, and will not be processing or accessing any data.
Expected output
The expected output includes completion of a scientific paper detailing robust risk estimates of the incidence of perinatal outcomes in children born after ART. Data analysis for this is currently underway and the manuscript is expected to be ready for submission by the end of 2022. It is expected that this paper will be submitted to a broad medical peer-reviewed journal which may or may not be subscription only; however, abstracts of this work will be open access. The primary audience for these papers will be a scientific/ clinical audience, in order for clinicians to disseminate results to their service users. It is not possible to say exactly which journal will be the appropriate one for submission of these reports as this depends to some extent on the results of the study. However, previous findings from this study have been published in BMJ Open and the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, and it is expected that this report will also be submitted to a journal of similar quality and impact factor.
Findings will also be presented at the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology conference.
Additionally, the findings of this study will also be disseminated via a study website. This is currently under development and is expected to be completed by October 2022.
Finally, a report detailing study findings will be prepared and submitted to the HFEA upon completion of all planned data analyses (target date early 2023).
Benefits reported
This project has already produced the benefit of linking cohort members and their mothers, which has also enabled restricted access to more reliable identifiers of cohort members than was originally available from the HFEA. As per original data sharing agreement, these identifiers are currently being held by NHS-Digital securely, but would allow future researchers to undertake important linkage work not possible before this project (when only very limited cohort identifiers were held by the HFEA despite their mandate to collect such comprehensive data). Such future access is subject to approvals from HFEA, CAG, HRA and NHS-Digital. UCL have no access to this data. Initial data analysis has been completed and a cohort profile paper has been published in BMJ Open (10.1136/bmjopen-2021-050931). Creation of this cohort will allow longitudinal monitoring of health and also facilitate exploration of additional outcomes through further linkages in the future.
Analysis of general health outcomes and hospital admissions has also been completed and a manuscript has been submitted to the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology and is currently undergoing peer review. The findings of this study showed that children born after ART were more likely to be hospitalized compared to those that are naturally conceived, with possible explanations including parental factors including underlying subfertility and increased concern. The initial findings of this study were presented at the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health conference in 2021 and will also presented at the International Population Data Linkage Network conference to be held later this year. Analysis for the third paper comparing perinatal outcomes is currently underway and will be submitted for publication later this year.
The findings of these analyses will allow UCL to contextualize levels and trends of disease burden and hospitalization, contribute to prevention and targeted intervention efforts through risk stratification and identification of at-risk individuals or families, develop a better understanding of prognosis, contribute to policy development in the UK, inform existing health services, and allow wider health system resource planning and anticipation of future health resource needs.
DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v3.4 1 June 2020 to 9 July 2022
- Title
- MR1318 - General Health & Hospital Admissions in Children Born after ART; A Population Based Linkage Study
- Commercial
- No
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 6
- Files released
- 1
Datasets: Civil Registration - Births; Hospital Episode Statistics Accident and Emergency (HES A and E); Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC); Hospital Episode Statistics Critical Care (HES Critical Care); Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP); MRIS - Bespoke
What changed from DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v2.4
Text removed is struck through; text added is underlined. Unchanged paragraphs are summarised rather than repeated.
| Field | Was | Became |
|---|---|---|
| Start date | 2020-06-01 | |
| End date | 2022-07-09 |
Datasets: + Civil Registration - Births
Objective for processing
University College London (UCL) are requesting an extension to allow further time to process the data. Delays occurred in receiving all the required data at the start of the project which delayed the start of the planned data processing time. No amendments to the research design, methodology or the scientific value of the study have been made.
University College London (UCL) are requesting access to data on maternal age at the time of birth for the existing study cohorts, consisting of children conceived after Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls.
Maternal age at the time of birth has been shown to significantly influence health outcomes in children. For example, several studies have shown that teenage pregnancies often result in infants with lower birth-weight, a greater risk of intrauterine growth restriction, preterm delivery and other adverse outcomes. While older maternal age is often associated with increased risk of preterm delivery, abnormal foetal presentation (such as spontaneous breech presentation), neonatal intraventricular haemorrhage, and increased risk of maternal cardiometabolic disease.
The aim of the study is to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls. Therefore, in this context, adjustment for key confounding factors such as maternal age at the time of birth is essential, particularly when analysing differences between ART and naturally conceived children in order to elucidate relative contribution of ART treatments and parental characteristics towards perinatal risks.
Additionally, UCL are also requesting a one-year extension of the agreement to allow further time to process this data, once it has been made available. This project has already yielded the three cohorts mentioned above, and initial data management has been completed. However, due to the poor data quality of the maternal age at the time of birth data on the Hospital Episode Statistics dataset (>50% missing data), further data processing has been delayed considerably. Therefore, UCL now request access to this variable only from the birth registrations dataset for the three study cohorts, along with an extension that will allow UCL the time to carry out the further data processing.
No amendments to the research design, methodology or the scientific value of the study have been made since this was last reviewed by IGARD and NHS Digital.
The legal basis for processing personal data for this purpose data at UCL falls under Article 6(1)(e) of the General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR), i.e. “a task carried out in the public interest”. It also falls under Article 9(2)(j), “processing is necessary for archiving purposes in the public interest, scientific or historical research purposes or statistical purposes”. It is in the public interest because the programme of research facilitates the conduct of clinically relevant research into establishing if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
UCL are the sole Data Controller who also process data.
[10 paragraphs unchanged]
The study cohorts, Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls, have been created using the criteria described in section 5b. The cohort numbers are 86,000 (ART Cohort), 23,000 (Sibling Cohort), and 172,000 (Controls Cohort).
Psuedonymised Hospital Episodes Statistics (HES) datasets (Outpatients, Admitted Patient care, Critical Care and A&E) and ONS mortality for the three study cohorts have been disseminated to UCL under a previous version of this agreement.
Manipulations carried out during ART treatment, including both supra-physiological ovarian stimulation and the manipulation of gametes and embryos in vitro, may lead to an increased risk of various adverse health outcomes in children born after ART. The Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) national database will be used to examine general health outcomes & hospital admissions (with an emphasis on long-term health outcomes e.g. burdens of peri-natal complications) in the three cohorts. Primary analyses will consider hospital admissions and recorded diagnoses, and further analyses will consider multiple admissions, length of stay and recorded medical interventions, stratifying for specific cause of infertility and type or means of assisted conception and whether conception arose from a fresh or frozen thawed embryo. Output variables will include all-cause and cause specific hospital admissions and recorded diagnoses, including all-cause and cause specific perinatal morbidity, congenital anomalies, cerebral palsy and epilepsy.
The rates of specific diagnoses will be compared to equivalent rates in both the matched and sibling control groups. In the first instance this will consider conditions chosen a priori including: Complications of Prematurity (Respiratory Distress Syndrome, Necrotising Enterocolitis, Retinopathy of Prematurity, Intra-ventricular Haemorrhage, Peri-ventricular Leucomalacia), Cerebral Palsy, Congenital malformations, Asthma, Allergic disease. Further analysis will consider multiple admissions, length of stay and recorded medical interventions. Subgroup analyses will stratify for duration and cause of parental infertility and type of ART (including fresh vs. cryopreserved cycles).
[2 paragraphs unchanged]
This study is currently funded by the Wellcome Trust via an Individual Investigator Award in Science. The Wellcome Trust has no role in the design or conduct of the study, and will not be processing or accessing any data.
Processing activities
The ‘Maternal age at time of birth’ data request for the three study cohorts, is available in the Civil Registration – Births dataset.
The following new processing activities are required:
1. NHS Digital will link the Civil Registration – Births dataset to the three study cohorts (consisting of children conceived after Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls).
2. NHS Digital will disseminate the ‘Maternal age at time of birth’ data field with the unique study ID for members of the three study cohorts to UCL.
3. UCL will match this data with the previously disseminated data from NHS Digital, via the unique study ID, for inclusion in the analysis.
4. The processing activities and conditions stated in this section below continue to apply (as per the previous version of this agreement).
NHS Digital are now the data controller for the Civil Registration Births dataset were previously this was controlled by the Office of National Statistics (ONS).
The previous processing activities are stated below.
The data processing steps for creating the three study cohorts and dissemination the linked HES and ONS mortality is described below.
[7 paragraphs unchanged]
6. NHSD sends the ART Cohort to ONS who return two controls for each member, creating the Control Cohort.
The control cohort was matched for age, sex and multiplicity.
[6 paragraphs unchanged]
Numbers 1 to 10 have been completed under the previous agreement. UCL is currently in receipt of de-identified data and is in the process of extensive cleaning of these. Analysis is due to being shortly.
The final de-identified data-set is held securely at UCL, using UCL's data safe haven. This storage has IG approval from NHS-Digital via Data Security and Protection Toolkit (DSPT)
The final de-identified data-set is held securely at UCL, using UCL's data safe haven. This storage has IG approval from NHS-Digital via IG toolkit.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
ONS data will be processed in accordance to the standard Office for National Statistics terms and conditions.
[3 paragraphs unchanged]
Expected output
[1 paragraph unchanged]
The expected outputs from this project include a number of scientific papers,
[14 words unchanged]
of specific diagnoses). It is expected these papers will be submitted by
the end 2019
early 2021
and published shortly afterwards.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Additionally the study will produce a report for the HFEA to publish
[15 words unchanged]
directly to patients via these clinics and their website) aiming for September
2019 - 2 years after receiving data from NHS- Digital.
2021.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
It is not possible to say exactly which journal will be the
[14 words unchanged]
the results the study will find. However, it is expected that these
to
will
be high quality journals. For example, work previously done linking this dataset
[29 words unchanged]
undertaken in partnership with NHS-Digital is due to be published in the
BMJ this week.
BMJ.
[1 paragraph unchanged]
Unchanged: Expected measurable benefits, Benefits reported.
Objective for processing
University College London (UCL) are requesting access to data on maternal age at the time of birth for the existing study cohorts, consisting of children conceived after Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls.
Maternal age at the time of birth has been shown to significantly influence health outcomes in children. For example, several studies have shown that teenage pregnancies often result in infants with lower birth-weight, a greater risk of intrauterine growth restriction, preterm delivery and other adverse outcomes. While older maternal age is often associated with increased risk of preterm delivery, abnormal foetal presentation (such as spontaneous breech presentation), neonatal intraventricular haemorrhage, and increased risk of maternal cardiometabolic disease.
The aim of the study is to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls. Therefore, in this context, adjustment for key confounding factors such as maternal age at the time of birth is essential, particularly when analysing differences between ART and naturally conceived children in order to elucidate relative contribution of ART treatments and parental characteristics towards perinatal risks.
Additionally, UCL are also requesting a one-year extension of the agreement to allow further time to process this data, once it has been made available. This project has already yielded the three cohorts mentioned above, and initial data management has been completed. However, due to the poor data quality of the maternal age at the time of birth data on the Hospital Episode Statistics dataset (>50% missing data), further data processing has been delayed considerably. Therefore, UCL now request access to this variable only from the birth registrations dataset for the three study cohorts, along with an extension that will allow UCL the time to carry out the further data processing.
No amendments to the research design, methodology or the scientific value of the study have been made since this was last reviewed by IGARD and NHS Digital.
The legal basis for processing personal data for this purpose data at UCL falls under Article 6(1)(e) of the General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR), i.e. “a task carried out in the public interest”. It also falls under Article 9(2)(j), “processing is necessary for archiving purposes in the public interest, scientific or historical research purposes or statistical purposes”. It is in the public interest because the programme of research facilitates the conduct of clinically relevant research into establishing if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
UCL are the sole Data Controller who also process data.
UCL (Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health) wish to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
The diagnoses which are to be investigated include:
a) Complications of Prematurity (such as respiratory distress syndrome, necrotizing enterocolitis, retinopathy of prematurity, intra-ventricular haemorrahges, per-ventricular leucomalacia)
b) Cerebral palsy
c) Congenital malformations
d) Asthma and allergic disease
e) Developmental delay/ and neuro-developmental problems
f) Death
g) Hospitalization rates and length of stay
These comparisons will help to provide robust risk estimates for this ever growing population. This is important as all of these potential risks have been suggested by previous research but have never been confirmed, as previous studies lacked the necessary power and design to do so.
The study cohorts, Artificial Reproductive Therapies (ART), related spontaneously conceived sibling controls, and unrelated matched spontaneously conceived population controls, have been created using the criteria described in section 5b. The cohort numbers are 86,000 (ART Cohort), 23,000 (Sibling Cohort), and 172,000 (Controls Cohort).
Psuedonymised Hospital Episodes Statistics (HES) datasets (Outpatients, Admitted Patient care, Critical Care and A&E) and ONS mortality for the three study cohorts have been disseminated to UCL under a previous version of this agreement.
Manipulations carried out during ART treatment, including both supra-physiological ovarian stimulation and the manipulation of gametes and embryos in vitro, may lead to an increased risk of various adverse health outcomes in children born after ART. The Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) national database will be used to examine general health outcomes & hospital admissions (with an emphasis on long-term health outcomes e.g. burdens of peri-natal complications) in the three cohorts. Primary analyses will consider hospital admissions and recorded diagnoses, and further analyses will consider multiple admissions, length of stay and recorded medical interventions, stratifying for specific cause of infertility and type or means of assisted conception and whether conception arose from a fresh or frozen thawed embryo. Output variables will include all-cause and cause specific hospital admissions and recorded diagnoses, including all-cause and cause specific perinatal morbidity, congenital anomalies, cerebral palsy and epilepsy.
The rates of specific diagnoses will be compared to equivalent rates in both the matched and sibling control groups. In the first instance this will consider conditions chosen a priori including: Complications of Prematurity (Respiratory Distress Syndrome, Necrotising Enterocolitis, Retinopathy of Prematurity, Intra-ventricular Haemorrhage, Peri-ventricular Leucomalacia), Cerebral Palsy, Congenital malformations, Asthma, Allergic disease. Further analysis will consider multiple admissions, length of stay and recorded medical interventions. Subgroup analyses will stratify for duration and cause of parental infertility and type of ART (including fresh vs. cryopreserved cycles).
UCL is not requesting identifiable data from NHS Digital and will not pass any data on to third parties, including the HFEA.
Fertility clinics have been engaged in a campaign to inform patients of how their data may be used for research and how they could opt out. Families connected to ART have been consulted on what they would like research to achieve. These service user views are incorporated in UCL's study design.
This study is currently funded by the Wellcome Trust via an Individual Investigator Award in Science. The Wellcome Trust has no role in the design or conduct of the study, and will not be processing or accessing any data.
Expected output
Outputs will contain only aggregate level data with small numbers suppressed in line with the HES analysis guidance.
The expected outputs from this project include a number of scientific papers, detailing robust risk estimates for the outcomes under investigation (including hospitalization incidence, and incidence of specific diagnoses). It is expected these papers will be submitted by early 2021 and published shortly afterwards.
It is expected that these papers will be submitted to broad medical peer-reviewed journals which may or may not be subscription only, however abstracts of this work will be open access. The main audience for these papers will be a scientific/ clinical audience, in order that clinicians disseminate results to their service users.
Additionally the study will produce a report for the HFEA to publish open access on their website and disseminate via their networks (the fertility clinics, clinicians and directly to patients via these clinics and their website) aiming for September 2021.
It is aimed to also submit abstracts to the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health to further publicise results.
It is not possible to say exactly which journal will be the appropriate one for submission of these reports as this depends to some extent to the results the study will find. However, it is expected that these will be high quality journals. For example, work previously done linking this dataset to national cancer registries was published by the New England Journal of Medicine which has the highest impact factor of any medical journal (impact factor 59.6). (http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1301675#t=article). Further work undertaken in partnership with NHS-Digital is due to be published in the BMJ.
Findings will also be presented at the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology conference.
Benefits reported
The receipt of all data and data linkage processes have taken much longer than expected. The main benefits will be delivered once the dataset is analysed and outputs are produced.
This project has already produced the benefit of linking cohort members and their mothers, which has also enabled restricted access to more reliable identifiers of cohort members than was originally available from the HFEA. As per original data sharing agreement, these identifiers are currently being held by NHS-Digital securely, but would allow future researchers to undertake important linkage work not possible before this project (when only very limited cohort identifiers were held by the HFEA despite their mandate to collect such comprehensive data). Such future access is subject to approvals from HFEA, CAG, HRA and NHS-Digital. UCL have no access to this data.
DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v2.4 10 July 2018 to 9 July 2021
- Title
- MR1318 - General Health & Hospital Admissions in Children Born after ART; A Population Based Linkage Study
- Commercial
- No
- Sublicensing
- No
- Datasets
- 5
- Files released
- 0
Datasets: Hospital Episode Statistics Accident and Emergency (HES A and E); Hospital Episode Statistics Admitted Patient Care (HES APC); Hospital Episode Statistics Critical Care (HES Critical Care); Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatients (HES OP); MRIS - Bespoke
Objective for processing
University College London (UCL) are requesting an extension to allow further time to process the data. Delays occurred in receiving all the required data at the start of the project which delayed the start of the planned data processing time. No amendments to the research design, methodology or the scientific value of the study have been made.
UCL (Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health) wish to establish if children born after assisted conception (including IVF and related techniques) are at an increased risk of specific diagnoses compared to spontaneously conceived siblings and unrelated spontaneously conceived controls.
The diagnoses which are to be investigated include:
a) Complications of Prematurity (such as respiratory distress syndrome, necrotizing enterocolitis, retinopathy of prematurity, intra-ventricular haemorrahges, per-ventricular leucomalacia)
b) Cerebral palsy
c) Congenital malformations
d) Asthma and allergic disease
e) Developmental delay/ and neuro-developmental problems
f) Death
g) Hospitalization rates and length of stay
These comparisons will help to provide robust risk estimates for this ever growing population. This is important as all of these potential risks have been suggested by previous research but have never been confirmed, as previous studies lacked the necessary power and design to do so.
UCL is not requesting identifiable data from NHS Digital and will not pass any data on to third parties, including the HFEA.
Fertility clinics have been engaged in a campaign to inform patients of how their data may be used for research and how they could opt out. Families connected to ART have been consulted on what they would like research to achieve. These service user views are incorporated in UCL's study design.
Expected output
Outputs will contain only aggregate level data with small numbers suppressed in line with the HES analysis guidance.
The expected outputs from this project include a number of scientific papers, detailing robust risk estimates for the outcomes under investigation (including hospitalization incidence, and incidence of specific diagnoses). It is expected these papers will be submitted by the end 2019 and published shortly afterwards.
It is expected that these papers will be submitted to broad medical peer-reviewed journals which may or may not be subscription only, however abstracts of this work will be open access. The main audience for these papers will be a scientific/ clinical audience, in order that clinicians disseminate results to their service users.
Additionally the study will produce a report for the HFEA to publish open access on their website and disseminate via their networks (the fertility clinics, clinicians and directly to patients via these clinics and their website) aiming for September 2019 - 2 years after receiving data from NHS- Digital.
It is aimed to also submit abstracts to the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health to further publicise results.
It is not possible to say exactly which journal will be the appropriate one for submission of these reports as this depends to some extent to the results the study will find. However, it is expected that these to be high quality journals. For example, work previously done linking this dataset to national cancer registries was published by the New England Journal of Medicine which has the highest impact factor of any medical journal (impact factor 59.6). (http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1301675#t=article). Further work undertaken in partnership with NHS-Digital is due to be published in the BMJ this week.
Findings will also be presented at the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology conference.
Benefits reported
The receipt of all data and data linkage processes have taken much longer than expected. The main benefits will be delivered once the dataset is analysed and outputs are produced.
This project has already produced the benefit of linking cohort members and their mothers, which has also enabled restricted access to more reliable identifiers of cohort members than was originally available from the HFEA. As per original data sharing agreement, these identifiers are currently being held by NHS-Digital securely, but would allow future researchers to undertake important linkage work not possible before this project (when only very limited cohort identifiers were held by the HFEA despite their mandate to collect such comprehensive data). Such future access is subject to approvals from HFEA, CAG, HRA and NHS-Digital. UCL have no access to this data.
Register history
When this agreement appeared in, or was edited in, each monthly edition of the register. Built by comparing every edition this site holds, the earliest of which is July 2021.
-
July 2021 —
already listed in the earliest edition this site holds, so it may be older. 2 versions: DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v2.4, DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v3.4
-
September 2022
1 version added: DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v4.5
-
December 2022
Register-wide edit DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v2.4, DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v3.4 — Datasets: legal basis: “
s261(1) and” taken out. Made to 639 agreements in this edition, so it is reported once, on the changes page, and not counted as an amendment of this agreement. -
August 2023
1 version added: DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v5.2
-
March 2024
1 version added: DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5-v6.3
Cite this page
NHS England (2026) Data Uses Register, September 2026 edition, agreement DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5, “General Health & Hospital Admissions in Children Born after ART; A Population Based Linkage Study”. Read via NHS Data Access Explorer (unofficial), https://healthdatauses.uk/agreements/dars-nic-180665-gjmw5/ (accessed [date]).
This address stays the same, but the page is rebuilt with each monthly edition, so the citation names the edition it shows. Every edition's data is kept in the facts store.
Source: datausesregister_september2026.xlsx, September 2026 edition of the NHS England Data Uses Register. Search that workbook for DARS-NIC-180665-GJMW5 to see the original rows.